6 ms·
‘Post-Fire London was a magnificent, beautiful compromise’
- oxymoron 10y agoNeal Stephenson paints an entertaining picture of the events surrounding the plague and the great fire in _Quicksilver_. It includes a fictionalized version of Robert Hooke with frequent references to his contribution to the rebuilt city, and chronicles the early days of the Royal Society in general. I truly recommend it to anyone interested in historical fiction and the early days of science.
- macarthy12 10y ago+1 great series, long but great. I had read biographies of many of the characters/historical figures, mostly Royal society type, before reading quicksilver, and I can tell that Stephenson did also. The audible versions of the books are great too. 60ish hours each
- M_Grey 10y agoI love listening to them while playing a good videogame... perfect combination of total mental immersions.
- oska 10y agoIt's an interesting article but I dislike the lead-in: > Cities are fragile things. They can burn: Rome in 64 AD (possibly thanks to the Emperor Nero); Constantinople in 1203 (courtesy of the Fourth Crusade); Lisbon in 1755 (because of the earthquake); Moscow in 1812 (thanks to Napoleon); Hamburg in 1842; Chicago in 1871; San Francisco in 1906… But in terms of devastation, few urban conflagrations can compare with the Great Fire of London, whose 350th anniversary is being marked this year. How about the fire-bombing of Tokyo and nearly all other major Japanese cities during WWII? The fire-bombing of Tokyo is considered the greatest urban conflagration in history with the US Strategic Bombing Survey conservatively estimating one million homes destroyed. Or the fire in Tokyo after the Great Kantō earthquake in 1923? Or, contemporaneous with the event described, the Great Fire of Meireki in 1657, which destroyed 60-70% of Tokyo and is estimated to have claimed 100,000 lives. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Fire_of_Meireki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Fire_of_Meireki
- prawn 10y agoTo be fair, the article says "few urban conflagrations can compare" and then you compared a few. Seems reasonable.
- M_Grey 10y agoExcept you could then add a few more, Dresden, Berlin, etc... and then a few more. And a few more. The article is chock-full of sophistry, and the lead-in just sets up the mindset.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe resilience of cities is much commented on. They do withstand fires, and earthquakes, and hurricanes, and floods, and plagues. They're considerably more resilient than businesses and corporations. What will kill a city, though, and rapidly, is a loss of economic foundations. Detroit, Pittsburgh, Manchester, St. Louis, Flint, Youngstown, Scranton, Dayton, .... But that's more a case of the fire going out.
- randomsearch 10y agoI think the missed opportunity to design (rather than "redesign"; there was no original design) London is an absolute tragedy. Whilst the "winding streets" and "character" of London's awful road layout may be romantic for visiting tourists, it has resulted in a city needlessly choked with traffic, that feels cramped and claustrophobic compared to Europe's great capitals. Some of London's most famous streets are heavily polluted by noisy dirty standing traffic, and give little room for pedestrian movement. The district around St Pauls feels so anonymous and cramped, in a way that affects so much of London. London cries out for open squares, wider pavements and pedestrianised areas. You need only visit Trafalgar Square (which itself could use a redesign) to see how many people the few open spaces that exist in London attract. It's not a beautiful compromise, it's a failure to manage, it's a failure of vision and ambition.
- notauser 10y agoWell everyone feels different ways about these things. The winding streets slow traffic down, making it safer to cycle around when compared to the fast and wide roads of New York. They also block wind meaning we don't get driving rain along straight avenues. The lack of large squares and piazzas reduces the distance you have to walk between places, which is very important in a damp environment. It takes ages to get anywhere on foot in Mexico City for example whereas you can walk all the way across central London in a couple of hours. I routinely walk to meetings around the city and it rarely takes more than 20 minutes. Rather than try and spread the city out planners are working on removing the cars and lorries. New pollution taxes, electric and autonomous vehicles, and pedestrianization of key roads like Oxford Street, are all going to work really well in the London model of a dense core whereas they won't add nearly as much to a city which is more spread out.
- randomsearch 10y ago> The winding streets slow traffic down, making it safer to cycle around when compared to the fast and wide roads of New York. I think the way to provide safe cycling is not to slow the traffic down, but to separate cyclists and cars. I looked for stats. Death rates in NYC and London are similar, but I couldn't find much comparable data on the number of cyclists or usage. > They also block wind meaning we don't get driving rain along straight avenues. That's a fair point, but presumably having well-designed streets still allows for this, e.g. by staggering roads? I agree that electric vehicles will greatly reduce pollution, you'll still be walking through dense standing traffic in many areas.
- reledi 10y agoFYI There's recent evidence that the fire didn't start on Pudding Lane: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/12109005/great-fire-of-london-origin.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/12109005/great-fire-o...
- dredmorbius 10y agoHow did Paris address the property claims challenge to redesigning itself in the 1700s and 1800s?