5 ms·
He literally gave a case (from memory) about the industry being an early adopter of technology. Not every anecdote needs a citation. Where's your citation about
by unethical_ban 10y ago
He literally gave a case (from memory) about the industry being an early adopter of technology. Not every anecdote needs a citation. Where's your citation about it being a myth?
Man, posts like this are so prevalent on HN. Why can't people stop and think about whether their words are useful to the conversation?
- idlewords 10y agoAnother tired accusation about negativity on HN, with no examples.
- wernercd 10y agoAnother tired accusation about tired accusations about negativity on HN... We have achieved irony inception.
- ionised 10y agoThe example was the post he responded to.
- quirkafleeg 10y agoHow would you have phrased it then?
- quirkafleeg 10y ago> He literally gave a case (from memory) about the industry being an early adopter of technology. Not every anecdote needs a citation. No, he didn't give a case (of porn pushing technology), and he also didn't say his claim was from memory or was an anecdote. So what are you talking about? He claimed porn used credit cards before "virtually anyone". Which is vague to the point of meaningless, concedes porn was in fact not first, and has zero to back it up anyway. It's simply a boring "observation" people love to repeat when the topic of porn crops up. That it's actually the top comment here, rather than something about the actual story/submission, is unbelievable. > Where's your citation about it being a myth? The fact that there is nothing to back up the claim that porn innovated or pushed technology makes it a myth. You cannot possibly not understand this, so I don't know why you're asking for a "citation". > Why can't people stop and think about whether their words are useful to the conversation? If you want to go down that route, what's so "useful" about trotting out an age-old hackneyed myth about porn? What's so "useful" about your reply to me?
- gknoy 10y agoI thought it was common knowledge that porn drove innovation in tech. :-) I had a hard time finding info on the web about Richard Morgan, but the NY Times is probably a decent citation. Mr. Gordon, 62, played a significant role in the birth of electronic commerce. While Amazon.com and eBay were still fledgling enterprises, the companies that Mr. Gordon founded in the early 1990s were already laying the groundwork for electronic transactions conducted with credit cards — a development that opened the doors to the first generation of e-commerce start-ups. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/18/technology/18gordo.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/18/technology/18gordo.html Also, credit card processing was used to verify age: In 2001 ... these companies ... were imperative for the industry’s existence: Adult Check, CyberAge, CCBill and Internet Billing Co. [E]ndorsed for age verification by ... in the Communications Decency Act 1996, the credit card [was] like a magic wand. [B]y requiring one, porn industries could immediately side step anyone accusing them of displaying porn to minors. http://thenextweb.com/insider/2012/10/07/cybersex-ascii-pinups-celebrity-fakes-how-the-internet-created-a-97-billion-porn-industry/ http://thenextweb.com/insider/2012/10/07/cybersex-ascii-pinu...
- mikestew 10y agoThe top-level post gave an anecdote that is culturally-assumed to be true, with nothing to back it. Let's suppose the story was instead about vaccinating children. Someone comes in, says "yet another example of how vaccines are harmful; they already give kids autism". You're just going to let that slide, and criticize those that point out the false assumptions? Where's your citation about it being a myth? The burden of proof does not lie with...oh, c'mon, you know this. Personally, I've given a fair shot at finding the boolean answer to the question. Best I can find, and the facts are sketchy at best, is the porn industry sucked at payment processing and the early card processing was done by a company that saw the need and filled it. But selling picks and shovels doesn't make you a miner. Man, posts like this are so prevalent on HN. Like what? The kind that call out urban legends, or the kind that perpetuate them?
- quirkafleeg 10y agoThis is really blowing my mind. Top comment is a hackneyed myth I didn't think anyone - even in porn - seriously believed. And any comment even remotely to the contrary is downvoted. WTF is going on here?
- mikestew 10y agoThe down votes I don't care about; I've got more points than I'll ever be able to spend (I can spend these points at the HN Company Store, right?). But the "but everybody knows that!" mentality that wouldn't be tolerated on any other topic just...mystifies me. Meh, we all have religious orthodoxy that dare not be questioned, and for some it's apparently "pr0n drives the tech industry".
- quirkafleeg 10y agoI don't care about the points (otherwise I wouldn't have posted again, knowing the same people will just neg more), I'm just amazed some people believe this myth so strongly that they immediately downvote any and every post, from multiple posters, making different points challenging it. It's a totally a bizarre reaction.
- DashRattlesnake 10y ago>>> I think most innovations in technology come from either the military, video games or porn. >> Looks like another case of the old myth about porn innovating or "pushing" technology, as usual with nothing to back it up. > He literally gave a case (from memory) about the industry being an early adopter of technology. Being an early adopter is not really the same thing as innovating.