8 ms·
The Bolt may work in terms of range and charging but it remains impractical for most of the general public. A Bolt costs roughly $32K (depending on incentives,
by Someone1234 10y ago
The Bolt may work in terms of range and charging but it remains impractical for most of the general public.
A Bolt costs roughly $32K (depending on incentives, maybe more). A Toyota Camry Hybrid starts at $26,790. And, I know what you're going to say, "electricity is free!" That's just untrue. Recharging electric cars is far from free.
The Bolt costs roughly $10 to recharge its 238 mile battery. A Camry Hybrid can drive approx 680 miles on a full tank and costs $37 to completely refill. So you're saving about $8 per every 680 miles you drive.
So the breakeven for the cost difference of the two vehicles (@$5,210) is 442,850 miles. Neither car is going to make it to 400K miles, so therefore you won't make your money back from a Bolt.
PS - Yes, my post uses tons of assumptions: Incentives for the Bolt, cost of electricity, cost of gas, average miles figures, and so on. You cannot make a post about this topic without doing so. Feel free to pick particular figures/assumptions apart, but pointing out "this is all based on estimates!" isn't very constructive within itself.
- greglindahl 10y agoThere are many reasons, besides lower cost, why people buy particular cars. Also, are you sure you aren't being confusing with how you're using "impractical"?
- Someone1234 10y agoUnaffordable is impractical. Most families cannot afford an extra $5K unless there is a reasonable amount of benefit to them, they don't have that kind of disposable income. So unless they can quantify why a Bolt is superior to a Hybrid (and cost definitely isn't a winning argument) you'll struggle to convince the average American household to own one. To me that is impractical.
- djrogers 10y ago> Unaffordable is impractical. Most families cannot afford an extra $5K unless there is a reasonable amount of benefit to them, they don't have that kind of disposable income If 'most families' acted in the rational manner you present above, then people wouldn't be leasing/financing new cars at the insanely high rate we do in the US. Given that there's a market for it though, the Bolt seems like a great option for GM to offer....
- pessimizer 10y agoThere is no relationship between "unaffordable" and "won't cost exactly as much as an equivalent hybrid until driven 450,000 miles." If you're equivocating, why not condemn the hybrid by comparing it with a traditional gas engine? I thought the point was to stop polluting? If not polluting has to be cheaper and easier, too, none of these conversations will make any sense.
- aetherson 10y agoHybrids seem likely to have more maintenance costs than pure EVs, but I think it's clear that EVs are still too expensive to be truly cost-efficient. If what you care about is lowest TCO, you can get a car of comparable size to the Bolt for like more than $15k cheaper, and of course you won't make that back up in fuel. I expect that the Bolt will also have crappy resale value, if, as I think we all expect, EVs continue to get substantially better over the next few years. The reason to get a Bolt right now is because you are ideologically committed to EVs or because the whole deal of mostly not having to deal with fueling up your car/liking the acceleration profile of an EV/etc., not because it's genuinely the lowest TCO.
- CarVac 10y agoToyota's hybrids have low maintenance costs; the transmission varies the gear ratio by electronic means and is overall far simpler than either a manual or automatic.
- aetherson 10y agoBut an EV presumably has all those advantages and also no gas engine to maintain.
- r00fus 10y agoMy 11 year old Prius (not even a plug-in) with 150k miles - No engine, brake or transmission maint costs whatsoever (other than the basic manufacturer recommended checkups and minimal at that). On the downside is that it's not fully EV, still stinky gasoline.
- ansible 10y agoI expect that the Bolt will also have crappy resale value... The battery pack replacement is a major maintenance cost, even if everything else is running fine. That's something a used EV buyer should take into account.
- 10y ago
- gnicholas 10y agoAlso, the Camry Hybrid is a much larger car. It seats more people, hauls more stuff, and is safer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ramy_d 10y agoI don't know anything about car ownership, but if it's more expensive to buy, but cheaper to operate, how does that conclude to being impractical for the general public? shouldn't things like interior space, handling, durability and craftsmanship determine its practicality? I'd say the biggest simplification in your analysis is only factoring cost, but not the cars themselves. Again, what do I know, right?
- maxerickson 10y agoThe Camry wins on all the other metrics too. Unless you are trying to fill a small parking space or something.
- runjake 10y agoHow did you arrive at it costing $10 to recharge its 238 mile battery? That seems way high. For your post to matter, you should really cite figures or at least detail your math a bit.
- ramy_d 10y agohttp://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/10/27/141766341/the-price-of-electricity-in-your-state http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/10/27/141766341/the-p... I assumed he used california prices. I live in canada and electricity is half the price as it is in cali based on that website (but the weather could affect millage as well).
- maxerickson 10y agoAverage US electric price is $0.12. So 60 kw-h is $7.20. Brings the breakeven miles down a fair bit, and I guess it should be possible to have quite lot cheaper electricity for charging (and lots of people will have to do the calculation with higher prices).
- peter303 10y agoIn Colorado the fixed fees nearly double the rate if you are a smaller consumer of 100 KWH a month.
- pilom 10y agoI totally agree, but your average EV driver who charges at home is going to use way more than 100 kwh/month.
- bzbarsky 10y ago> Average US electric price is $0.12. This number (which actually varies somewhat widely depending on which source you look at) hides a huge standard deviation. For example, http://www.eia.gov/electricity/state/ http://www.eia.gov/electricity/state/ lists the overall number at $0.1044 but by that ranges from $0.0776 to $0.1705 if we ignore the Alaska and Hawaii outliers. And even then, the number this lists for Massachusetts is $0.1535 but my bill (in Masachusetts) say $0.1906.... Of course gas prices vary quite widely state to state too.
- deelowe 10y agoAs an EV owner, the bigger benefit is the vastly simplified maintenance schedule. I don't know how the TCO works out, but in general, the EV is much less of a pain compared to my wife's ICE.
- fillskills 10y agoMy business runs on Toyotas. Hundreds of them. Not one single breakdown in an entire year.
- radiorental 10y agoYou may have misread the original comment. Breakdowns and maintenance schedules are not the same thing. Breaks, fluids etc.
- mywittyname 10y agoEVs still need lots of the expensive maintenance associated with gas cars (like tires, brake systems). If you compare maintenance costs on KBB between cars and their EV counterparts, you'll see that EVs have about 10% maintenance cost discounts over their gasoline counterparts. It helps that maintenance on gas cars has been reduced dramatically due to advances in chemistry and material science, allowing for very long maintenance intervals and "lifetime" fluids in transmissions, cooling systems, and differentials.
- radiorental 10y agoI'd take that 10% number with a large mouthful of salt as it's a basic projection at this point in time. Of the few who have pushed their teslas to 200k they've documented very low costs as compared to ice. More moving parts simply means more failure costs over time. But at this point in time, we do not have hard data to compare ice with ev. Also, simply incorrect on breaks. Regenerative breaks means rotors and pads have a much much longer service interval.
- 10y ago
- sremani 10y agoThere is a Volt out in the wild that is running @ 353K (http://www.voltstats.net/Stats/Details/1579 http://www.voltstats.net/Stats/Details/1579). So to assume that Bolt will not make 400K is still up to be tested.
- pfranz 10y agoI'm not sure why cars eventually get scrapped, but I have a 13 year old car with 130k. Other things started breaking which make driving bothersome. Cloth started drooping from the headliner, the glovebox got loose and stopped closing, leather seats crack. I'm happy that cars last longer and longer, but I'm not sure how practical 400k is for any car unless a lot of care is put into it.
- pjc50 10y agoIn the UK, I'd get rather different numbers: the Camry hybrid fuel tank is 70L, petrol is currently ~£1.20/l, pound at 1.22 to the dollar (thanks Brexit), so a full tank would be $102.48. That gives a saving of $74/680m or breakeven around the 50k miles point, if my maths is correct.
- sremani 10y agoYes, Gasoline in US is cheaper compared to other parts of world.
- chiph 10y agoActually, the cost of the fuel itself is slightly cheaper in the UK because they've got a lower delivery cost (smaller country, shorter pipelines & tanker truck routes). The difference is, of course, taxes. There are proposals in the US to change how states collect tax from cars if electric vehicles gain widespread adoption. Currently the highway trust fund gets most of it's money from the motor-fuels tax and that will dry up. Mileage-based taxation is being looked at, where your odometer reading would be collected via the OBD-II port.
- kbenson 10y agoSo, in Northern California where I live, gasoline is $2.50/gallon, so to fill the Camry's 17 gallon tank it's $42.50, and for 680 miles that's $0.0625/mile. If I can get the baseline rate in my area, I pay $0.12025/kwh. Assuming there's a 10% loss on charging (no idea what the actual loss is, so just choosing 10%) the 60kw battery, that's $7.9365, and for 238 miles that's $0.0333/mile. That's a savings of $0.0292/mile. If you drive 1000 miles a month (average), that's $29.20 in savings a month, or $350.40 a year in fuel costs (assuming base gas/electricity prices inline with what I have here). If you think gas prices will average $3.00/gallon for the lifetime of the car, the fuel savings are $41.80/mo per 1000 miles, $500.40 a year in fuel costs for 12,000 miles, and evens out at just under 125k miles. For $2.00/gallon the 1000 mile savings are $16.70, $200 for a 12,000 mile year. That said, I think I average about 20,000 miles a year on the family car that we use to ferry kids to/from school and most daily errands. The very important thing to consider though is whether or not you have access to free public charging. If you can find a free public charger and work it into your schedule in some way (maybe run some errands by foot in the area), you might be able to eliminate almost all of your home charging. If I was able to do really good at this, and only home charge for 10% of my usage on average (probably a tall order), and assuming that availability of free chargers doesn't change drastically for the worse, at current gas prices that would put my average (12,000 miles) yearly savings at $710.04. I consider $3.00/gallon a more likely average over that time, and that puts the yearly savings at $860.04, and it evens out at just under 73k miles. . That's not super compelling when compared to a Camry Hybrid, but it may be cheaper overall, depending on how the future unfolds. That said, if what others are saying and Hybrids have increased maintenance costs, it may be enough to make electric the clear winner in this comparison, but I don't know.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoAvg Chicago gas price in the past few years has been $3.50. That's $60 to fill that tank, not $37 for Chicagoans and others in urban areas with high gas prices. Avg 3-5 cents kwh for overnight charging here via ComEd's hourly pricing system. Assuming a decent level of inefficiency here via the charging process and ComEd's variable rates after 8pm I'm closer to $3 to charge than $10. So the Camry gets 3x the range, but at 20x the cost. The Bolt is 6-7x more economical per mile for me in Chicago, which is fairly impressive. Not sure how that plays out from a real dollar perspective, but I imagine after incentives the Bolt might be the cheaper option. I also imagine an EV car is a simpler machine than a ICE car, so you may have maintenance and reliability benefits. Personally, the complexity of a hybrid is a pretty big turn off. I'd rather just get a lower HP ICE car that naturally gets good milaeage and deal with worse performance than go the hybrid route. The nice thing with electric is you get all these cost savings and you get some decent performance as well. The Bolt does 0-60 under 7 seconds. The Camry Hybrid is almost 10 seconds.