7 ms·
Non-scientists can take a legitimate stand on the methods, e.g. the statisticians from Canada who destroyed the hockey stick. We'd see even more of that if the
by hga 17y ago
Non-scientists can take a legitimate stand on the methods, e.g. the statisticians from Canada who destroyed the hockey stick. We'd see even more of that if the data, code and methods were public (pity the original raw collected data was lost (much of it might be recoverable if someone were to go back to the original national weather service sources)).
I think you're also misrepresenting the nature of the debate; it would be a lot more like everyone arguing about managed (GCed) code vs. unmanaged (C/C++/Objective C etc. with manual memory management). The other side, and plenty of them are scientists and even specialists in this area, are not arguing the equivalent of "machine code is best", an idea that died very shortly after the advent of symbolic assemblers.