9 ms·
Publishers Are Rethinking Those ‘Around the Web’ Ads
- detaro 10y agoSurprised it took this long. These things are incredibly jarring and low-quality, and actively try to redirect users away from the publishers sites into a rabbithole of even more links. If they supposedly pay so well, I wonder where the money for that comes from. Just high ad-density?
- chipperyman573 10y ago>If they supposedly pay so well, I wonder where the money for that comes from. Just high ad-density? Probably because ad-networks pay per click, and if you have something SO clickbaity like these ads there's a lot of ad clicks. For example if google ads and Outbrain both pay $7 per thousand clicks (I have never used either so this is just a random number) and google ads bring in 1000 clicks while outbrain brings in 3000, you're making 3 times as much money.
- ryan-c 10y agoSome ad networks pay per click, some pay per thousand impressions. The numbers I've seen tend to be several dollars per thousand impressions, or a significant fraction of a dollar to several dollars per click. Random blog post I just found talking about rates: https://www.hochmanconsultants.com/cost-of-ppc-advertising/ https://www.hochmanconsultants.com/cost-of-ppc-advertising/
- mbesto 10y agoFrom someone I know who advertised on Outbrain, he said the CTR was way higher on Outbrain than it was on AdWords...so while we may all sit here and talk about how crappy those ads are for general use, they do in fact drive traffic.
- chipperyman573 10y agoThat doesn't surprise me at all. Hell, I've clicked on them before and I could tell exactly what they were. I'd imagine that the average user probably clicks on them significantly more than they click on any other type of ad.
- robryan 10y agoIt is mostly just an arbitrage, the site advertising their click bait content just needs to get more money from the numerous ads on their page than they spent on the outbrain click.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoDoesn't surprise me at all. Every time I've clicked on one it's been because I've been under the impression it's another story on the Independent or whoever. Of course those clicks generated 100% bounce rate.
- FussyZeus 10y agoThat's because they aren't immediately recognizable as ads. More deception, in this case leading to a site with a lot more deception. Ad networks need to die, and about 70% of news organizations also need to die. Then I think we'll be in a good market balance to where journalism can actually be profitable again.
- bbcbasic 10y agoUltimately the money comes from a mark further down the line. For example some poor sucker desperate to fix their health problem spends hundreds on a flakey high margin product, be it physical or digital. Sure there are legit ads too but I'd guess the greyhat stuff will give higher EPC. Google ads takes the long term view and doesn't tolerate shit like that. They are very strict and would rather not take that money and destroy their brand. Result? People still use Google to search for stuff.
- prawn 10y ago"Google ads takes the long term view and doesn't tolerate shit like that. They are very strict and would rather not take that money and destroy their brand. Result? People still use Google to search for stuff." Are you sure? I've seen loads and loads of some of the trashiest ads through Google's ad network.
- manicdee 10y agoAnd at least Google iAds give you the tiny little logo in the corner for you to click so you can report the ad that tries very hard to look like a download button :(
- reitanqild 10y agoOnly they never seem to quite get it: Google: here is x dating site, Me: click, mark as irrelevant. Google: here is y dating site Me: irrelevant Google: z dating site? Me: nope Google: lets try an ad for x dating site again then Me: actually, you got my mail, all my searches for the last 10 years and still you cannot find anything more relevant for a happily married sw engineer? <reaches for my adblocker>
- dc_gregory 10y agoUnless happily married SW engineers with your search history whom mark dating sites as irrelevant are great for dating site conversions.
- omegaworks 10y agoThe ad content is designed to look as though it is part of the source website, so claims made appear to be those of the originating site. Outbrain seems to be the web's answer to native content marketing. Unfortunately NYT, Huffpo, Wapo don't realize by putting these on their legitimate articles they're allowing these third parties to siphon away some of their credibility.
- kristianc 10y agoThis - they're bought programmatically. The buyer submits metadata (headline, URL, image, etc) to a bidding exchange and they're formatted to look like they're part of the relevant site on the fly.
- M_Grey 10y agoHonest question: How many people are left without some form of ad-blocking? It seems to have become incredibly ubiquitous, and when malicious ads aren't teaching people to go and get it, loud and obnoxious ads are.
- legodt 10y agoMobile users. There just aren't any pleasant ad free browser experiences for stock mobile phone users. Firefox for Android is quite poor and fixing through chrome requires root, something most users are not going to be doing
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI pipe all my reading into Pocket, which does a great job of stripping the ads out.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eropple 10y agoI have heard good things about block-this, which creates a VPN connection that just strips out ads, but it seems (unscientifically, because Android doesn't track VPN battery usage) a battery suck.
- revelation 10y agoThe web must be hell to people without multiple levels of adblocking extensions. Meanwhile, I'm confused the NYT is now citing random people from Twitter: One Twitter user asked The Guardian in April: “Don’t these @Outbrain articles kind of undermine the integrity of news outlets?” That must be Outbrain inside.
- gregmac 10y agoThese ads specifically were the ads that drove me to ad blockers. I resisted for years, as I took the stance I simply didn't visit sites that had overly obnoxious ads. I've had flash turned off for years so that likely cut down on a lot of that garbage anyway. Then these fake "Other things you might like" ads started appearing around many sites. Occasionally somewhat relevant, but always click-bait headlines. I was even tricked once or twice early on, since I hadn't yet recognized those as ads. Then they started becoming outright obnoxious, and everywhere, and one day I just lost it and installed an adblocker. Now I can't imagine how I'd ever go back.
- BipolarElsa 10y agoU-Block Origins. Always.
- pjc50 10y agoYup. And I blocked Taboola and Outbrain in my hosts file years ago after some particularly unpleasant ads of rotting teeth. To me they're a symbol of low-quality misleading advertising. I think there might be a place for good cross-advertising of articles, but that seems to not be what the public clicks on.
- davemel37 10y agoIt has less to do with what the public clicks and more to do with the level of quality competition amongst advertisers. As more and more brands get smart about native, the networks will push out the arbitrage sites and other bad actors. Bad advertisers is a sign that an ad network actually works but hasnt matured yet.
- a3n 10y agoEven without these types of ads, mere performance compels me to use an ad blocker. I've recently been playing around with different Linux distros, and so installed Firefox multiple times if it wasn't already there. I'm the type of person who queues up a number of tabs for reading. At the NYT, at about four or five tabs open, the laptop becomes unusable, because of all the ad downloading. And now, the absolute first thing I do after opening FF the first time is to install ublock origin. The web is all but unusable for me without it.
- intrasight 10y agoI've not seen those in some time. Thank you uBlock Origin. On Android I use Firefix with Javascript disabled and in desktop mode. And if it's unreadable, I prefix url with about:reader?url=
- sotojuan 10y agoHeh, these ads were so bad to the point of being ridiculous. I had fun reading them because they seemed so self aware and like a parody of ads.
- loudandskittish 10y agoI've always enjoyed some of the juxtapositions, like some article about sexism with one of those things suggesting readers might also like "Top 10 smoking hot celebrities who got UGLY!" And they I have to wonder, do those things even pay enough to be worth it?
- ericthor 10y agoOh yes the "chumbox" https://theawl.com/a-complete-taxonomy-of-internet-chum-de0b7a070a2d https://theawl.com/a-complete-taxonomy-of-internet-chum-de0b...
- mrgreenfur 10y agoThis is a great way to look at these things, love the analogy.
- colanderman 10y agoThat's funny, I got through the first paragraph and thought "wow, that was a short article". To my brain, chumboxes are what mark the end of an article.
- austinz 10y agoWhat a great summary of the utter baseness of this type of advertising: a stomach-turning body horror image I never wanted to see, some article calling strangers "morons" based on some stupid superficiality, and gossip about the private lives of strangers that is, quite frankly, none of my business. That being said, if these companies vanished tomorrow it wouldn't be a complete positive either, since the fine sociopaths of the advertising industry would simply use the resultant vacuum to come up with something even more contemptible. Fuck that industry.
- tyho 10y agoThe link just shows me a login form. Mirror: https://archive.fo/zu1Wp https://archive.fo/zu1Wp
- flashman 10y agoOne of my least-favourite parts of video game news outlet Rock Paper Shotgun is the box of Taboola links at the end of the article. They never have anything to do with video games. The sad part it, I'm sure RPS gets a lot of money from that box of links, meaning if they ditched it, I'd get less content from them. I would greenlight their site in my adblocker but it's just not worth the crap fiesta of ads.
- throwaway1892 10y agoI removed RPS from my whitelist when they added that box. I agree it's crap, even compared to the other ads.
- brainfire 10y agoWeirdly, "subscribing"/"supporting" RPS doesn't seem to remove the ads, or if it does then that's not indicated on the page about it.
- st8675309 10y agoFascinating watching this go down. It's like capitalism vs religion but the iteration cycle is months/years not decades/millennium.
- cloudjacker 10y agoIf only advertising networks had the same disdain that perceived ponzi schemes had everyone throws money at the click through rate casino, anyone doing studies on their ROI, or do we hand waive it away by saying they were targeting wrong
- thr0waway1239 10y agoOK, great, but let us see what is going to replace them. My guesses: a) more aggressive retargeting - "Customers also bought" suggestions from Amazon will now follow you around the web even when you complete a purchase b) sign in using Amazon account to read articles c) retargeting with social proof (you didn't buy X from company Y, but here is a testimonial from a friend of a friend who thinks X is great) d) revival of popup ads, only a little more beautifully designed - with large clickable area and small, nearly invisible, too far above the fold close buttons
- Senji 10y agoI'm not logging in with diddly squat to access your page NYTIMES
- davemel37 10y agoIt is surprising to me how little people seem to know about native/ content amplification ads. Here is a brief primer: First, as far as quality goes, there are different networks with different quality policies. In general, Outbrain is very strict, Taboola is also, but less so, and RevContent, Content.ad, and the 50 or so other native networks (including mantis targeting marijuana publishers and jewish content network targeting orthodox jewish publishers), Like all channels, there are good actors and bad actors. Native ads - defined as ,turning the atomic consumption unit into an ad unit, work really well because they dont require switching context. (i.e. adwords, Facebook newsfeed ads, indeed job postings, etc...) These ads work really well when done properly. (High contrast images, compelling but very descriptive headline that qualifies the visitor, and constant freshness in both images and headlines... pointing to a high quality advertorial that presells a product or service, with links to purchase within the content and as banners on the side of the page.) Any new channel that is very effective will attract affiliate marketers and some bad actors, but eventually, the networks police themselves, and they become very effective ad networks for everyone (i.e. Facebook newsfeed ads are basically as main stream now as Adwords is, but 5 years ago, it was full of shady affiliates. It still is, but much less so.) In general, There are five types of native advertisers. 1. Advertising arbitrage sites - These are the the celebrity articles, etc... the folks who do this right are making bank, but for every person who succeeds at this, hundreds try and fail. It is a real skill. It also requires a large bankroll since you get paid net 30-45 for the ads you place. 2. Affiliate marketers primarily promoting info products and digital products - These are the health ads (i.e. secret fruit loses belly fat or nail fungus home remedy ads) and the software security ads. One thing you can be sure of... when it comes to rampant affiliate marketers, if it wasn't driving sales, they would move on to another channel. 3. Direct advertisers (most notably LendingClub & bankrate - I think)Don't be surprised to start seeing Proctor and Gamble to be running detergent native ads and typical Ecommerce sites running ads to their content. 4. Publishers growing their audience. - This is the most natural usage of native ads, but lends itself to arbitrage like the first type of advertiser. I worked with a few very large publishers buying ads on Taboola and Facebook news feed and arbitraging it by serving up Taboola native ads successfully. 5. Remarketing - These networks let you remarket you visitors and I think criteo (for sure some do) run remarketing through taboola, etc... You can also do it natively in the network by using their remarketing pixel. If you do go this route, expect CPCs in the US on solid publishers to run you over $1.00 and smaller publishers in the $0.30-$0.60 range. You can still get the junk traffic for about $0.10 a click, but not much cheaper. All in All, I think native ads will find their place and be a net positive for the internet...but clearly we aren't there yet. One thing is for sure. Affiliate marketers who are spending $10-$20k/day on Native ads, are not losing money. It works and it works well... and not just for arbitrage or info products. I've run successful Ecommerce product ads via native successfully. Edit: Spelling
- samdung 10y agoI wonder how Taboola and Outbrain keep coming back even when i manually blocked them on Adblock and Adblock Plus.
- Gaelan 10y agoDo you have acceptable ads on? They somehow managed to get whitelisted.
- chris_wot 10y agoThese ad networks tend to distribute redirect JavaScript. I know of at least one newsroom that has editors all getting redirected to spam sites. From their own publication!
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoOne of the stunning things to me was discovering that Edge uses Outbrain and Taboola type links on the browser's New Tab page... And you could get malicious fake virus pages right off the home screen of Windows 10's default browser.
- MarkMc 10y agoIt's interesting to compare Outbrain to Google. Google has all my search history, a list of all the AdSense websites I visit, my YouTube history, my location history, ten years of my email history, my Android app history, my Play Store purchase history. They have a large number of PhD engineers working to develop the best internet advertising algorithms. And yet when Time or Forbes want to display an ad that will generate the most money, Google is beaten by a company that is simply focused on catchy ads. I realise that Google's higher standards (and perhaps higher commission) put their ads at a disadvantage in terms of publisher revenue, but I thought that their huge advantage in targeting ads would more than compensate.
- cm2012 10y agoI spend a lot of money on advertising. Google's non search stuff is not nearly as good as FB for targeting.
- cyborgx7 10y agoCan't wait for the ad industry to die. I'll do what I can to help that process along.
- 3chelon 10y agoIt astounds me the number of so-called quality news outlets that seem happy use these providers. Do they even know what kind of NSFW trash is appearing on their readers' browsers?
- Jordrok 10y agoThank goodness that the publishers are finally starting to catch on. Outbrain, Taboola, and their ilk have always been utter trash and the sooner they die the better off we'll all be.
- 627467 10y agoI keep asking: if you're a serious publisher, shouldn't it be your job to create/curate the right content for your readership? Isn't it your job to know your readers? Leaving screen real-estate (and really substantial amount) to random third party algorithms who most likely than not will be spamming my eyes with unrelated and sensationalist content is disrespectful.