2 ms·
I'm not replying to all the mis-characterizations of my article -- aside from saying I'm not racist nor planning on moving out of the country any time soon. But
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I'm not replying to all the mis-characterizations of my article -- aside from saying I'm not racist nor planning on moving out of the country any time soon. But I found your observations very interesting.
It IS complicated, and (I think) still a matter of debate why people actually leave a city. I don't claim to know the answer, I was just wondering if those generally-agreed-upon trends would amount to the same kind of exodus seen in the cities over the past few decades.
Particularly I liked this phrase you used:
because it is possible to engage the city without actually living in the city
This would seem to be the basis for cities like Washington, D.C. threatening to tax commuters for "allowing" them to come to work in the city. Perhaps also this is the basis for the U.S. continuing to tax citizens even if they don't live in the U.S. or ever visit.
Question: does the internet allow us to "engage" the rest of the world to the extent necessary to make this geographic proximity less important than it was 20 years ago?
And for those who wondered, I can't remember all the countries this startup was dealing with. Their business model was providing an internet portal for Americans looking to retire/live overseas and get the most out of their remaining savings and income. Costa Rica comes to mind. As does Chile and Brazil. If I remember correctly, one of the services they provided was a annual survey of countries and how friendly they were to American ex-pats. Also lots of advertising from resort and retirement communities from all over the world, along with real-estate listings, business opportunities, etc. It looked like a cool idea, but I didn't really think about the larger trends it was based on until reading the ex-pat tax article on HN a few days back.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoPeople leave cities because a mixture of zoning regulations and high real estate prices lead to a scenario where the city becomes a place of work and only work. Car culture leads to a loss of locality and continuity (you can go from A to B and not give a damn about, or interact with, any of the points between them). The city starts losing people, and a death spiral begins as it turns into a "5 o'clock town". The balance of amenity vs. inconvenience/expense drives people to the suburbs. Throw in a bit of white racism (although that's not a major factor anymore) and "white flight" is what you get, along with "inner city" ruin. One major cause of this is that real estate prices are "sticky downward"; they skyrocket easily (Bay Area, early 90s) in an economic boom, but don't decline fast enough along when the market softens; people become unduly attached to real estate (as opposed to other investments) and hold out forever. This process kills a city, and you'd expect that to depress real estate prices and bring back equilibrium, but the price movement that occurs is too little, too late. If you want to buy a house in the ghettos of Chicago's South Side you will still have to pay at least half a million for many of them.
- edster 17y agoDetroit (like many big cities) already taxes commuters. If you work in the city, you pay 1.5% income tax to the city. In the extreme case of Detroit, a huge percentage of the city tax revenues come from people who have no ability to be represented in the city. (The whole taxation without representation thing) As Detroit learned, thinking that people will continue to engage the city without living there is only true to a point. In this area, business has moved to Troy and Southfield and Novi. Most people I know go into the actual city of Detroit a couple of times a year, mostly to go to a ball game or casino. People don't go there to shop or socialize.