12 ms·
Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016
- xaduha 10y agoAlternative route is to build a VFIO capable computer and run OS X or whatever your heart desires in a VM with real hardware (read GPU) passed through. You can even run several VMs with several GPUs at the same time. Essentially you can have 2+ computers at the price of one.
- CPLX 10y agoThis sounds interesting. Know of any unusually good guides/resources for this?
- xaduha 10y agoI can't judge from the beginners standpoint, here are few places to start looking https://nixos.org/wiki/QEMU_guest_with_VGA_passthrough https://nixos.org/wiki/QEMU_guest_with_VGA_passthrough https://www.reddit.com/r/VFIO https://www.reddit.com/r/VFIO https://www.reddit.com/r/unRAID https://www.reddit.com/r/unRAID https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/PCI_passthrough_via_OVMF https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/PCI_passthrough_via_OVM... I'd recommend going with NixOS and libvirt, but other communities such as around unRAID or Arch might be bigger.
- mountaineer22 10y agoCan you describe your current setup(HW/OS)?
- xaduha 10y agoi7-3770 (no K), ATI GPU, Gigabyte B75-D3V board. I boot into NixOS without X server and launch a Windows VM with libvirt using this config (redacted a bit). https://gist.github.com/xaduha/226ff1b991bd54db09ff0bbd1df79314 https://gist.github.com/xaduha/226ff1b991bd54db09ff0bbd1df79... snapshot=on option allows me to discard changes to the image with every launch, folders like Desktop, Downloads, etc are not part of the image. When I do need to keep the changes I use a commit command, not mucking with actual snapshots anymore. $ virsh qemu-monitor-command MAIN --hmp commit all As for macOS VM, I haven't used one recently, but it's totally possible.
- jrcii 10y agoYou can run OS X with qemu on Linux.
- rcarmo 10y agoIt crawls, even under KVM.
- xaduha 10y agoIt runs fine, you probably misconfigured something.
- rcarmo 10y ago"fine" for me encompasses fluid rendering of the interface.
- xaduha 10y agoIt's pretty damn fluid with real GPU passed through, literally no difference compared to running on bare metal. If you're not passing a real GPU then you're doing it wrong and shouldn't expect much anyway.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoAre you using VMware for this?
- xaduha 10y agoI'm using kvm, which is basically qemu with hardware acceleration. VT-x is minimum, VT-d is better. Also by default qemu/kvm only uses one processor core I think, what are using to launch it? A script?
- Hydraulix989 10y ago
- dperfect 10y agoI use a configuration like this (with Proxmox) to send content to the various TVs in my house (HDMI over Cat 5e). 4 cheap GPUs in the machine allow for up to 4 VMs running OS X (my preferred OS for media) to simultaneously play HD content, run classic emulated games, web browsing, etc. (haven't bothered with UHD yet, and probably won't for a while). Of course, a lot of HD content can run with very modest specs (as long as the codecs are accelerated on the GPU), but for occasional content that requires CPU decoding or players/sites that aren't yet supported on standalone devices (Apple TV, Roku, etc), it's a really nice solution. Plus, it keeps each TV very clean in terms of cables and hardware. I've done hackintosh on bare metal in the past, but even if I were setting up a single-headed hackintosh now, I'd still go the VFIO route - it makes updates much less stressful since you can quickly roll back to a snapshot if you break something.
- weitzj 10y agoDo you have this configuration by chance as a GIST on GitHub? There are KVM/Qemu configurations, but especially ProxMox would be nice
- dperfect 10y agoKind of a late response, but here are the basics of my setup (maybe I'll publish some specifics in a gist at some point): - Hardware (which is dated now): Asus Z87 Pro with i7 4770, 16 GB Memory, 4x AMD Radeon 6450 cards (< $20/ea used) - Proxmox/host config: vfiobind the PCI device IDs for graphics cards on boot, slightly modified pve-q35.cfg (workaround for some OS X issues on q35), using fairly standard VM args for booting OS X - GPUs work fine after a standard OS X install, but to get audio working over HDMI, I needed a couple of edits to my DSDT (basically just inserting a GFX0 device with "hda-gfx" = "onboard-1", a standard HDAU device, and a DTGP device), and boot with the Enoch bootloader (this can be specified in the VM args to avoid having to install to disk). No extra kexts needed. That's about it. Some of those things may no longer be necessary in the latest version of Proxmox (I haven't updated my base system in a while). Once I got things working, it's been completely stable for more than a year.
- mountaineer22 10y ago
- rcarmo 10y agoThat's nice, but further down the thread you say you haven't tried OSX at all. Anyone else have a useful data point for this scenario?
- orf 10y agoHas anyone here actually made a custom mac? I thought Apple tried to stop this by preventing the OS from installing and you had to do some hacky stuff to get it to work?
- drinchev 10y agoI did in the past (2011). Had an i7 with 16GB of RAM. It was pretty stable. Though I had problems with iMessage & OS X upgrades. Nevertheless I think it's fairly easy to build one and there is big benefit, since Apple's iMac is now the only 32GB capable machine that they sell.
- stephenr 10y ago> iMac is now the only 32GB capable machine that they sell. The Mac Pro supports up to 64GB of RAM.
- redial 10y agoI doubt they sell many, if any mac pros any more.
- mountaineer22 10y agoOr a Hackintosh for less than $1,200?
- minikites 10y agoThe Mac Pro hasn't changed internally since 2013, calling it a professional computer is a joke at this point.
- rbanffy 10y agoThe reasoning was that newer Xeons were not fast enough to warrant a redesign. I am curious about the kind of usage a fully loaded Mac Pro is inadequate for. Of course, you can buy a similarly capable Dell (OSX not included) for less, but you lose the hassle-free Macintoshness.
- erlehmann_ 10y agoWhy do people do this? Is it only for fun? I would think that any GNU/Linux system could provide similar or better tooling and most likely results in a less painful upgrade process.
- drinchev 10y agoI doubt that. Sketch / Photoshop does not run on GNU / Linux as well as Safari. These are a must for any front-end developer these days and personally although I like some window managers for X11, I can't afford to go that way, because they don't feel mature enough. Not to mention iTunes, Photos and all the nice software that comes with OS X.
- X86BSD 10y agoAlso there is no dtrace on Linux.
- drinchev 10y agoSoon there will be. http://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2016-10-27/dtrace-for-linux-2016.html http://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2016-10-27/dtrace-for-linux... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12806941 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12806941
- jrcii 10y agoGnome and KDE are painful to use when you're used to Aqua, not to mention all the great Mac-only apps.
- morganvachon 10y agoOpenbox + compton gets me the same smoothness as Aqua, and is much more configurable. You can make it look and feel 99% like Aqua, or you can go another direction and make it exactly what works for you instead of cloning another interface.
- toyg 10y ago
- op00to 10y agoI experimented with Hackkntoshes years ago. It was a fun toy, but overall not the best use of my time. Upgrades required effort even if they didn't outright break my system. More importantly, Hackintosh requires custom kexts, at a minimum FakeSMC.kext. That kext is used to bypass Apple's hardware locks. Has it been audited? If so, can you trust that the installer you use to wedge the kext in actually uses the clean kext and not a rooted version that puts you at risk? What happens when you load that kext? Even if it isn't overtly trying to compromise your system, does it open security holes? Does it silently corrupt your disk due to a bug somewhere? Let's say you're ok with all that. What happens when you make it big, and Apple decides to sue you for breaking the EULA of MacOS? I wouldn't base my business on it.
- e40 10y agoI did the Hackintosh thing for a couple of years. It was painful, but even more so since I wanted a RAID 1 on my main boot disk. That, it turns out, is not supported that well. If someone claims it is, then I'd say it definitely adds extra steps, and it can sometimes be tricky and tense. I never dual booted Windows, but I read about lots of problems people had in the forums. It was like removing a large pebble from my shoe when I got my Mac Pro.
- op00to 10y agoDid you run your business on the Hackintosh? I'm curious of people who do this - what's the calculus that makes this decision (time, security risk, etc) a viable choice?
- _asummers 10y agoI could see it in the Mac Pro sort of setup, say if rendering is part of your flow, so that you can shove OSX onto Xeons with 64GB RAM or whatever. I personally wouldn't take that risk, but I can see why someone would.
- xaduha 10y ago> I wouldn't base my business on it. Who even said anything about business? But if you're worried about security you can run OS X well enough in a VM (optionally with real hardware) doesn't need any 3rd party kexts AFAIK.
- keeran 10y agoLast time I tried this is it was a complete ballache to get iMessage working - I expect other services are similarly problematic. Is this still a problem?
- cordite 10y agoI never use it, though guides constantly mention you gotta have the right system profile and some other low level settings for it to work.
- Retr0spectrum 10y agoI installed Sierra just a few days ago on an Intel server board (S5000XALR). I had to change a single setting in my bootloader (clover) to make all the services work (Admittedly, it did take a bit of googling to find that setting). I think Intel boards are ideal because they are presumably quite similar in hardware to the Mac Pro motherboards. All my hardware (including GTX480) worked without any additional configuration.
- erikbye 10y agoiMessage working on both my systems, it was not a pain in the ass at all. The only thing I did was make sure my two boxes had unique serial numbers.
- hogrammer 10y agoOr you can run Windows 10 with first-class support on Intel and NVidia hardware.
- riprowan 10y agoI think this trend becomes popular every time Apple's product line becomes stale.
- chrisabrams 10y agoYeah, it's kind of a catch 22 as the product line has to stop innovating for these guides to stay relevant.
- protomyth 10y agoI dearly wish that Apple would just go back to licensing their OS. I get the feeling, other than portables, they really don't want to make Macintoshes. Heck, even a $500[1] package would be fine. Put out a list of acceptable hardware like the old NeXT list[2]. I know they won't, but I still have dreams. I do wonder what was the real story when Steve Jobs made his public comments on clones[3] and what the price was they refused[4]. 1) Lord knows I paid more for NeXTSTEP back in the day. 2) It was kinda fun to call a number and get a fax back with the list of hardware you could buy. 3) https://youtu.be/a3MrpLyUOo8?t=34m41s https://youtu.be/a3MrpLyUOo8?t=34m41s 4) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYLuoahTP_s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYLuoahTP_s
- threeseed 10y agoNo Apple will never go back to licensing their OS. It nearly killed them after Power Computing went straight for Apple's profit margins instead of trying to entice new customers to the ecosystem. The fact is that many of the innovations we come to appreciate Apple for come from their ownership of both the hardware and the software.
- protomyth 10y ago> The fact is that many of the innovations we come to appreciate Apple for come from their ownership of both the hardware and the software. Since they switched to Intel, what are these innovations that I cannot just buy? I see the new Touch Bar, but even that I can skip[1]. I really wonder what would be different? I doubt they will ever go back, but Apple sure isn't doing a whole lot to satisfy my desktop love. What exactly on the Mac mini and Mac Pro cannot be bought by a third party? 1) The whole idea of something that make me move my eyes to the keyboard is unwelcome.
- redial 10y agoI don't know if you would count this as innovations, but magsafe, the glass trackpad still ahead of anything else and the full unibody enclosure in my mind are clear innovations that made a mac a much better alternative than the competition. I also think they were only possible because people are willing to pay a little more to get macOS, thus allowing Apple a higher price point to develop and include those features.
- pjmlp 10y agoI understand not wanting to pay the Apple tax, but I think what makes a desktop experience great is the whole package. How hardware and software come together in an unified user experience. This is why people talk about Spectrums, Commodores, Ataris, Amigas, Macs, and game consoles. This is why hardly anyone talks about nice memorable experiences with PC clones.
- FullyFunctional 10y agoBased on the comments of people doing this, the vast majority are far less motivated by saving money than by getting macOS on great hardware. It's a frustrating fact for those willing to pay that the Mac "Pro" is very far behind the bleeding edge.
- ScarZy 10y agoI was lucky to infact have the components that I built for my gaming computer also tick the boxes for a hackintosh build. I had a spare SSD that I was running arch on, so thought I'd give it a whirl. I use a MBP for work, and having a similar system to work on is quite nice (especially since it's great for labwork with 32GB of RAM). It's been rock solid, and I want to write my own boxen so that I can mimic my MBP build
- mmastrac 10y agoHas anyone built a Hackintosh laptop that works? Even one that booted into Linux (with proper sleep/hibernation support) to run an OSX VM using PCI passthru would be useful.
- dylan604 10y agoWhen I built my current CustoMac, I selected an Gigabyte X99 chipset motherboard that supported an optional Thunderbolt2 expansion card. This was an important part in my decision making as I have a lot of peripheral video equipment that I need in day to day work. It worked, with the caveat that it was not plug-n-play. Devices were only detected at boot. Cool, I can handle that. However, when I upgraded the OS to El Capitan, I needed to update the firwmare of the mobo. After upgrading the firmware, Gigabyte removed support for the Thunderbolt expansion card. Suddenly, I can no longer use any of those devices. I searched, but there was no mention of the loss of thunderbolt with the use of that firmware. I have seen online where others are also in the same Thunderboltless boat, even if they are running Windows. Just and FYI to consider if anyone reading this thread is thinking of the CustoMac route. This isn't the Hackintosh community's issue for something they changed. It's the hardware vendor's decision.