5 ms·
> My current employer doesn’t let me work on Open Source projects or personal projects without prior permission That's ... weird. I hope they're paying well fo
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
> My current employer doesn’t let me work on Open Source projects or personal projects without prior permission
That's ... weird. I hope they're paying well for this.
- MrSourz 10y agoI had the same thought. Do you know if there's a list anywhere of valley / well known companies with this type of policy? It's the type of thing that'd turn me off for sure during a job search.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThe stance on personal after-work projects, as well as whether or not you're to work in an open-space office, are two things I'd really love every job listing mentioned. It would be the primary filter for me.
- svachalek 10y agoIt's more typical for them to claim ownership of it, rather than to forbid it. Any job where you have to submit a list of prior work with your employment contract (which is most of them in my experience) is usually a sign that there's a clause in there claiming ownership of everything you do while employed there. Personally I doubt it's very enforceable, especially since California is so worker-friendly on everything else I know about, but I don't know how well these clauses work out in practice.
- kobeya 10y agoIt's illegal under California law, so no "valley" (I assume you mean Silicon Valley?) company can outlaw moonlighting.
- xenadu02 10y agoCalifornia categorically prohibits this so all such provisions are null and void in CA. Anything you develop during non-working hours, not at your employer's office, and on your own equipment is yours and employers are not legally allowed to have any claim on that work.
- rerx 10y agoAnd it's really not something I'd have expected from Mozilla.
- throwawayReply 10y ago(preamble: I'm not a lawyer and this is not legal advice.) Here (in the UK) it's often in boilerplate employment contracts that any projects worked at any time during employment[0] belong to the company. I tend to go through and cross it out when I find it but I'm also fairly sure it's one of those "it's in there but it's not legally enforceable" things that are often found in employment contracts so I don't know how well tested it is in the courts and also I don't think a company would damage their reputation enforcing it unless someone was working on a project directly relating to or competing with a product the company made. It's understandable that an employer wouldn't want someone developing an open source competitor to their own products. The 'social contract' is that the employer should invest in their human capital so that in return the employee gains valuable experience and learning by providing training courses, conferences and the like. How much that happens of course varies greatly in the wild. [0] During as in the duration of your life where you're employed, not "working hours".
- kobeya 10y agoIt's not understandable that a company should have the right to limit what an employee does after-hours on his own hardware with his own IP.
- throwawayReply 10y agoIf you spend your nights rebuilding your company's software as an open source offering, you don't think that would contravene ethics and your obligations to your employer? Some might argue, "But existing IP and trade secrets protection already covers this". In cases such as this it would be difficult and expensive to pursue a criminal case around IP and trade secrets, so it's cheaper and easier to have a contract clause which approximately restates the same thing but as part of the contract, with some stronger statements to provide added protection. There are plenty of clauses in contracts which might seem odd because they're effectively restating parts of criminal law in the contract, but moving things from criminal law to civil law moves the burden of proof from "Beyond reasonable doubt" to "On the balance of probabilities". Employment contracts are for the benefit of both parties, but ultimately it is the employers who draft them and they will try to get away with as much as possible.