3 ms·
Reread what I said and note that I didn't say you were definitely wrong, only that it's inconsistent to treat two anecdotal accounts in completely opposite ways
by acdha 10y ago
Reread what I said and note that I didn't say you were definitely wrong, only that it's inconsistent to treat two anecdotal accounts in completely opposite ways. I'm entirely comfortable accepting that what you wrote is what you honestly believe but you're trying to argue that your limited personal experience represents an entire field so completely that everyone who says otherwise is either confused or lying.
If you want to convince anyone, post some actual data or peer-reviewed analysis. Otherwise it's just a question of whether this is garden variety argument from authority or some sort of stronger argument from Dunning-Kruger version.
- exstudent2 10y ago> it's inconsistent to treat two anecdotal accounts in completely opposite ways. I can either believe a random person on the internet peddling a rather trendy political opinion or my own extensive industry experience. I'd expect outsiders to treat both our claims with a grain of salt and instead use their own observations.
- acdha 10y agoTo anyone other than yourself, you are the “random person on the internet peddling a rather trendy political opinion”, especially since it's easy to find people with just as much industry experience who both disagree with your portrayal and have reasonable explanations for why you might not be aware of their experience.
- exstudent2 10y agoHence why I said: "I'd expect outsiders to treat both our claims with a grain of salt and instead use their own observations."