2 ms·
The other areas of philosophy can inform how we should live questions. For example, if science were to show that free will, at least as traditionally conceived,
by goatlover 10y ago
The other areas of philosophy can inform how we should live questions. For example, if science were to show that free will, at least as traditionally conceived, was impossible, how does that effect our lives? Should our system of justice be changed to reflect that (as some have thought)? Daniel Dennett wrote a book defending a compatibilist version of free will because he was worried about the hard determinist influence on politics.
Another example from the 18th or 19th century was when doctors thought dogs were just automatons, lacking any consciousness. Which allowed them to perform cruel medical experiments on the dogs, and ignore their howlings. But if we become convinced that animals are conscious and can experience pain and misery, do we change how we treat them?
- Erik816 10y agoCertainly. I think science, and more objective areas of philosophy, are great at providing information about the world. And that should certainly factor into the discussions of how we should live in that world. They just can't determine it.
- ryuker16 10y agoDepends on how tasty the animal is. The more self-aware an animal is, the less tasty it becomes. Cows, seafood, and pigs simply lack the divine park. Source: my stomach