4 ms·
I'm kind amazed at the tone deafness of several comments in this thread. I get that as a larger effect, reducing the success rate of scammers hurts their busine
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
I'm kind amazed at the tone deafness of several comments in this thread. I get that as a larger effect, reducing the success rate of scammers hurts their business, but if I'm dealing with someone who's been hit because they weren't adequately prepared, I'm gonna recommend they pay the ransom if they want their stuff back. Because I'm trying to recommend what's best for them. People could be losing their entire family's memories for the last two decades here. (I find for many consumers, photos is their singular valuable on their PC.)
Most of us in this thread ARE adequately prepared with backups, so it's easy to forget that yeah, someone should probably value their family memories over an infinitesimal effect on the scammer business by not paying. A lot of people here seem to suggest lying to or misleading people to believing they can't get their stuff back is a solution, while ignoring that it leaves people... unable to get their stuff back.
- wlesieutre 10y agoWhen Transmission had an infected release a couple of months ago, I remember reading that the malware had in-progress features to encrypt Time Machine drives. It gets installed, waits a couple of days, locks up your hard drive and any backup drives that you connect, and there's nothing to do about it. That's enough to hose 99% of users, even the ones following traditionally sufficient practices. You're only safe if you have offsite backups with drives that didn't mount to your computer recently.
- derefr 10y ago> You're only safe if you have offsite backups with drives that didn't mount to your computer recently. Or if your backup solution is—from the perspective of the computer being backed up—an append-only store. Like a box of tapes, or Tarsnap using restricted keys, or Arq pointed at a versioned S3 bucket, or a NAS exposing an iSCSI target backed by an LVM thin pool LV with automatic daily snapshots. Sadly, as far as I know, no turn-key hardware "home backup" or "home NAS" product is in that category, though.
- wlesieutre 10y agoI've contemplated setting up a small home server with write-only shares for backups, but ended up not doing it because of the cost and time. If there were a reasonably priced off-the-shelf product for this, I'd recommend it to everyone I know. On the other hand, if there were an off-the-shelf product for this, it would probably have unpatched security issues two weeks after you bought it, and if it were in common use you'd see ransomware targeting it. Tough problem to solve if you're not running and maintaining your own devices. I suppose tarsnap or S3 would be the way to go, I'm just not that into cloud backups. Maybe it's time to get over that.
- derefr 10y ago> if there were an off-the-shelf product for this, it would probably have unpatched security issues two weeks after you bought it I'm waiting for the NAS "appliance" that's actually running CoreOS, and then just relies on running the :latest tag of some popular Docker image (and not a fork of it that they'll forget to update eventually; the original upstream image), plus a bit of config-file glue generated into a shared volume from a web-UI service running in another container. (Bonus points if the second container is only started up, for an hour at a time, when you press a button on the NAS, WPS-style.) Such a design is essentially the same as shipping the device's OS as "firmware" with auto-updates, but for the fact that the vendor themselves isn't anywhere within the path of creating or distributing those updates. Which, in the end, makes all the difference.
- tempestn 10y agoFortunately, there do exist several inexpensive and user-friendly incremental cloud backup solutions. For a few bucks a month you can back up everything to Cloudflare or Backblaze and be fine even if your primary copy and recent backups all get hosed.
- KB1JWQ 10y agoCrashPlan. Not Cloudflare.
- dspillett 10y ago> You're only safe if you have offsite backups with drives that didn't mount to your computer recently. Or doesn't mount to the source computer(s) at all. My active machines push backups to intermediate locations, and the true backup locations pull from there and create snapshots. Status information used to verify the backup process is passed back the other way. The active machines don't (in fact can't) authenticate with the main backups and vice versa, reducing the likelihood that someone hacking into one can easily compromise the other at the same time. I wouldn't expect the man on the street to muck around setting this up though, but many cloud backup solutions effectively do this if they don't have an easy "delete snapshot" API call or similar. I'm surprised that the "soft offline" backup side of it isn't marketed more actively. Maybe no one thinks they can adequately explain the benefit to the man on the street without putting them off by it being a little more complicated than a simple file copy.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThe problem is, the file can get locked and still be available for backup. Smart enough malware will send an encrypted version when accessed over LAN while local access is unimpeded for some time. There is a reasonable chance that your backup will end up with encrypted files. This is why you need more than one.
- firethief 10y agoThat only matters for content created after the malware was installed though, assuming the backups' snapshot interval is reasonable. The malware doesn't usually hang around very long, does it? If it's detected while it can still hide, it still has the decryption keys.
- serendipitous 10y ago> it still has the decryption keys No, they (usually) work similar to PGP/GPG, i.e. each file is encrypted with a different AES key and the AES key is encrypted with a public RSA key. The original AES key for a particular file is immediately deleted from memory after the file is encrypted and the private RSA key (needed for decrypting the AES key that is stored in the file) only ever gets delivered to the system if the ransom is paid.