4 ms·
> Data caps/tiers/metering is basically the only fair way to provide data service. "Unlimited" is inherently flawed as a product concept. It was proven time an
by shmerl 10y ago
> Data caps/tiers/metering is basically the only fair way to provide data service. "Unlimited" is inherently flawed as a product concept.
It was proven time and again that data caps are driven by greed, not by necessity. That's clear in wireline networks where congestion isn't a problem at all, and can be as well demonstrated in mobile ones, where spectrum limit can be an issue. Caps don't prevent network congestion in mobile networks. I.e. don't pretend it's a network management tool, it's not. It's just money gouging tool. So it has nothing to do with fairness.
ISPs already have tiers for bandwidth. There is no need to use caps as well.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoNonsense. If you believe the whole "driven by greed" drivel, you have never looked at how a business operates in your life. It's no more or less greedy than raising prices for everyone (which would otherwise happen). The difference is, data caps are a tax on the top 1% of users, rather than a tax on everyone.
- shmerl 10y agoNot true. Data caps apply to everyone, not to 1% of users. And they are driven by greed, not by expenses or technical necessity, because ISPs themselves don't spend more because of more traffic. And those who have that greed will find any way to fleece their users. Raising prices for everyone without need is exactly greed, but happens when competition isn't enough to put them in place. In other words it's a sick result of lack of competition. And trying to pretend it's about some "fairness", means supporting crooks and thinking being a crook is fair.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoAgain, it's clear you do not understand how any of this works. It has nothing to do with technical necessity, or even expenses of delivering a specific user's service. Your focus on that indicates you have no understanding of the market. An explanation of business economics is beyond the scope of what I can fit in a reasonable comment. This is a simplified example of how tiered pricing works in a business sense I wrote up a few weeks ago to explain it: https://plus.google.com/+JakeWeisz/posts/8dSeCHrzZpo https://plus.google.com/+JakeWeisz/posts/8dSeCHrzZpo
- shmerl 10y ago> It has nothing to do with technical necessity, or even expenses of delivering a specific user's service. Exactly my point. Therefore it's driven by greed, and is an indication of monopoly abuse. To repeat what I said. ISPs already have tired plans for _bandwidth_, and those who are heavier users can pay more for more bandwidth, which has technical necessity behind it. There is completely no need in caps. See https://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Senator-Wyden-ATT-Merger-Poses-Huge-Threat-to-Net-Neutrality-138247 https://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Senator-Wyden-ATT-Merger... > Your focus on that indicates you have no understanding of the market. I understand it. The only reason this garbage like caps and violation of Net Neutrality happens is lack of competition, and crooks taking advantage of that fact in the context of insufficient regulations to prevent them.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoNo, it's not "driven by greed", it's "driven by basic math". There's nothing abusive about asking people using your service to pay more than the people who use it the least. And it has nothing to do with "monopoly abuse", we have four (five-ish) national carriers as well as plenty of regional offerings. Mobile providers are the least monopolistic telecoms in the industry right now. The idea of paying for network speed is a poor one: It means the network is intentionally crippling their product when they can provide better, and they're under no obligation to even guarantee the speed you pay for. Paying for network speed is not good for the consumer. Paying for usage is the ideal situation, because the provider and the customer have aligned interests. It's in the best interest of the provider to provide the fastest, highest quality service, so that users can consume the most data. And consumers get the best possible product, without being intentionally gimped or throttled.
- shmerl 10y ago> No, it's not "driven by greed", it's "driven by basic math". Stop the demagoguery please. Calling greed "math" doesn't change it being greed. > Paying for usage is the ideal situation You sound like an ISP shill. Are you one? Paying for usage is horrendous, because ISPs who own media services disadvantage competing media services, by excluding their own from caps. This should be forbidden not just by Net Neutraility, but simply by antitrust law. But I suppose you think monopoly is ideal situation too, right? And you'd claim there is nothing wrong with "asking to pay more" because people have no choice but to use the abusive monopolist if they want service, and it's not greed but "basic math". Yeah, right. Arguing with shills is pointless though, so I finished here. Everything was said above already anyway.