8 ms·
IoT Growing Faster Than the Ability to Defend It
- CommanderData 10y agoRouters should be adapting to growing IoT. The ability to easily prevent Internet access or access to certain country IP pools like China. A really easy way to manage routers e.g. through an app will help mitigate the threat somewhat. But it would require a unified API or some sort and not installing CF.
- icebraining 10y agoRouters are themselves often easily hackable and turned into malware launching nodes. Expecting router manufacturers to help us is a pipe dream.
- curiousgal 10y ago>The lack of exploit mitigation techniques in the target Cisco software makes the life of attackers very easy http://arstechnica.com/security/2016/08/nsa-linked-cisco-exploit-poses-bigger-threat-than-previously-thought/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2016/08/nsa-linked-cisco-exp...
- TeMPOraL 10y agoRouters are a joke. Did I ever tell how my current solution at home fetches the DHCP leases (to get the list of devices connected to the network)? Basically, to access the data you need to send an auth token along with request. How can you get such a token? By logging in, of course. Or, by firing your request anyway, which will cause the router to return you an error page with a cookie containing the auth token you need. That's just... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
- Jade_Jet 10y agoCan we please stop trying to force everything to be connected to the internet? I have no issue with those that want to make a smart house, but it seems like it is increasingly more difficult to find certain quality appliances that are not connected, televisions as an example. I find this whole iot thing very frustrating as a consumer.
- goalieca 10y agoI have an ancient programmable thermostat. It allows me to program heating and cooling for the house. It is wired. I do not host my private information on the cloud. I do not have to send wireless data. I do not have to worry about security updates, feature patches, or bugs. It was thoroughly tested under a waterfall development cycle with strict functional requirements.
- paulddraper 10y agoI have a sprinkler system with similar qualities.
- sbov 10y agoMine isn't, because I always forget to activate rain delay. And under our water restriction, we could get fined for watering within 24 hours of rain. I'm assuming you always remember?
- paulddraper 10y agoNo, I use a rain sensor. Also not connected to the internet.
- cobookman 10y agoI don't get the internet connected part of a lot of the devices. Why not just use Bluetooth to smartphone. And have the smartphone proxy all data to the internet.
- rogerbinns 10y agoWhile that approach could technically work, in practise the support calls will be very lengthy and eat up all of your profit and then some.
- cobookman 10y ago
- notzorbo3 10y agoThe article is taking a rather lack stance against manufacturers with words like "ability" and "interest": > The IoT is expanding faster than device makers’ interest in cybersecurity This is just pure bullshit. It has nothing to do with 'expanding' or 'interest' or 'ability'. This type of security has nothing to do with the scale at which it has it deing deployed or growing. The fact of the matter is that manufacturers are too cheap to provide decent security. This is a profit problem. And dancing around the issue by the media is just weak-ass journalism. The solution is simple: The government holds them accountable for creating shoddy products. The companies creating these products pay for the damages done. It's really this simple. Unfortunately, the U.S seems to have this completely unhealthy obsession with keeping the government impotent and companies powerful at the expense of the people. And not just the american people, but the entire world. Baiscally the only hope we have at this point is the European Union.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoThe solution is simpler and doesn't involve giving more power to idiots: don't buy shit.
- vkou 10y agoI didn't buy any Internet of Shit products. Unfortunately, my neighbour did, and now his toaster is used as part of a DDOS attack against a critical piece of internet infrastructure. How does your solution help?
- jjawssd 10y agoThis is an amazing problem. There is simply no solution because most people don't care!
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThere is a solution, and it's called "government" and "law". No, really. We've been dealing with people who don't care from the very dawn of civilization. There's a reason societies always end up creating governments and regulations, and it's precisely that reason.
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoThis is a huge issue. Bigger than huge. We live in an age equivalent to the great Pollution period of industrial revolution. Where any crap steam engine or boiler was built as long as its golden path worked. Boiler explosions killed thousands and damaged businesses for decades. Smog killed perhaps hundreds of thousands - and only government regulation reeled it in. But we have proved awful at building service based global regulations - TTIP is barely limping now and there is little expectation that "free open global internet" is going to be rallying cry to save the agreements. I would like to see a framework where the user owns root and so is responsible for the upkeep but the manufacturer is obliged to provide ten years worth of patches for anything sold - or provided funding to an open development process to supply patches and updates.
- phmagic 10y agoThe horizontal progress indicator on this page is funny (a blue strip on the bottom if you look). It looks like it's moving from left to right to meet the scroll bar which is going from top to bottom. Several online publications have used this web design pattern and it confuses me. What's wrong with looking to the scroll bar position to know how much text is left on a page?
- phmagic 10y agoThere should be government organization currently responsible for data security. Unfortunately, with the proposed leadership options for the White House, I don't think this will be a priority. The FCC is too concerned with rationing out the electromagnetic spectrum. I doubt UL and CE has enough resources to step up here. For the device makers who want to provide a secure interface to their cloud servers, I think platform and infrastructure providers should set out an easy to adopt standard that any device maker can follow. The expectations on getting a device to market is already so high that small companies typically do not invest in data security. The incentive to adopt the security best practices could come from retailers. Retailers who only stock products with this standard would save on returns / lawsuits. In the coming year, DDOS attacks are the least of their worries if hackers can commandeer devices that see into people's homes and monitor people's lives.
- maxerickson 10y agoISPs could provide seed funding for UL to spin up a certification for connected smart devices. They certainly have the resources and are kind of mixed up in the problem already.
- edoceo 10y agoCouldn't a smarter home router solve a lot of this? Only allow reasonable outbound traffic to whitelist ? Or black hole a lot of the internet for untrusted devices?
- TuringNYC 10y agoMany manufacturers incur liability for their products' defects. How do IoT manufacturers get away without incurring such liability? Is it because the EULAs users sign are airtight? Is it because they are overseas companies? Is it because they are small and would just close up shop if they got sued? Is each incident so tiny that it does not make sense to sue (what about class-actions or ultimate-victim-initiated actions?) Not that I'm proposing litigation as a solution here, but I don't understand what makes IoT manufacturers so different.
- user5994461 10y agoThey are no different. It's just that noone sued yet. Wait for an attack to Brick the vulnerable IoT devices and then the class actions will begin :D
- dev_throw 10y agoI think there is a great use case for open source software running on our IoT devices, where we are cognizant of features, security and implication of updates. I predict this will be more commonplace in the next 5 years. At present, we are so blissfully unaware of what runs on our devices that it is scary.
- flukus 10y agoIt's not like there was no warning, anyone with half a clue knew that security wasn't good enough, yet people plowed ahead with IoT anyway.
- kbaker 10y agoDoes anyone know if there are ongoing efforts to reign this in? Like a standards working group for a UL-like certification process for IoT security? Maybe a group like the Linux Foundation or Core Infrastructure Initiative could take this on and lay out some goals for IoT manufacturers to aspire to (product update guarantees, secure communication, secure coding practices, signed firmware...) One of the biggest problems now is the free-for-all nature of developing IoT products. Though I personally don't see a complete solution unless there is regulation or a government agency like the FTC steps in. I view this as kinda similar to bans on other not-immmediately-visibly-harmful things like CFCs. But I don't see them having any traction themselves to get started. I think if the industry developed a standard certification process they could latch on and help manufacturers and distributors solve the problem.