6 ms·
I feel the same way. I want teams that are diverse and inclusive, because I think that's how you get both the best business results and the best society. One g
by wpietri 10y ago
I feel the same way. I want teams that are diverse and inclusive, because I think that's how you get both the best business results and the best society.
One good historical example is labor force inclusion of women. For centuries, women were excluded from most professions. Circa 1970, women got only 10% of law and medicine degrees. They hit parity in the mid-aughts. Are doctors or lawyers making less? No. The expanded pool of applicants means as a society we're getting either more or better doctors and lawyers, so as a society we're wealthier. And things are undeniably fairer. Economic and social incentives coincide.
- nitrogen 10y agoIt's important to remember that doctors and lawyers have professional organizations that try to ensure competence and limit supply.
- acdha 10y agoOr enforce preconceived views about who belonged in the field and discourage others — you don't have to go back very far to find those groups setting quotas on the number of Jewish doctors, for example: http://mobile.nytimes.com/2009/05/26/health/26quot.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2009/05/26/health/26quot.html
- FT_intern 10y ago> because I think that's how you get both the best business results I don't think this has ever been proven, especially not in a field as technical as software engineering.
- wpietri 10y agoVery few human practices in software engineering have been proven to any level of rigor. But still, you have to make choices. There is usually no neutral position. You have to pick a particular language, a particular platform, a particular process, a particular team. For me, the theory's pretty clear. The hard part about software is not the typing; it's the thinking. It's my experience that thought monocultures are less effective, so I always hire for diversity along many axes. I like having somebody with ops experience. Somebody else who loves the details of front-end work. Somebody else who has wrestled with deep optimizations. Young and old, functional and OO, careful and bold, etc, etc. I take as much variety as I can get, because the more diversity you have, the more problems you can spot and solve quickly. An especially hard part about software is thinking about users. Good developers are always imagining the effect their choices have on the people they serve. But our imagination is limited by our experiences. Our empathy comes most easily for people like the ones we know. The more diverse your team, the more likely you are to spot and solve human problems. So sure, it's not scientifically proven to be optimum. But the default isn't either. If we only question the things that seem novel, that's just a fancy way of arguing for a sort of generic orthodoxy.
- FT_intern 10y agoI agree that diversity in software perspectives/technologies/experiences is important. However I don't see how racial or gender diversity plays a role in that.
- wpietri 10y agoOk. I believe you don't see it. Many people don't. How can I help you with that?
- oldmanjay 10y agoYou could stop asserting it's true even though you have no evidence. I won't hold my breath.
- wpietri 10y agoI don't believe I asked you, but sure, jump on in. Is there a contrary assertion you would like to make and present evidence for? I'm all ears. I should point out I can't stop asserting it's true, because I never started doing that. I said "I feel [...] I want [...] I think [...] For me, the theory [is ...]". Did you really not understand I was expressing my educated opinion?
- moduspol 10y agoHistorically, most things done well have been by a group of like-minded people banding together to do something in a way that minimizes individuality and differences between them. They focus on a single vision and unite around it to become successful. You won't find a lot of studies on this because it's not a politically correct topic. Nobody wants to do the study that confirms you're better off just hiring whoever's the most qualified unless your customer base is dramatically different from your development team. I also feel like it's a false equivalency to suggest racial / gender diversity is in any way comparable to this: > I like having somebody with ops experience. Somebody else who loves the details of front-end work. Somebody else who has wrestled with deep optimizations. Those things actually relate to the work being done.
- krakensden 10y agoDoctors in the US capped the supply, so it isn't a great comparison. Law currently has an oversupply problem, with low wages for most lawyers.