4 ms·
If you want to go after the simple stuff then blocking significant outbound traffic at the ISP level from a home user account until they agree it's something th
by onion2k 10y ago
If you want to go after the simple stuff then blocking significant outbound traffic at the ISP level from a home user account until they agree it's something they want to do is the most straightforward solution. No need to change much infrastructure, no need to test devices, and no need to have costly manufacturing processes. You could even let specific traffic through (Facebook live streaming, online gaming services, etc).
- clarry 10y agoAn attack can be quite effective even if the traffic from a single home is insignificant. I don't need ISPs to mess with my connection any more than they do already.
- onion2k 10y agoAn attack can be quite effective even if the traffic from a single home is insignificant. In a recent attack there were 145607 devices sending >1.5Tbps[1]. That's a lot from individual connections. (From: https://twitter.com/olesovhcom/status/779297257199964160 https://twitter.com/olesovhcom/status/779297257199964160 )
- clarry 10y agoAbout 1.4 megabytes on average is not that much. Even so, this one wasn't a particularly sophisticated attack. Even if we could weed out this particular type, many a DoS rely on amplification or asymmetrical computational cost with respect to the size of the request. So if we concluded that 1.4 MB/s of HTTP or DNS or plain TCP were a lot and managed to block these senders, it would be far from a universal solution against DDoS originating from domestic hosts. And there's reason to believe we'll see much larger botnets unless manufacturers of IoT devices start taking security seriously. So tomorrow 0.14 MB/s per home could be plenty. What cost would this blocking incur? How often would I have to call my ISP because they blocked perfectly legitimate traffic? Unfortunately maybe not that often, because after the first few calls I'd probably figure that they are too big to give a shit about my problems.
- ArchReaper 10y agoThat sounds like a terrible idea. You think every end user, everywhere, needs to manually verify with their ISP for every single outbound connection? How could that possibly be an acceptable solution?
- onion2k 10y agoI think you misread or misunderstood what I meant by "blocking significant outbound traffic". 99.9% of what home users do doesn't generate significant amounts of outbound traffic. If someone typically browsers the web, sends a few emails, and then their traffic starts doing 20Mbps/s on an undocumented port, blocking that traffic until they verify what it is wouldn't be a bad idea. It wouldn't affect most users.
- wila 10y agoAlmost, it would be a better idea to block incoming telnet traffic. I am having trouble coming up with a good reason for having telnet open to the internet.