5 ms·
> this is exactly how journalism works No, this is "industrial espionage" through illegal methods, and it's only OK-ish to do if it serves some public good (ju
by bad_user 17y ago
> this is exactly how journalism works
No, this is "industrial espionage" through illegal methods, and it's only OK-ish to do if it serves some public good (justice). And no, this is not journalism, unless by that you mean intentionally breaking the law for your own profit.
I really hope the person that stole that phone and Gizmodo are prosecuted for theft.
Because of dicks like these we ended up with the current patent system.
- punchfire 17y agoall i think is that everyone is making a mountain out of a molehill in this situation. this is blown way out of proportion.
- ynniv 17y agoExcept reactions to Gizmodo publishing the name and photo of an innocent employee, who they then proceed to mock. The only rationale for doing so is to deflect some of the heat that they were getting in classic dick fashion. "Dude! We screwed up, but... look at this guy! Man he likes BEER!" Thats professionalism right there.
- stcredzero 17y agoI read their comments regarding beer as attempts to rehabilitate that guy as an ordinary fellow who makes mistakes.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tghw 17y agoWow, guys picking up phones in bars led to the current patent system? There's a piece of history I never knew. There is no "industrial espionage" here. Industrial espionage would, at the very least, require Gizmodo to intend to steal the phone from the outset, which clearly isn't the case. As far as trade secrets go, Apple gives up all claim to them as soon as that phone leaves its campus. Gizmodo probably crossed some line in what it did and how it handled this story, but accusing a gadget site of industrial espionage is just ridiculous.
- anigbrowl 17y agoWould you happen to know what statute governs this?
- tghw 17y agoThe trade secrets part is based on the Uniform Trade Secrets Act: The act defines a trade secret as information, including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device, method, technique, or process, that: i) derives independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known to, and not being readily ascertainable by proper means by, other persons who can obtain economic value from its disclosure or use, and ii) is the subject of efforts that are reasonable under the circumstances to maintain its secrecy. The auto industry has provided plenty of case law where car manufacturers tried suing people for photographing and reporting on new cars the companies were testing in public, almost all of which they lost because once the car was out in public, even with fake body work added (see http://www.worldcarfans.com/10803171807/vauxhall-reveal-the-secrets-of-camouflage http://www.worldcarfans.com/10803171807/vauxhall-reveal-the-...), it no longer met the second requirement of reasonable efforts to maintain secrecy.
- cynicalkane 17y agoField-testing a prototype phone that fits in your pocket isn't the same as driving a car all over the place! And it's not even clear whether the info on the new iPhone was obtained legally!
- anigbrowl 17y agoIndeed. and you make a good point about cars, that being that if one actively shows the thing off in public one is inviting scrutiny. I would have no problem at all with a story along the lines of 'Man spotted in bar photographing self with iPhone - new model must have front-facing camera'. For that matter I'd be OK with 'iPhone prototype found? Man finds functional iPhone, but exterior case looks fake (obvious exterior facts)'. But suppose, to stick with the car example, the driver of a prototype car parked in a public lot and then dropped the keys, or was careless enough to leave them in the ignition. Would it be legitimate for someone to drive away and then sell it to a car fansite so they could pop the hood and partially disassemble it? There's a large qualitative difference between passive observation and active taking into possession. And I don't think opening the case is a proper means of evaluating a lost item, especially not when one has already ascertained the identity of the owner (by recognizing him from his facebook page, where he was easily contactable). Thanks for taking the time to flesh out your argument. I was hoping you'd refer me to the statute for industrial espionage, by the way, because I think you might be surprised at its scope and specificity. Would you like to, or shall I?