2 ms·
I'm curious, as I want to make some poster-sized art prints soon: 1) What resolution were the source files? 2) What upscaling options did you use? 3) What mu
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
I'm curious, as I want to make some poster-sized art prints soon:
1) What resolution were the source files?
2) What upscaling options did you use?
3) What multiple of the original file size did you go up to? Were you limited by the quality of the upscaling, or did you just decide on the size of print and dpi, and multiply?
- dahart 10y agoOh, I was downscaling, mainly for filtering/anti-aliasing. My source files were the 60k^2 images, and the output was more like 20k^2... I shoot for at least 300 dpi and I was printing 60-inch prints. I had enough trouble downscaling such large images that I ended up writing my own downscaling in my renderer so that I wouldn't have to use GraphicsMagick or anything else, but of everything I ever tried, GraphicsMagick was the best at handling enormous images. FWIW, I've never been happy with any upscaling. If you do have the option to render at your target res and not use upscaling, that's ideal. If you must upscale, it's hard to find anything that can do more that 2-3x without noticeable artifacts or visible blurriness.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoThanks for the detailed reply. I'd assumed your source files were digital photos of artwork (e.g. 20 megapixel). I want to print some photos of Japanese wood block artwork, and there's an RNN implementation which apparently works well for doing 2x, 4x etc. upscaling: https://github.com/nagadomi/waifu2x https://github.com/nagadomi/waifu2x
- dahart 10y agoAh, yes photos are difficult. I have used some of the pixel art upscalers, but not for prints, and I haven't used waifu2x before. They can be almost magical in some situations, and Japanese woodblocks seem like a pretty good application for waifu2x. I'd worry a little about textured background and what happens in areas of high detail, but I'm speculating. You can see resolution artifacts in the waifu2x examples. But those source images are tiny -- it may behave completely differently on a 20MP image. It also depends on what material you print onto. Canvas and some popular art papers have a lot of texture that can hide the 1-2 pixel sized artifacts. If you are taking the photos yourself, one option you might consider is to take overlapping photos of sub-portions of the woodblocks and stitch them together using a panorama editor like Hugin to get a source image that is at or above your target resolution. If you have no other options but upscaling, do some experiments with the cheapest printing service you can find that will print 24x36 inches at 300dpi. There are a bunch online that will mail you prints very fast. If you're in the US, Costco does ridiculously cheap photo prints at 24x36. Experiment with upscalers and see what works best for the photos you have. You might find that you don't like any of them, or you might find out that you can't tell much difference between waifu2x and generic upscaling, or you might find out that waifu2x is perfect and unbeatable.