5 ms·
I think this theory "fits the facts" as we know them but for me it fails for me on South America. South America was much more like early Europe in that it has b
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I think this theory "fits the facts" as we know them but for me it fails for me on South America. South America was much more like early Europe in that it has both a diversity of groups, geographic features that make it hard to conquer, and competition. So what was missing that left the empire of Brazil falling behind when Europe was racing ahead?
- metafunctor 10y agoThis is an interesting question. For some reason, the European scientific culture to question everything and preferring “useful knowledge” apparently did not transfer to Brazil with the Portugese. Here's an excerpt from Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman!, discussing education in Brazil which I think is relevant: http://v.cx/2010/04/feynman-brazil-education http://v.cx/2010/04/feynman-brazil-education
- rmk 10y agoThanks for that excerpt. It was an entertaining read!
- Animats 10y agoI remember that section from decades ago, mostly because of Feynman writing: “When you take a lump of sugar and crush it with a pair of pliers in the dark, you can see a bluish flash. Some other crystals do that too. Nobody knows why. The phenomenon is called "triboluminescence.'". Reading that, I thought "could it be lasing?". A laser is two parallel mirrors around a medium with electrons in an excited state. Squeezing a crystal will produce electrical energy by piezoelectricity. Crushing a crystal will produce parallel planes, at least momentarily. So the preconditions for lasing exist. This is still an open question today. Lasing of crystals under pressure may have been observed in some exotic materials.[1] But it doesn't seem to be the main light-emission mechanism in triboluminescence. [1] http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2002ApPhL..81..460R http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2002ApPhL..81..460R
- metafunctor 10y agoA very long time ago, I read about this and experimented in a dark toilet after sunset. I did get the flash, but it wasn't terribly easy to get a flash with the small sugar crystals available to me at the time. The next day, there were ants after all that sugar on the toilet floor (also featured in Feynman's book), leading to further experiments ferrying ants :)
- wavefunction 10y agoIn Guns, Germs and Steel Jared Diamond claims that a large contributor to the disparity between Europe and the indigenous New World was due to the North-South aligned axis of the Americas versus the East-West major axis of Eurasia. Crops can often grow at different longitudes as long as their along the same latitude but the converse is not true. Thus the crops in the Americas were more specialized regionally because the folks who cultivated them and potential adopters had little reason to make any effort to spread the crops and reach the widespread diversity of foodstuffs available in the Eurasian continent. Obviously he lays out his other argued sources but this seemed to be a big one as far as something that encourages trade and interaction between civilizations.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoWouldn't a variety of crops also encourage trade? Get your winter yams here, in exchange for summer squash (or whatever.) I recall there being a mention made of the fact that South America doesn't have very many domesticatable animals.
- usrusr 10y agoParticularly none that were really suitable for transport. Good luck trading along the Andes with your turkey-carts. Another thing I seem to remember from that book is that we do have occasional evidence of various discoveries of the wheel in the Americas, it just never caught on due to lack of cart-pulling beasts. (skimmed the book: evidence of wheels in Mexico, but no Llamas north of the Darien gap) Besides, preindustrial transport did not happen anywhere on the scale required to transport bulk goods like base nutrients over the distance between latitudes of different biomes. Luxuries and spices, sure, but not basic foodstuff with low value per unit. Even the roman empire never really left their comfort zone of wheat-producing regions.
- wavefunction 10y agoThe other issue is the bottle-neck of the Isthmus of Panama. _All_ trade between North and South Americas would have needed to transit this corridor, unless some more complex system involving Caribbean island-hopping was developed.
- sodafountan 10y agoI'd say climate played a factor in Brazil and South America's economic progress. This article mentions nothing about climate, Europe during the winter months would be the perfect time to sit by a fireplace and solve hard problems. Notice how much of the countries and people living near the equator fail to have built great civilizations, humans just aren't as productive in the heat.
- p333347 10y ago> Notice how much of the countries and people living near the equator fail to have built great civilizations, humans just aren't as productive in the heat. I think Iraq, Egypt, Iran and India were all as hot as they are now and they all had some of the greatest civilizations. Historically these "countries" spread beyond current political borders which more or less encompasses a continuous stretch of land and I am talking in that sense.
- pipio21 10y ago"I think Iraq, Egypt, Iran and India were all as hot as they are now." Not really, we are talking 3000 to 4000 years ago and certainly climate was colder then. When we talk about Egypt we know there were very fertile land and cities then that are desert now. In Mesopotamia there were terrible deforestation done by humans that is recorded on documents and salinization of fertile lands that are now also desert but at the time supported millions of people. We also know there has been at least two terrible changes in climate that lasted at least years that made the Earth cold and dark linked to volcanic eruptions.
- flukus 10y agoNot to mention things like disease that spread more in equatorial areas. How many Einsteins died of something like malaria?
- icebraining 10y agoAs a Portuguese, what would surprise me is if they were able to overcome the dysfunctional culture we left them and race ahead. Remember that the guy who proclaimed independence was himself a Portuguese, and his son ruled as emperor until almost the 20th century, when his authority was so weak that it barely needed a push to fall.
- s_kilk 10y agoSupposedly, the animals available in South America aren't great candidates for domestication. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOmjnioNulo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOmjnioNulo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEYh5WACqEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEYh5WACqEk
- usrusr 10y agoIn cold, deforestation-ridden England, coal hit like crack. They switched to fossil fuels not because they could, they did so because they had to. Contrast this with the abundance of biological resources in Brazil: if you want growth, you simply cut down some more forest. Much easier, much more predictable, negative long term effects are only starting to be fully understood today and the understanding is still not sufficient to make it stop. It does not scale though, like the once-in-a-planet's-lifetime escalation of productivity that the switch to fossil caused in Europe. But they did not know that there either. If England had not grown out of the limited biological resources of their island, the industrialization might have never happened. Quick googling led me to this scan of an article from 1977: https://nature.berkeley.edu/er100/readings/Nef_1977.pdf https://nature.berkeley.edu/er100/readings/Nef_1977.pdf "An Early Energy Crisis and Its Consequences", looks like a very interesting read.
- WalterBright 10y agoA documentary I saw on TV (can't remember the name) explained it in terms of land ownership. South America was run essentially by feudal lords. There was little opportunity for regular people to acquire land and operate it. But in North America, settlers were offered land that they could own if they worked it. This produced an environment of many, many small businesses (farmers), forming the basis of a free market and the resulting dynamism.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAlthough in Europe land ownership was by feudal lords as well. So not a strong argument for or against. I'm following up on the energy crisis lead, that seems promising. I don't suppose it is lost on people that if the land provides your needs, it seems you don't develop a lot of knowledge, and if it doesn't you do[1]. And that correlates at least loosely with myths about losing access to the garden of eden by eating from the tree of knowledge. [1] Sort of a variation on the maxim, "Success makes you complacent, failure makes you smarter."
- jernfrost 10y agoNot entirely true. Both the British and e.g. Dutch had land divided up in a more market oriented fashion and farmers produced and sold for a market. The bad luck for South America was that they inherited the Portuguese and Spanish structures of society. Europe was not a homogenous mass of countries. Success within Europe varied widely and South America copied the institutions and land laws of the most backwards countries in Europe. Portugal and Spain could maintain an illusion of success based on all the wealth they got from their plunder and exploitation.
- pipio21 10y agoBackward countries in Europe referred to Spain and Portugal in 15 century is completely nuts. In that century Spain and Portugal were way more advanced that England or any other part of Europe. For example, Cadiz or Cordoba were way richer than most cities in Europe. Spain forbid slavery in 1512 and declared all native people equal to Europeans. England by contrast only forbid slavery in 18XX, and only because they used it as an excuse to occupy and colonize Africa. You could not compare the West conquest of the US(and the extermination of the native population) at the end of 19th century, start of 20th century, with things like rail roads to the Spanish colonization that ended before industrialization. I only expect you not to be American, first because if you are you are probably over some land stolen and plundered from some native people, and second because it is the country that currently plunders and exploits other countries like Iraq, Afghanistan or Libya. You could say the same thing about the US today if you remove the illusion of success that means the petrodollar and the exploitation of the rest of the world that it represents.
- pjc50 10y agoBrazil was recovering from being colonized by Portugal, no? Arguably the whole of South America still is, along with all of the interference of communists and the CIA. I suspect tropical disease may also have been important.
- SixSigma 10y agoWhile it's not quite Industrial Revolution the late 19th C saw China & South America get hit by El Nino floods. & drought. > Late Victorian Holocausts: El Niño Famines and the Making of the Third World is a book by Mike Davis about the connection between political economy and global climate patterns, particularly El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO). 50m Chinese & Indian starved to death from drought. 25m South Americans got wiped out by floods. "All we had left was our slaves", one Brazilian wrote. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Victorian_Holocausts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Victorian_Holocausts
- jernfrost 10y agoI suggest reading Adam Smiths wealth of nations from 1760s. It is rather ironic that such an old book actually describes these things very well. Adam Smith accurately predicted that South American would develop poorly compared to North America. What is good about Smith's description is that he includes the factors mentioned here as well as a number of others which together give a very good explanation for why the industrial revolution had to happen in Europe and England in particular. 1) As mentioned the fragmentation of Europe gave competition of ideas, and avoided the intellectual stagnation of the great arab and eastern empires. 2) Coast line and river relative to landmass is crucial. You thin land e.g. given more relative coastline than circular. Hence America, Africa and China are poor fits. You also want many rivers criss crossing and not just a few going one direction. WHY? Because before railroads, transport by water will be crucial. Massive amounts of specialization is needed for industrialization. That requires being able to ship products out to as many people as possible cheaply. You can only achieve that with lots of easily available water transport combined with high population density. There is no country fitting that description that Britain in the 1700s. No country had as high population density and high density of rivers and coastline relative to landmass as them. In fact the country starting a sort of earlier industrial revolution was the Netherlands which had a similar advantage. Due to being under the sea level, digging canals was very easy. So they could dig a lot of them and transport goods cheaply. The Netherlands had nothing else of important resources, they just had high population density combined with an extensive canal network. That made the Netherlands the richest country in the world per capita in the 1600s. 3) Institutions. Adam Smith compares these extensively between the North and South of America. The Portuguese and Spanish possessions had very unfavorable institutions and social structures for economic development. Unlike North America they let a few elites take all the land. It ended up like a sort of feudal system were people worked at the local castle and village for their "lord". In contrast North America was divided into lots of small patches of land with competing farmers selling their products in a free market. North America inherited British rule of law, rather than rule of men, so businessmen in North America could feel safe lending money or investing in ventures with more powerful individuals. In the south you could never know if you'd get your money back from some well connected individual, because written laws mattered little, but connections was everything. In short I think the receipt for industrialization is many small competing states, lots of rivers and coastline with dense population combined with strong institutions. By strong institutions one might instead say that rule of law is observed combined with some form of democratic or power sharing traditions.
- pipio21 10y agoI believe is climate. I have lived in Germany and in Brazil. Living in Germany is like living in Boston, Chicago or New York, but probably worse: There is winter and you die if you are not prepared. As hard as it sounds, this is a reality that forges the German culture, it puts you in your toes every year. I was born in Spain, and Spain is cold in winter, but cold being minus two or three Celsius degrees. Having to live with minus 30 degrees Celsius and everything covered by snow, and almost no sunlight is completely different. But living in Brazil is a shock because their winter is even less winter than in Spain, only Argentina and Chile has a similar winter to Spain and no part of the South hemisphere but New Zealand and Antarctica has something similar to Canada, Russia of North of North America. In fact, the Brazilians form South(colder) are totally different form the people of the North. More serious, less party going.