3 ms·
> A lot of research is supposed to be new, uncertain, high-risk, high-reward. So it should fail often. Except that has nothing to do with papers not being read
by pron 10y ago
> A lot of research is supposed to be new, uncertain, high-risk, high-reward. So it should fail often.
Except that has nothing to do with papers not being read. Papers that detail failure are usually never written, and if they are, they're not published. But in any event, reports of failure should be read almost as much as reports of success.
In addition, bad research and unread papers are two completely separate problems, that may not be related in any way whatsoever.
Papers are not read but because researchers must churn out a lot of papers even for results that are partial or not very interesting on their own, so we are flooded with what basically amounts to noise. It obviously makes sense that a lot of research would turn out to be not very interesting, but that shouldn't result in papers being written and published. I guess that even those who publish those papers would rather have more time to bring ideas to the point where they become interesting, or conclude that an approach has failed, but the system doesn't work that way, and that's a failure of the system.
- evandijk70 10y agoWhile I agree that reports of failure can be important, in many cases experimental research is trying to develop a protocol to perform a measurement. A protocol that does not work is simply not as interesting as a protocol that does work. For example, I am sure there are many plausible gene-editing protocols, but none are as robust as CRISPR. Of course the papers that describe CRISPR are going to be cited more, since that protocol is going to be used in many other studies.