2 ms·
>The answer to the first question is a historical one, and the record seems clear that its original purpose was explicitly to reduce the black population. You
by krapp 10y ago
>The answer to the first question is a historical one, and the record seems clear that its original purpose was explicitly to reduce the black population.
You seem to be correct in that the founder of Planned Parenthood believed in eugenics[0,1], but many people did at the time, and the evidence seems to be that she was more concerned about bringing fewer unwanted poor children into the world than explicitly preventing the birth of black children. Although I have found as many sites arguing that she was explicitly anti-black as debunking it, so I don't know.
>It is a simple fact that more black pregnancies are aborted, and that more PP abortion clinics are in low-income, minority areas. Therefore it is a simple statistical fact that PP reduces or controls the black population more than the white population.
"Controls" implies coercion, but black women are choosing to have abortions, not being forced to do so. Is Planned Parenthood really controlling and reducing the black population or is the black population controlling or reducing itself?
>Therefore, even if she were not racist in intention, her policies are racist in effect.
Fair enough, but you did ask rather explicitly which candidate was racist, so you seemed to be implying racism in intent. One can hold pro-choice beliefs and support Planned Parenthood for reasons other than racism, so the "racism in effect" seems like it would apply more to the organization than to her, if it applied to anything at all.
>Why does she support a policy which supports a racist organization? Does she think that there are benefits which outweigh racist side-effects? (...)
Perhaps she, like many women, considers access to the services that Planned Parenthood provides (which aren't limited to abortions) to be necessary. And being pro-choice, she isn't likely to consider abortion services to be evil, more than any other medical procedure.
Also, it's probably worth mentioning that Trump has publicly supported Planned Parenthood[2,3], and praised the organization for providing access to birth control, cancer and STD screenings, although he disagrees with abortion funding, except in cases of rape and incest.
So if merely supporting Planned Parenthood is racist, both Trump and Clinton appear to be racist, in that both support a "racist organization."
> According to you, anyone who thinks Clinton is closer to being a racist than Trump is an "extremist." This is not reasonable or civil.
No, I think the framing of Planned Parenthood as primarily an organization dedicated to racial genocide is extremist, and that presenting support for the organization as evidence of Hillary Clinton's racism requires accepting an extremist point of view.
I also don't think "closer to being a racist" means anything useful. Racism isn't something you can quantify and graph.
[0]http://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2015/08/14/432080520/fact-check-was-planned-parenthood-started-to-control-the-black-population http://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2015/08/14/432080...
[1]http://www.politifact.com/new-hampshire/statements/2015/oct/05/ben-carson/did-margaret-sanger-believe-african-americans-shou/ http://www.politifact.com/new-hampshire/statements/2015/oct/...
[2]https://www.conservativereview.com/commentary/2016/02/fact-check-trump-supports-planned-parenthood https://www.conservativereview.com/commentary/2016/02/fact-c...
[3]http://www.cnn.com/2016/02/25/politics/donald-trump-defends-planned-parenthood-republican-debate/ http://www.cnn.com/2016/02/25/politics/donald-trump-defends-...