3 ms·
I think that in a highly skilled workplace, the hierarchical aspect of management accounts for a relatively small fraction of what managers do. For the most par
by analog31 10y ago
I think that in a highly skilled workplace, the hierarchical aspect of management accounts for a relatively small fraction of what managers do. For the most part, I treat managers like any other workers. I'm not afraid to have substantive discussions with them, or to delegate tasks to them.
For roughly a year, I actually outranked my boss. I did the engineering, and he dealt with schedules, priorities, communicating upward, etc. It was a great relationship, because we both had jobs to do, and we did them.
In the 21st century, we're getting beyond the point where the hierarchy of authority is accompanied by a hierarchy of knowledge or expertise. In the 19th century business of my imagination, the head clerk knew more about clerking than the junior clerk. A manager was expected to know more about management and business.
Today, people change jobs and fields throughout their careers. It's not unusual for a manager to have subordinates who have been managers themselves, or who have even run entire businesses. People know more about the behavior of the businesses that they work for, than they can learn from management pronouncements, because we can read about the behavior of similar businesses. Managers have diverse staffs. I don't expect my boss to be knowledgeable about my field, because he's a chemist and I'm a physicist.
- hammock 10y ago>For roughly a year, I actually outranked my boss. I did the engineering, and he dealt with schedules, priorities, communicating upward, etc. That doesn't sound like you outranked him. He scheduled your time, set your priorities, and was gatekeeper to the broader organization.
- taneq 10y agoThat's because you're defining 'rank' as 'setting schedules'. You could just as easily view the situation as the manager providing an interface to the rest of the company, and helping with organisation - somewhat secretarial role.
- dexterdog 10y agoYes it does. It sounds like his boss was actually his administrative assistant.
- analog31 10y agoTo be fair, more like a project manager, and a damn good one. He could keep things straight in complex projects, and was deft with politics, but without sacrificing his integrity or engineering cred.
- analog31 10y agoThat would drive me out of corporate life in a hurry, especially the gatekeeper part. It was a different kind of relationship. My job comes with a fair amount of autonomy and authority. I'm trusted to communicate with people directly, and consider that to be a vital part of how I do my job. And the department is "matrix" organized, so there's a lot of cross communication. Anyway, the rank inversion was temporary, and was just a matter of having different numerical rankings for "technical track" and "management track" employees.