7 ms·
In my experience, there's a difference between "how much suffering are you willing to take", and "how much suffering can you take". This race is interesting be
by hprotagonist 10y ago
In my experience, there's a difference between "how much suffering are you willing to take", and "how much suffering can you take".
This race is interesting because participants can stop whenever they want to -- and they know it. So there's a meta-contest happening for each participant. I have, on very long bicycle rides, found myself spending a lot of mental energy on knowing that I could stop any time.
This is not always true, even in recreational activities or endurance sports. I have been on climbs where there is no reasonable option for retreat and getting off the rock wall is actually a worse option than finishing the climb. Similarly, I've been on backpacking trips where weather and terrain dictate that the only reasonable course of action is to (for example) get off that ridge _now_.
In situations where I don't have the option of choice, I find I'm capable of a lot more.
- nugget 10y agoA friend from my Navy days told me the only way he survived BUD/S hell week was to mentally accept that he would either pass the course or freeze to death in the water.
- jacobolus 10y agoFor anyone else curious, BUD/S = Basic Underwater Demolition/SEAL, part of the US Navy’s special forces training. Considering the crazy life-threatening things special forces soldiers might be commanded to do in a real mission, weeding out anyone who doesn’t think like your friend is likely one of the main goals.
- overcast 10y agoActually SEAL's are Special Operations, US Army has the Special Forces designation. They are completely different in the context of the military.
- jacobolus 10y agoWikipedia: Special forces and special operations forces are military units trained to conduct special operations.[1][2][3] NATO defines special operations as "military activities conducted by specially designated, organized, trained, and equipped forces, manned with selected personnel, using unconventional tactics, techniques, and modes of employment".[4][1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_special_forces_units#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_special_force... > They are completely different From what I can tell “special operations” and “special forces” mean the same thing, as far as lay definitions of the generic terms are concerned. Here’s what Collins Dictionary says: “special forces: élite, highly trained military forces, specially selected to work on difficult missions”
- overcast 10y agoI'm just telling you how the military designates the branches.
- rhizome 10y agoSure, and it's useful as far as it goes (I didn't know precisely), but this isn't the military.
- mr_overalls 10y agoovercast is correct. "Special Forces", in the context of US military units, refers specifically to the Army's Green Berets. "Special Operations" is an umbrella term describing the high-trained, unconventional soldiers who serve in all branches of our military. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Forces_(United_States_Army) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Forces_(United_States_...
- bryondowd 10y agoTo be fair, that appears to be directed to a layman audience, possibly including non-US. In a general context like that, lower case 'special forces' can be assumed to be the generic term for the many international groups with a wide variety of official designations that fit similar loose criteria. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_forces
- andyjohnson0 10y ago"The first two weeks of basic conditioning prepare candidates for the third week, also known as "Hell Week." During Hell Week, candidates participate in five and a half days of continuous training. Each candidate sleeps at most four hours during the entire week, runs more than 200 miles, and does physical training for more than 20 hours per day." [1] Insane. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Navy_SEAL_selection_and_training https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Navy_SEAL_sele...
- barbs 10y agoThere's a neat 6-part series following one of the classes. Here's part 1 on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vi5LgsYCgKs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vi5LgsYCgKs
- Buttons840 10y agoSince we're talking about Navy Seals on a website about startups and business, I have to recommend this book: https://www.amazon.com/Extreme-Ownership-U-S-Navy-SEALs/dp/1250067057/ https://www.amazon.com/Extreme-Ownership-U-S-Navy-SEALs/dp/1...
- remarkEon 10y agoWhen I went through Ranger School there was a similar mentality. You learn pretty quickly about how far you can physically push yourself, but the real true test was how much you could endure mentally. Sleep deprivation combined with a low calorie diet and extremely taxing physical tasks, I would say, ends up attacking your mental abilities in a way it's difficult to prepare for. I was probably in the best shape of my life when I started (and the absolute worst when I graduated) but the fact that you could quit at any time meant that you had to dig elsewhere for motivation. I think more importantly than anything you learn about your own physiology or mental dedication, you learn how to motivate and lead people who are as broken or more so than yourself. So when people ask "why is it necessary to destroy people like this" that's why.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>I think more importantly than anything you learn about your own physiology or mental dedication, you learn how to motivate and lead people who are as broken or more so than yourself. So when people ask "why is it necessary to destroy people like this" that's why. Yes, because everyone knows that Suffering Makes Stronk. In fact, permanent damage to your physiology is nothing if you're stronk, and there's certainly no advantage to actually keeping healthy your whole life in performing difficult mental and physical tasks. /s
- scott_s 10y agoI think a charitable read of remarkEon's comment assumes he meant in the context of combat training, and not necessarily in preparation for life in general.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoI legitimately don't think that permanently injuring people makes them more ready for combat.
- scott_s 10y ago
- jhayward 10y agoOne of the best things I learned from my bike racing days was how to handle "you can quit any time". Once you accept something like "this is the part that sucks, if you just keep pedaling it will at some point not suck" it all gets better. In other words surrender to the moment, quit worrying about it, and just keep riding. Lots of life is like that.
- b_emery 10y agoThis comes up a lot in the accounts of navy seal training that I've read. The strategy is to just make it through the next few moments without letting your mind go to the future pain and suffering.
- kelvin0 10y agoI would like to read about that, can you suggest any links or books?
- zimpenfish 10y agoSame with marathons - my first (solo, unsupported, few escape points) was a lot "easier" to get through than the subsequent non-solo/supported/lapped ones purely because I just didn't have the (easy) option to quit.
- spiderfarmer 10y agoI participated in the Red Bull Dutch Extreme, a 3 day event. The winner of that event told the press that he's always able to continue after breaking down, simply because he wouldn't accept that he reached his limit. But, while that might sound inspiring and all, I personally found out that if you don't drink enough during events like that, your limits suddenly become very clear.
- taneq 10y agoI hate the "limits are all in your mind" mentality. Sure, maybe the limits in many peoples' minds kick in before their physical limits. Those limits are there for a reason, though - hitting physical limits has (often serious) physical consequences. In the extreme case you start to damage muscles, ligaments, organs. Your body is actually killing itself. It's like when people talk about "giving 110%" on a racetrack. You know how to spot the ones giving 110%? They've already crashed, because no amount of positive attitude is going to increase your tyres' coefficient of friction.
- hprotagonist 10y agominds have physical limits, too.
- baddox 10y agoThat's one thing I love about longer backpacking trips. I did the John Muir Trail this summer, with 18 days available. There are only a few feasible bailout opportunities, and virtually none in the last half (going southbound). I like the feeling that after a day or two you are essentially fully committed. Of course there are options in the case of injury or other emergency, but if you're just worn out and homesick (which definitely happened) your best option is to just keep chugging along. We ended up taking a full unplanned rest day in the middle, and still finished a day early.
- CydeWeys 10y agoThat's an excellent point. As one piece of anecdotal, I just got back this morning from three days spent hiking in the Grand Canyon. Despite taking twice as long and being on tired legs, the hike up on the third day was less mentally taxing than the hike down on the first day. Once you're in the Canyon you're fully committed, whereas when you're going down you can still bail for most of the way and end up with less total exertion.
- petertodd 10y agoI do cave exploration, and it can be an even more insidious version of that: in a vertical cave you rappel down to the bottom - a task that can require almost no exertion at all in some caves. Then once you turn around its vertical climbing all the way to the top, occasionally in very cold and wet conditions where stopping for any significant length of time can lead to hypothermia and death faster then you'd be rescued. Of course, good cavers know all this and take their limits into account! So it doesn't have to be as dangerous as it sounds, but God help you if you go in without knowing this. And sure enough, I usually find the most mentally hard part of caving to be going in, rather than coming out.
- CydeWeys 10y agoThe rule in the Grand Canyon is that each mile you hike down is 1.5-2X harder to hike back up, so you should turn back once you've given at most 33-40% of your available effort (or make plans to spend the night at the bottom). It sounds like that multiplier is way higher still in caving. 10X? More?
- petertodd 10y agoIt depends a _lot_ on the cave - some caves are pure horizontal crawling with equal effort in and out - but the worst case is pure rappels where you may literally do nothing more than lightly hold onto the brake end of the rope for an hour while you descend, followed by a grueling climb straight up. On top of that, the efficiency of ascending gear varies wildly: if you use an inappropriate setup - quite common with climbers who have no prior experience caving - you may be working 10x or more harder than someone with an appropriate setup. Basically the problem here, is the typical way climbers climb a rope is only suitable for very short climbs of 30-40ft, because you end up applying the force at a big angle relative to the rope; rather than pushing vertically up you wastefully push sideways. The vastly more efficient setups/equipment that cavers use allows you to push almost directly up while climbing up the rope.