4 ms·
"Yes, we did use the WordPress open source library for a minor part of the application (that is the concept of open source right?), and everything we improved t
by pavlov 10y ago
"Yes, we did use the WordPress open source library for a minor part of the application (that is the concept of open source right?), and everything we improved there or modified, we submitted back as open source ..."
That is not the concept of the GPL though. They need to release the source for the entire derived work, not just that one component. It's not Wix's choice -- it's required by the license, and the act of incorporating code under that license makes them bound by it.
For a letter written by a CEO, this one seems strangely oblivious to the real issues. Did he run it through the legal department at all? (Presumably not, since it's the weekend.)
Abrahami writes: "If you believe that we need to give you credit" -- but that's not the issue at hand. It gives the impression that he doesn't understand the differences between open source licenses, and that can be a serious liability for a company that builds so heavily on other people's code.
[Edit] I actually wish the GPL were finally tested in court, because that would resolve a long-standing question around its enforceability. The CEO of Wix admitted that the derived work in this case contains "more than 3 million lines of code"... The copyright owner of the GPL'd module could sue them to have all that released under the GPL, and (assuming Wix wouldn't comply) then we would finally know if the license holds up in court or not.
- tzs 10y ago> The CEO of Wix admitted that the derived work in this case contains "more than 3 million lines of code"... The copyright owner of the GPL'd module could sue them to have all that released under the GPL, and (assuming Wix wouldn't comply) then we would finally know if the license holds up in court or not. The copyright owner would win, but all they would likely get out of the court is an injunction stopping Wix from distributing the infringing product and monetary damages. They would probably not be able to force Wix to release source code. If the GPL code is just a wrapper around MIT licensed code, as has been claimed, Wix should be able to quickly change their code to use that MIT code directly instead of using WordPress' GPL wrapper.
- pavlov 10y agoThat would still be a major victory for the GPL. To my knowledge it has never been tested in court in the USA. Everyone knows that the GPL is being commonly violated by companies that just don't care and developers who don't understand it. Any US legal precedent around GPL would be welcome.
- Tomte 10y agoSay again? The Netfilter case was the first and is famous. Harald Welte vs. Skype was another.
- pavlov 10y agoYou're quite right -- I was thinking about US only, not worldwide. Will edit to correct.
- Tomte 10y agoI suspect the reason those cases have been in Germany and not in the US aren't simply that Harald Welte happens to live in Germany, because the US surely has people who would like to put up a fight. I guess a big part of the reason is that suing in Germany is costly, but not "you'll be poor for the rest of your life" costly.
- mioelnir 10y agoIf as some have commented, parts of the MIT license attribution were removed, Automattic might not have been legally allowed to distribute the software either. At which points the involved lawyers would have a field day trying to figure out how binding a license is that you use for distribution of works that you are not allowed to redistribute.
- nkuttler 10y agoWordPress isn't even properly GPL-licensed. No license in the top-level app file [1] [2]. The included license file doesn't selectively attach itself to all relevant files, and not to source files that have a different license [3]. WordPress contains copyrighted material that's definitely not GPL-compatible [4], so even if the previous points are considered irrelevant, it remains questionable if the source can be distributed under the terms of the GPL at all [5]. [1] https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress/blob/master/index.php https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress/blob/master/index.php [2] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-howto.en.html https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-howto.en.html [3] https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress/blob/master/license.txt https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress/blob/master/license.t... [4] https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress/blob/master/wp-content/plugins/hello.php https://github.com/WordPress/WordPress/blob/master/wp-conten... [5] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-2.0.html https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-2.0.html See term 7.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- caseysoftware 10y agoNo, they could sue to bring them in compliance with the license. ONE of the options to be in compliance may be to release the entire project GPL. Another option may be to simply remove the offending code. And the losing side (or settlement) may include attorney's fees. There is no clause to the GPL that says "if you break our license even once, we get your project!"
- pavlov 10y agoI'm not a lawyer, but Section 5 of GPL v2 states: "5. You are not required to accept this License, since you have not signed it. However, nothing else grants you permission to modify or distribute the Program or its derivative works. These actions are prohibited by law if you do not accept this License. Therefore, by modifying or distributing the Program (or any work based on the Program), you indicate your acceptance of this License to do so, and all its terms and conditions for copying, distributing or modifying the Program or works based on it."
- delinka 10y ago"Another option may be to simply remove the offending code." This would remove their dependence upon GPL'd code, thus obviating applicability of the entire GPL, including section 5.
- eli 10y agoDeleting a pirated movie you downloaded doesn't absolve you of the original copyright infringement.
- delinka 10y agoThe music and movie industries have changed tactics in that they go after the uploader/sender of a copyrighted work. And you would be correct that a simple "oh, sorry, I'll stop sharing that" would probably not suffice to remediate a case that's gone to court - the damage is already done: those that downloaded can't 'unwatch' the movie, and a sale can probably be proven to have been 'lost' as a result. However, we've seen software copyright cases over source code being remedied in this exact manner. Courts take the type of IP into account. Perhaps a judge might think if the code can simply be replaced without tremendous effort and without drastically affecting the end users' experience, then that infringing piece of software probably wasn't that instrumental in the full app and thus the monetary benefit to the infringer from the infringing code wasn't all that great. Further, in GPL infringement cases, I don't know that the owner could demonstrate damages; we'd be stuck with a punitive award from the court. And here's the rub: GPL hasn't gone to court in the US.
- tptacek 10y agoHasn't the GPL been tested in court repeatedly?
- kijiki 10y agoNot in US court. All US cases so far have settled. Though given that the pro-GPL side is usually just looking for compliance, not $$$, those settlements suggest serious doubts about winning in the minds of the alleged violators. There have been a few in German court (Hellwig v VMware most recently). And probably some in other jurisdictions as well.
- hodgesrm 10y agoThe fact that GPL cases often settle does not mean the GPL is weak. In fact at least in some cases it's because the violators know they will lose and have no motivation to proceed to trial. Also, "pro-GPL" suites play out a little differently than many people suppose. The plaintiffs are not necessarily looking for compliance but trying to collect license fees. To pick an obvious example, let's say you develop an app with Oracle MySQL using the MySQL client libraries. By linking to the MySQL libraries (for example the Connector/J JDBC driver) your application has become derivative. If you ship a binary you now either need to release all derivative code under GPL V2 or pay Oracle a commercial license fee.[1] However, if you just ship with the Oracle driver and don't release code your GPL license automatically terminates and you are now liable for the commercial license fees. This kind of case is open-and-shut if the copyright owners get a copy of your binary with linked libraries. This is also the kind of case that should never come to trial unless the plaintiffs are really greedy or the defendants somehow don't understand their legal quandary fully. Start-ups often use GPL for this reason--it's a powerful inducement to license. [1] https://dev.mysql.com/downloads/connector/j/5.1.html https://dev.mysql.com/downloads/connector/j/5.1.html Edit: on the license fees, if you don't have a license you might owe payments going back years. The sum can run into the millions depending on the extent of violation, not to mention legal fees, disruption of having to do discovery, etc.
- dsymonds 10y agoI don't think it has actually been "tested" in the true sense here. I believe every known case has either been settled out of court (so the court hasn't even had a chance to adjudicate), or has been decided based on some other technicality (like unclear authorship/ownership of the original).
- jpatokal 10y agoNit: Wix is based in Israel, where the weekend runs Fri-Sat (because Sabbath) and Sunday is a normal working day. Although the blog is timestamped Oct 29 (Sat), which is during the weekend in any case.
- hodgesrm 10y agoThe GPL has been tested in court and the license holds up. I suspect many cases actually settle because they were not winnable for the violator and they were looking at substantial damages if the case came to trial. In this case there's usually some kind of confidentiality agreement [1]. If you ship GPL code and don't release sources for the entire derivative work that is a very shaky economic model. [1] http://www.americanbar.org/publications/gp_solo/2012/november_december2012privacyandconfidentiality/confidentiality_settlement_agreements_is_virtual_necessity.html http://www.americanbar.org/publications/gp_solo/2012/novembe...
- rando832 10y agoIt has been tested in court. Not all aspects, but there is no question as to whether it is enforceable.