3 ms·
The talking only confirmed their community's observed actions up to that point. Anyone paying attention knew what they were doing, the emails just made it "cry
by hga 17y ago
The talking only confirmed their community's observed actions up to that point. Anyone paying attention knew what they were doing, the emails just made it "crystal clear".
And it's funny you should bring up Chicxulub and the K-T extinction event. When the Alvarez team proposed that hypothesis, it was not ... warmly welcomed. But they were allowed to argue their point and the community eventually agreed they were (likely) correct. If their work had been in the climate science domain I don't think we would have seen the same outcome. I know we wouldn't have seen the same process.
With regards to the "consensus" that the "planet is warming", that "fact" has not been true for the last decade or so, so that "fact" is indeed potentially irrelevant (we need to wait a bit longer to be sure).
- nollidge 17y ago> If their work had been in the climate science domain I don't think we would have seen the same outcome. I know we wouldn't have seen the same process. But of course, that is entirely your own conjecture. You "know" this for a fact.
- hga 17y agoI "know" this as a "fact" of human behavior. Yes, it's an appeal to authority (myself :-), but I've been watching politicized science for about three and a half decades so I'm pretty confident about my judgment.
- nollidge 17y agoRegarding the "planet has not been warming for the last decade" claim, here's why that doesn't disprove global warming, even if true (tl;dr: 1998 was an anomaly): http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2006/04/warming-stopped-in-1998.php http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2006/04/warming-stoppe...