4 ms·
I think this is exactly right. There is some fudging with the cost (this seems to be a common theme with Elon) by pre-including savings and rebates Etc, but the
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I think this is exactly right. There is some fudging with the cost (this seems to be a common theme with Elon) by pre-including savings and rebates Etc, but the fact is this makes a solar roof something different than a set of panels across an existing roof. The durability question, and the weight per sq foot will be interesting.
That said, the combination of the PowerWall and the roof might actually make it more amenable for power companies since you could grid tie "for emergencies" but lower your total overall power budget and help avoid the evening surge (max grid usage in the Bay Area is about 5:30PM, solar is off-line and people are coming home from work, firing up appliances (like cooking dinner, getting a beer from the fridge which turns on the converter) environment systems (heating/cooling) are activating to bring the house to the 'occupied' temperature, Etc.
If your house uses its PowerWall for all that energy you'll appear as a much smoother non-load on the grid.
- hinkley 10y agoTar shingles are pretty damned heavy. If you've never experienced it, try picking some up at your hardware store, they have a bit of a weigh budget to work with. And then if you want some sympathy for your roofers, imagine slinging a box of those while standing on a diagonal surface 20 feet in the air in the afternoon sun. Yikes. I'd almost worry more about about the size of the panels making installation problematic in a light to moderate wind, and having them sail off the roof into the neighbor's car.
- brownbat 10y agoSolar, surprisingly enough, has a higher death per kilowatt rate than nuclear, primarily because roofing work is so dangerous. Nowhere close to mining coal of course. http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/#41956adf49d2 http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-de...
- josinalvo 10y agoI've heard these numbers from Forbes come from a very pro-nuclear estimate. Does anyone more knowledgeable care to comment? What other estimates are there? How are they calculated?
- philipkglass 10y agoI would like to see the original inputs that went into the calculation myself. I've searched quite a bit without being able to locate them. As far as I can tell, it's calculated by dividing the (very low) number of acute fatalities from civilian nuclear accidents by the (very high) number of terawatt hours generated by civilian nuclear power plants. If I'm correct that would kind-of be cheating because they're not counting "mundane" fatal accidents (forklift crushing, arc flash, falls from high places, etc.) that also happen on nuclear sites. The spirit of the comparison that fossil combustion is far more dangerous to human health than nuclear power is correct, but the exact number given for nuclear may be a bit too low. Additionally, I'd like to see fatality numbers for solar overall, not just rooftop solar. In the US at least more solar capacity is installed at ground-mount plants than on rooftops. The rooftop number itself could probably use an update; increasing module efficiency, if nothing else, is going to reduce the number of rooftop trips required for a given capacity, hence the number of accidents per terawatt hour.
- cc81 10y agoAnd if you compare to mining for coal should you not compare the manufacturing/mining that is required for nuclear and solar too?
- philipkglass 10y agoYes, though both nuclear and solar require significantly less primary materials extraction than fossil generation. The highest impact from coal is actually air pollution affecting the general population rather than on-the-job deaths of miners.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoRelevantly, building a solar roof once, rather than adding solar to a standard roof, would eliminate these deaths (assuming building a solar roof is no more dangerous than building a standard roof) and if the roof tiles are genuinely more durable as Musk claims, they could end up with negative fatalities.
- inimino 10y agoGiven that solar installations are tiny and nuclear installations are huge and have generally excellent safety records, this seems quite reasonable.
- jondiggsit 10y agoSlate is pretty darn heavy too