7 ms·
I smell a hit piece from a mile away. 18F has done a lot of good but in trying to change how government IT does business but they've also made powerful enemies
by rmason 10y ago
I smell a hit piece from a mile away. 18F has done a lot of good but in trying to change how government IT does business but they've also made powerful enemies who view them as a threat to their power base..
Find something that can be spun negatively and sell the story to a friendly journalist. That it what appears to have been done here. Next get the head of a budget committee to question 18F spending. It is all done behind the scenes and sadly 18F's strongest supporters are all leaving government.
- barney54 10y agoThe story is reporting on a report from GSA's Inspector General. It's straight reporting. Not a hit piece.
- jrockway 10y agoThe author comments that he doesn't like their new logo.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThe greater point is that 727 hours of staff time were spent on it.
- jrockway 10y agoIs that a lot of time for a logo redesign? I've spent more time brushing my teeth than that.
- striking 10y agoIf you're younger than 29.88 years old: no, you haven't. https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(727+hours+%2F+(4+minutes+per+day)+)+in+years https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(727+hours+%2F+(4+minu... This is assuming you've brushed your teeth for two minutes, twice a day, since the day you came out of the womb.
- brainfire 10y agoThat is a great point in favor of it being a hit piece, because that's wrong - rndmize pointed out below [0] that it's a misinterpretation of the report. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12862065 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12862065
- at-fates-hands 10y ago727 hours/10 hours a day = 72.7 days. roughly 22 working days per month. 72.7/22 = 3.3 months As far as logo design goes, this is actually pretty fast. Most companies I've dealt with stuff like this usually takes much, much longer depending on how picky the founders are.
- bovermyer 10y agoI paid $5 for a logo on Fiverr that took the artist about 3 days (general turnaround time, not active work time). To this day, I feel really bad about taking advantage of an artist like that.
- nashashmi 10y agoDivide 3.3 months across multiple people (say 5), and you get less than 3 weeks. Also worth mentioning is the $X million dollars spent on redesigning Merrill Lynch's logo. The only redesign that occurred was a different angle view of the lion.
- nashashmi 10y agoI too smell a hit piece. But I kept reading to figure out why. What got me thinking this was the statement about generating 22 million when there is a goal of 32 million. And that was after a year of zero revenue.
- sosuke 10y agoI was impressed with that too.
- noir_lord 10y agoThis happened in the UK with the GDS (which 18F is modelled closely on), they got savaged in the press by vested interests, it was pretty blatant tbh.
- conjectures 10y agoNow I don't think GDS walk on water, but their work really is much better than how things normally get done in the civil service. The press focussed on, "This bureaucrat paid market rate for in-demand skills! Disgusting!" Rather than, "In house experts save tax payer being ripped off again!"
- noir_lord 10y agoExactly, they aren't perfect (nothing is) but the work they've done by government standards is incredible and by commercial standards very good. They also worked really hard to get government departments to buy-in to modernising with some success. Current government is gutting them though.
- dasil003 10y agoThat is so depressing. I lived in London from 2011 through 2014, previously having no clue about GDS or anything else in the UK for that matter. Being a ruby developer, it kind of blew me away when I met so many GDS developers and saw what they were doing. They were operating like a top-tier commercial agency much moreso than anything that resembles government in my mind (and I'm half-brazilian, so US government to me is far from the worst in terms of inefficiency and boondoggles). Next thing you know they stop letting the non-white people in, and before you know it Berlin leapfrogs London as the primary tech destination in Europe.
- noir_lord 10y agoBut if you have an effective in house team you can't give the work to your dodgy mates/ benefactors... The UK has very civilised corruption.