3 ms·
An appeal to a "consensus" is by definition an appeal to authority. It has nothing to do with theory or data, it's not science, it's science policy. As Jerry
by hga 17y ago
An appeal to a "consensus" is by definition an appeal to authority.
It has nothing to do with theory or data, it's not science, it's science policy.
As Jerry Pournelle said, "Science policy is to science as birdshot is to birds."
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoWe're going in circles now. I can claim that 60% of US citizens believe in angels and cite surveys to back that claim up. You can argue about whether that fact is correct with or without a personal belief in angels. If someone (perhaps someone with an axe to grind for or against the existence of angels) simply refused to accept that evidence of 60% belief and provided nothing in return, then that alone would make them a dubious source to me. This whole thread started with your confusion of a list of prominant subscribers to global warming which was offered as proof of consensus with it being proof of the consensus position itself. Let's not end in the same place we started.
- billswift 17y agoActually, I think it was Dr Petr Beckman that originally said that in the early 1970s.
- hga 17y agoA quick check with Google indicates you're right, and that's the sort of thing he certainly would have said back in that period. Thanks for the correction.