3 ms·
Although in Europe land ownership was by feudal lords as well. So not a strong argument for or against. I'm following up on the energy crisis lead, that seems p
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Although in Europe land ownership was by feudal lords as well. So not a strong argument for or against. I'm following up on the energy crisis lead, that seems promising.
I don't suppose it is lost on people that if the land provides your needs, it seems you don't develop a lot of knowledge, and if it doesn't you do[1]. And that correlates at least loosely with myths about losing access to the garden of eden by eating from the tree of knowledge.
[1] Sort of a variation on the maxim, "Success makes you complacent, failure makes you smarter."
- jernfrost 10y agoNot entirely true. Both the British and e.g. Dutch had land divided up in a more market oriented fashion and farmers produced and sold for a market. The bad luck for South America was that they inherited the Portuguese and Spanish structures of society. Europe was not a homogenous mass of countries. Success within Europe varied widely and South America copied the institutions and land laws of the most backwards countries in Europe. Portugal and Spain could maintain an illusion of success based on all the wealth they got from their plunder and exploitation.
- pipio21 10y agoBackward countries in Europe referred to Spain and Portugal in 15 century is completely nuts. In that century Spain and Portugal were way more advanced that England or any other part of Europe. For example, Cadiz or Cordoba were way richer than most cities in Europe. Spain forbid slavery in 1512 and declared all native people equal to Europeans. England by contrast only forbid slavery in 18XX, and only because they used it as an excuse to occupy and colonize Africa. You could not compare the West conquest of the US(and the extermination of the native population) at the end of 19th century, start of 20th century, with things like rail roads to the Spanish colonization that ended before industrialization. I only expect you not to be American, first because if you are you are probably over some land stolen and plundered from some native people, and second because it is the country that currently plunders and exploits other countries like Iraq, Afghanistan or Libya. You could say the same thing about the US today if you remove the illusion of success that means the petrodollar and the exploitation of the rest of the world that it represents.
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"You could not compare the West conquest of the US(and the extermination of the native population)" Somewhere around 90% of the indigenous population of North America had succumbed to disease before the United States even existed.