4 ms·
Would anyone else here prefer a paper and pen ballot system? Computers are too easily hackable.
by pmoriarty 10y ago
Would anyone else here prefer a paper and pen ballot system?
Computers are too easily hackable.
- programmarchy 10y agoYep. Black box voting is wide open to fraud. Maybe if the code was open source, the firmware could be verified by a voter somehow, and there was some kind of blockchain system where every individual could verify their own vote... but otherwise I'd much rather have a paper trail.
- vidarh 10y agoI'd love both (paper receipts from an electronic system, that goes into ballot boxes; count the ballots and return the electronic records). But if I had to pick one, I'd pick paper. We know what to look for to spot fraud with paper ballots.
- greenyoda 10y agoIn NY, we fill in bubbles on paper forms with a pen, and then we feed our form into a scanner. So you get both an electronic tally of the vote and paper artifacts that can be re-counted (either by scanners or people) if there are any questions afterwards. When you scan your form, the machine informs you if it's invalid (duplicate candidates selected) or incomplete (no selection for an office), and you can try again. Before this we had ancient mechanical voting machines that would break down all the time (but made a very satisfying metallic clunk when you pulled the huge lever to register your vote).
- Houshalter 10y agoElectronic voting allows for superior voting systems like Condorcet methods, that are too expensive to implement by hand. My ideal system is two separate machines. One takes votes and prints them onto a paper ballot in OCR readable font. The voter can then inspect their ballot to make sure the machine didn't alter it, and then turn it in. Then another machine can read the ballots and table the votes. This machine doesn't need any kind of input other than paper ballots, and its easy to test it and verify it's working properly. This limits the surface area for attacks and tampering. The machine then outputs a big table of the pairwise election results for every single candidate. You add the tables from every single voting station, and the candidate that would win every pairwise election against every other candidate, wins the election.
- oh_sigh 10y agoYup...I support pen and paper(along with an observer system), exit polling, and voter ID. Probably the most objectionable of my points is voter ID, but I would be all for government spending whatever it took to make sure that all eligible citizens had an ID to vote.