5 ms·
Hands up who would happily trade 5mm extra thickness for 32G, 8 cores and a bigger battery? For me its a no-brainer... And I'll wager for anyone else who wants
by gaius 10y ago
Hands up who would happily trade 5mm extra thickness for 32G, 8 cores and a bigger battery? For me its a no-brainer... And I'll wager for anyone else who wants a workhorse not a fashion accessory...
- noir_lord 10y agoI currently use a Vostro 17" beast (7lbs) as I really don't care about thinness or lightness at all, I'm a 200lb 6ft bloke so carrying it around/resting it on my knee isn't an issue. This trend towards thin/light everything at the expense of upgrade-ability and repair-ability confuses me but I'm not the target demographic.
- goodwink 10y agoI'd like to see that used on a plane in economy. Given that I travel a lot and don't always end up in business/first, this is one of the first questions I ask myself when considering any new laptop.
- gaius 10y agoBut how does extreme thinness help there? I got alot of work done on planes with what passed for a laptop in the 1990s...
- JimDabell 10y agoNot so much size, but weight. If your carry-on allowance is 7kg and you don't check baggage, having a laptop that weighs 3kg like the Vostro 17" is a big deal. If you've got a heavy laptop, you've got to either bring less stuff with you on your trip, or go through the hassle of checking baggage.
- knieveltech 10y agoWhat percentage of your time over it's entire lifespan is spent using a it on a plane?
- jonknee 10y agoBeing a 6' tall 200lb person will be worse in economy than whatever laptop you're trying to use.
- uxp100 10y agoProbably depends on what you do. And, I've luckily really never had to repair a laptop. Never drop my phone either, except a tragic drop of a blackberry pearl from 2 feet onto concrete that killed it. 60% or my work is through SSH, 30% writing in outlook, and 10% in various trace analyzers and debuggers. When it came time to upgrade my work laptop, I just asked for the lightest one I could get. A 15" with an extended battery I felt was irritatingly heavy to lug around. My personal laptop is a 2009 Dell 13". Not very thin, but light. (Irritatingly enough, outlook is probably more demanding on my laptop than the debuggers and analyzers)
- noir_lord 10y agoAbsolutely depends on what I do, I don't travel on planes and 99% of laptop usage is client meetings, sofa programming (that is in the sofa not programming the sofa though with IoT that won't be long) and coffee shops so big and heavy isnt an issue if it gets me the things I want.
- toxican 10y agoI just want to meet the consumer who looked at the old MBP and thought, "wow this is far too thick!". And the same goes for cell phones. Thinner is better, but only to a certain point and certainly not at the expense of battery life and features.
- strange_quark 10y agoOk I'll bite. I'd like the power of the 15" MBP, but after having the 15" in 2008 which I found to be too heavy to carry with me in my bag constantly, I've always bought the 13" Mac laptop (had a 2011 Air, now a 2015 Pro). I find the current 13" Pro to be about as heavy as I would like to comfortable carry in my backpack for hours at a time. I appreciate that the new 15" MBP is only .5 lbs heaver than the current 13" Pro which makes it a real option for me.
- adamors 10y agoYeah, I agree. I have a 15" MBP from 2008 and that thing is heavy. Was eyeing the 13" only for the weight.
- bennyg 10y agoThe real question: If the new 15" MBP was the same weight as last generation and included the new Kaby Lake processor, more RAM, better battery, etc. would you pass on it for the weight?
- lmm 10y agoYou could say that about every feature though. If they hadn't bothered improving the battery but had refreshed the processor, RAM, and dropped the weight, would you pass on that just for the battery? Each individual feature is going to be marginal for most users, but together they add up to making the upgrade worthwhile.
- et-al 10y agoThat's why there used to be two lines: the Air and the Pro. The new MBPs announced the past week feel more like ultraportable machines versus potential desktop-replacement workhouses. If Apple had the same announcement last week, but instead of calling MBP and calling it just the MacBook, people wouldn't be in as much of an uproar (aside from the fact that the MBPs are delayed yet again). USB-C and thinness are great--no one is arguing against that--but for a Pro line, to sacrifice utility and power is foolhardy. However it seems like Apple is going down some path of convergence, which doesn't look good for many professionals.
- lmm 10y agoWhat on earth would you want/need 32G or 8 cores for? My laptop is for doing work but that just sounds like an obscene spec unless you're doing 3D rendering on it or something. 16G is plenty, and while I'm not that fussed about thinness per se I wouldn't want my laptop to be any heavier.
- zobzu 10y agoIve 16gb but everything fits under 8. Til i kick in an osx vm. Then i need an additional 8gb easily. Macosx tends to eat memory for breakfast
- gaius 10y agoI want to run lots of VMs to simulate different network topologies. But lots of people these days can make good use of power: 3D as you say, CFD and FEA and other engineering applications, computational chemistry or bio, machine learning, financial modelling...
- akvadrako 10y agoIf I was running network simulations I'd certainly run all those VMs on a server cluster and not my laptop.
- _ph_ 10y agoMy iMac with 32G of memory sometimes gives me even out of memory dialogs because Safari has leaked about 30 gigabytes of memory by sitting idle with many tabs open. Reopening Safari fixes this, but it shows that these days even web browsing can put an enormous pressure onto the memory usage. And if you are running VMs on your machine you can use up 32G fast. The thing is, the macbook pro is Apples "workstation" machine, by price and by the fact that they don't offer many alternatives. So people expect it to support workstation loads, and 32G and 8 cores is not excessive for that today.
- afro88 10y ago"640K ought to be enough for anybody" I use my MBP for dev work, and would love to have faster compile times for example
- nicolas_t 10y agoYes especially since the new macbook pro is 250g lighter but you have to carry 250g in adapters... I have a macbook for portability but for the macbook pro, I don't need it to be light or thinner, I need it to be powerful.
- muad 10y agoPerformance is the single biggest issue keeping me from getting a new MBP. 16GB just flat out isn't enough.