5 ms·
Will "White Flight" Strike the U.S.?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pw0ncakes 17y ago-5
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- meowmix 17y ago> ...I wonder if the country as a whole will suffer a kind of "White Flight", where the better off people move out of the city... Congratulations on subtly associating "white" with "better off"
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- milkshakes 17y agoAs the quotation marks suggest, he didn't invent the term: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight
- starkfist 17y agoHe didn't coin the phrase. This phenomena has been called "white flight" in the media for decades. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight
- meowmix 17y agoOh I know. I used to live in Baltimore, I'm quite familiar with the concept. Edit: My original point was more to demonstrate that it's easy to use an outdated term ("white flight") and continue to use it to promote the idea that white = wealth.
- dschobel 17y agoWhile White Americans made up roughly 75.1% of all persons in 2000, 87.93% of all households in the top 5% were headed by a person who identified as being White alone. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_States#Race http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_...
- mnemonicsloth 17y agoHow is the term outdated? Last I checked, economic parity between black and white Americans was a ways off yet. I'm sure you have the best of intentions, but from here it looks like you're objecting to a pithy truth that you don't want stated. Which is a worse signal to send, for people concerned about racial inequality in the US -- Thought Police, or Vocabulary Prudes?
- pw0ncakes 17y agoWhite flight is about racial anxiety more than it is about wealth or tax policies. It's not necessarily appropriate in the OP's case, because what he's describing doesn't have much to do with race inherently, although there is a correspondence between white racism and supposedly disinterested economic conservatism. The most flagrant opponents of government assistance programs have no problem with programs that benefit them-- "my opponent [Al Gore in 2000] wants to run Social Security like it's some kind of federal program" and "keep your government hands off my Medicare"-- but have a huge issue with "those people" (blacks and Latinos) on "welfare". Author's note: "Welfare" is not one US social program, but a disparaging epithet used by working-class conservatives against whatever social programs-- Medicaid, food stamps-- are used predominantly by people lower than them on the socioeconomic totem pole. I grew up in a low-income, traditionally white neighborhood, so I've seen this first-hand. There was one family notorious for this: they received benefits from some social welfare programs and would rip on those who were on more such programs for being "on welfare". Also, many racist whites are against "big government" not because of an inherent objection but because the government uses more affirmative action than private-sector employers, which leads them to the (wrong) conclusion that government is 100% staffed with underperforming women and minorities. This is what "government (except the military) can't do anything right" is actually about.
- patio11 17y agoJurisdictions actively competing for internal migration is one of the healthiest features of the American political system, and with the rise of globalism and the Internet I see this trend only increasing. I'm not big on the framing of this particular post, but the prefecture I live in had a declared policy of encouraging "immigration by desirable foreigners" (their phrasing, not mine) a few years ago -- educated professionals and business owners, principally. This prefecture was hardly a revolutionary trendsetter in that regard. Although I know more of my fair share of expats based out of cheap countries in Southeast Asia due to the circles I run in, note that this is totally not limited to the choice of "first world country with mediocre services and crushing tax load" versus "third world country where you're on your own." America/Japan/Canada/UK/etc can compete for mobile individuals just like California and Kansas compete for them.
- xiaoma 17y agoUnfortunately, it isn't exactly a fair competition for overseas Americans due to the long reach of US financial laws. Aside from having to file taxes to both the country of residence and the US, there are a number of financial reporting rules about even fairly modest sums of money (>$10k) in foreign bank accounts. Most troubling is that the failure to keep up with the ever-changing accounting regulations results in draconian penalties which are often more than the person's entire net worth. I find the threat of being completely wiped out financially or even being put in prison simply for not keeping track of whether a paycheck has put my bank account over $10k or not far more worrying than owing a bit of money in taxes. This gives Americans a modest disincentive to move abroad and compete with the people from Japan/Canada/UK etc... who don't face those dangers.
- patio11 17y agoXiaoma is referring to a Treasury Regulation which requires you to file a one-page form with two numbers on it (nuisance scales linearly with accounts controlled). The penalty for forgetting to file it if you're a paycheck over $10,000 is that a bureaucrat will be very cross with you, if they notice. http://www.irs.ustreas.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f90221.pdf http://www.irs.ustreas.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f90221.pdf Relatedly, the IRS' response to minor issues with tax returns is to send you a bill.
- patrickgzill 17y agoIMHO: yes. Just like the Jews dispersed after the destruction of the Second Temple, there will be an American disapora. And that monthly rate to live somewhere else is closer to $4k per month than $10K per month, depending on how much you want to travel, etc. even while living overseas.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoI can't believe someone would compare our supposedly high taxes to a historical atrocity. There is no comparison between paying a few percent more in taxes, for causes that benefit the common good, and having your country conquered. None whatsoever.
- davidw 17y ago> I can't believe someone would compare our supposedly high taxes to a historical atrocity You must not have been on the internet long:-/ It seems that even on sites like this, which have a fairly "high quality" user base, the path from intelligent discussions to flame wars is a perilously short one when the subject is politics, which is why I continue to argue for their abolishment from this site. Not that the article in question starts from the best position, either: the number of people "renouncing their citizenship" last year was in the hundreds, whereas every day, some 10,000+ babies are born in the US, just to put things in perspective.
- spking 17y ago"...paying a few percent more in taxes, for causes that benefit the common good..." That's a very broad generalization and an extremely debatable statement. 1. "Paying a few percent more in taxes" When you factor in the whole of the tax burden the average working American pays (Federal, state, local, special district) it adds up to about 50% of personal income. This is not just income tax, but sales, Medicare, SS, Unemployment, gas, property tax, special assessments, DMV, etc. 2. "Causes that benefit the common good" Unfortunately, the vast majority of our tax dollars goes to servicing the interest on the national debt and our vast military machine. See: http://www.warresisters.org/pages/piechart.htm http://www.warresisters.org/pages/piechart.htm
- JeffJenkins 17y agoThe tax situation only affects people living outside of the US, and possibly needing to renounce your citizenship is an incentive to not leave the country. The US is also one of the least taxed countries, despite rhetoric suggesting otherwise. The people who are "better off" are by far the most comfortable here and least likely to be feeling the impact of the increased cost of living. They're also the least likely to actually need the government services which aren't working. Lastly, as you hinted at near the end, the fundamental difference between moving to the suburbs and moving to another region (domestically or internationally) is that you are going to be far away from friends and family as well as developing whole new routines. In the suburbs you can just drive into the city if you had been doing something there regularly.
- rfreytag 17y agoLeaving now before you know what a new administration might bring seems hasty. I am seeing hopeful signs of improvement in the US economic structure (Glass-Steagall anyone?). Perhaps domination of the economy by the finance sector and its zero-sum approach to wealth creation will diminish in favor of new value-creating enterprises in other sectors. Statistics showing lots of new businesses would be a very good sign.
- dhh 17y agoWhich South American country exactly would you move to that is both better governed and less taxed? I don't think the author has visited many SA countries. That's not to say that there are no reasons to move to South America, just that you don't go there for the model governance, wonderful taxation scheme, or regime/economic stability.
- maw 17y agoChile and Uruguay are supposedly well-governed. I'm not sure about taxation in either. Despite that, I agree with you: there's a lot to recommend Latin America (I've lived in Mexico for almost six years), but generally you don't include model governance or well-run taxation among those reasons. I haven't been here long enough to comment on regime or economic stability.
- nsfmc 17y agoFirstly, "white flight" is not due to "people [moving] out of the city because the burden it is placing on them does not match the value of the services they are receiving." The most correct explanation is that "it's complicated" and has to do with issues of class, mobility and race, but has little to do with the city "failing to provide" in fact, the reason white flight exists is because it is possible to engage the city without actually living in the city. A good example of this is detroit in the past hundred or so years. I love that this article is essentially predicated on the idea that you should retain an american salary and live in a depressed economy where that is disproportionately large in relation to the average. This sort of white flight actively diminishes the tax base and local revenue in a negative feedback cycle more significantly than the increasing population of "poorer people." I mean, if you want to leave the country, by all means, but don't expect it to take care of you once you're gone. I'm reminded me of the closing paragraphs of a recent [NYT poll][survey] on the Tea Party movement: > ...nearly three-quarters of those who favor smaller government said they would prefer it even if it meant spending on domestic programs would be cut. > But in follow-up interviews, Tea Party supporters said they did not want to cut Medicare or Social Security — the biggest domestic programs, suggesting instead a focus on “waste.” > Some defended being on Social Security while fighting big government by saying that since they had paid into the system, they deserved the benefits. > Others could not explain the contradiction. > “That’s a conundrum, isn’t it?” asked Jodine White, 62, of Rocklin, Calif. “I don’t know what to say. Maybe I don’t want smaller government. I guess I want smaller government and my Social Security.” She added, “I didn’t look at it from the perspective of losing things I need. I think I’ve changed my mind.” [survey]: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/15/us/politics/15poll.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/15/us/politics/15poll.html
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI'm not replying to all the mis-characterizations of my article -- aside from saying I'm not racist nor planning on moving out of the country any time soon. But I found your observations very interesting. It IS complicated, and (I think) still a matter of debate why people actually leave a city. I don't claim to know the answer, I was just wondering if those generally-agreed-upon trends would amount to the same kind of exodus seen in the cities over the past few decades. Particularly I liked this phrase you used: because it is possible to engage the city without actually living in the city This would seem to be the basis for cities like Washington, D.C. threatening to tax commuters for "allowing" them to come to work in the city. Perhaps also this is the basis for the U.S. continuing to tax citizens even if they don't live in the U.S. or ever visit. Question: does the internet allow us to "engage" the rest of the world to the extent necessary to make this geographic proximity less important than it was 20 years ago? And for those who wondered, I can't remember all the countries this startup was dealing with. Their business model was providing an internet portal for Americans looking to retire/live overseas and get the most out of their remaining savings and income. Costa Rica comes to mind. As does Chile and Brazil. If I remember correctly, one of the services they provided was a annual survey of countries and how friendly they were to American ex-pats. Also lots of advertising from resort and retirement communities from all over the world, along with real-estate listings, business opportunities, etc. It looked like a cool idea, but I didn't really think about the larger trends it was based on until reading the ex-pat tax article on HN a few days back.
- pw0ncakes 17y agoThis is ludicrous. We don't see Swedes and Finns leaving their countries over taxes. They take pride in their welfare states and relative lack of poverty. The counterargument is that "we're different". Sure: we're a lot more nomadic. It's not unusual for an American to live 1000 miles away from where he was born, and for a lot of us, living overseas is attractive, but I still don't see this as a mass threat. Besides, if conservative whiners want to leave the country in droves, I'm fine with that. We'll do fine without them. After blocking universal healthcare in '48 (Southern racists didn't want to desegregate the hospitals) and bringing us Nixon's ridiculous drug war, the utter failures of Reaganomics, and a crass consumer culture, I'm surprised we haven't kicked them out yet.
- anamax 17y ago> We don't see Swedes and Finns leaving their countries over taxes. The Swedes and Finns still in Sweden and Finland are descended from folks who didn't move to the US because they were unhappy about something. Americans, for the most part, descended from folks who left somewhere because they were unhappy about something. Which reminds me, as Mankiw showed, the per-capita tax burden in dollars in the US is fairly close to that of European countries. However, it's a smaller fraction of GDP because the US per-capita GDP is higher. In other words, Americans pay about the same and have more. It's unclear why changing to pay the same and have less is a good thing. And, since we're already paying the same and getting less, the whole "but look at what they get for their taxes" argument fails. http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2010/03/taxes-per-person.html http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2010/03/taxes-per-person.html http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=4626 http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=4626
- hga 17y agoThis Swede left his country "over taxes": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingmar_Bergman#Tax_evasion_charges http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingmar_Bergman#Tax_evasion_char... How much more abusive would you guess the IRS is vs. Sweden's equivalent?
- Quarrelsome 17y agoSorry but I call "old man argument". It's the same argument that my dad makes. "Things are bad, it's better abroad" which more or less leads to his "the world is going to end" diatribe. I think this "white flight" premise is a lot more to do with the older generation who among other things earn more money and thus pay more tax and more easily fall into "the country's gone to pot" way on thinking. In the UK You certainly saw a number of people nearing retirement age move to the continent (Spain mostly) on the back-end of the housing boom. I don't think "the current situation" has changed one iota, its only that you've aged and now see things differently. I would suggest you help out the younger generation by staying and helping them pay the tax bill and possibly generating some jobs for them. Also the US has lotsa undeveloped land. So idk what you're talking about there.....
- CWuestefeld 17y agoThere's a kernel of truth in your argument. At least some of the effect is changing perception. But some is changing realities as well. My investment advisor tells me that with the GWB tax cuts expiring, scheduled increases in capital gains taxes, and the government's refusal to address the AMT problem, that my tax situation is changing drastically enough that I need to change my investment strategy. I'm paying into Social Security to give my grandparents more money than they ever paid in, and covering the shortfall created by my parents' generation running up huge deficits and borrowing the money from SS. On the other side, you're asking me to help out the younger generation pay their tax bills. And stuck in the middle, I find that any responsible behavior on my part is answered by looting the savings from my frugality to give to reward the profligate. I'm paying down my mortgage as fast as I can, while underwriting the costs for those who bought McMansions and can't afford them. Those of us who bought economical cars are paying part of the costs for fuel hogs to trade in for better mileage. I'm quite certain that after all the savings I've done for old age, the long term care insurance I've paid 5-digits into, etc., the government is going to see that I have too many privileges (that I've worked for, and lived frugally to amass) and take away more of what I've had to give to the wasteful. Every day I see another version of the ant-and-grasshopper story. I don't think you can blame me for frustration. And you really ought to worry about the moral hazard it's causing. I fear that it leads to a feedback cycle, where the problem gets worse and worse.
- maukdaddy 17y agoWhy is this inflammatory, tea party crap being voted up?!
- astrodust 17y agoI have to agree that this does seem rather Libertarian and/or political if not simply misguided.