5 ms·
I honestly don't see how all this whining is justified, except for the fact that you need dongles to hook up your shiny new iPhone and EarPods to your MacBook.
by Razengan 10y ago
I honestly don't see how all this whining is justified, except for the fact that you need dongles to hook up your shiny new iPhone and EarPods to your MacBook.
• People wanted Skylake, they got Skylake.
• They got faster GPU and I/O and great battery life. The numbers on these are impressive, especially the I/O.
• They got 4 ports of the fastest and most versatile interfaces for external devices ever. The removal of all other ports is really no worse than when the VERY FIRST iMAC went USB-only back in 1998! [1][2] We all see how the rest of the industry followed, as it will again when everything becomes USB-C.
• The Touch Bar is actually a cool new input device that brings context-sensitive multitouch to macOS without bastardizing the traditional desktop UI as Windows does. You wanted innovation, you got it. What do people expect to happen to laptops at this point anyway?? I don't see any good alternative ideas being offered.
• Lastly, and I'm amazed at how this is being overlooked in every discussion: The move to 30-BIT-PER-CHANNEL SCREENS! I have an iPad Pro and the difference that a wide color display brings has to be seen in person to be appreciated. Accurate color representation in consumer devices is a field which has languished for over 20 years. I believe mad props are due Apple for pushing everyone ahead, and up until now I don't think there were any good laptops for actually creating and previewing P3 content, without connecting them to expensive external screens.
----
Now the bad things.
I only recently purchased an iPhone 7 and a 9.7" iPad Pro. I love them to bits, especially their wide color cameras and screens, but I won't be able to connect them to an already-expensive new MBP, or use the new Lightning EarPods, without spending even more money on dongles and carrying around extra stuff with me everywhere.
Given the prices, I really think Apple should have softened this by at least bundling Lightning-to-USB-C with the new MacBooks. WHY fight within your own ecosystem?
The naming is also a disaster. I don't really mind them calling the 9.7" iPad "Pro" (it's an amazing device) but putting out a "MacBook Pro" without a Touch Bar really muddies the waters and only creates confusion. They should've just called it a 13" MacBook, and given it a choice of more colors.
These are the areas where they are justifiably deserving of ire, but on the whole I think all this relentless negativity is a bit excessive and feels like the work of competitor-hired PR firms, but I hope it pushes Apple to address the actual issues.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMac#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMac#History
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legacy-free_PC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legacy-free_PC
- pilsetnieks 10y agoIt's also much harder to differentiate "pro" and consumer products these days, especially with the x86 CPU and chipset development plateauing as it is now. To have the same difference as there was between an early iBook and a Powerbook you'd have to pack the Macbook Pro with dual processor octacore Xeons, non-mobile graphics cards, etc. with all that entails (i.e. power draw, cooling, weight, price.) Few "pros" would be willing to return to lugging a 10lb "laptop" thick as an encyclopedia around, or pay twice as much.
- ksec 10y agoiPad sales, while declining, is now double that of Mac. I thought this was clear enough, consumers aren't even touching their PC anymore, at least that is where the trend is heading. The iPad, at those price point has taken over the cheaper segment what 11" Macbook Air was originally for. So what Apple envisioned, is that anyone using a PC or Mac is either a prosumer or professionals. And just like many other tech, Apple force their way in and make early steps for changes, Floppy, CD-ROM etc. No SCSI for iMac? Apple wanted everyone, or will force every USB to be USB-C type. And it is clear someday, 802.11ac / ad will be fast enough for wireless transfer between Professional Cameras. So they will get rid of SD-Card now. Any Kaby Lake offers little to no performance improvement over Skylake. And if you are wondering, the 10nm 25W Mobile CPU wont arrive til 2018. I honestly dont have any idea what people are complaining about in terms of tech. For me, apart from... Price.....
- timbo1642 10y agoThe whining isn't justified? We wanted a better product, not a product that is more expensive and lacks basic connectivity. The reason people want THIN AND LIGHT laptops in convenience. What convenience do we get if we have to carry all kinds of dongles and adapters? And why do we have to pay money for them when the macbooks are very expensive. Why isn't AT LEAST a USB C to lightning cable included along with a USBC to USB 3.0? Explain that. Someone else pointed out that the skylake included performs slower than the old processor and its already a generation old. Battery life may be good, but lets not forget because of it, we can't go over 16 gigs of memory. That's a joke. 16 gigs may be decent for most people today, but I want 32 gigs, especially if its a year from now since they won't update these for a while. > They got 4 ports of the fastest and most versatile interfaces for external devices ever Great. Remove the ports that we all use and love that are not going anywhere anytime soon. Give us ports that barely anyone uses or cares about. Why not have both? No one gives a shit about a port they won't ever use. What a dumb response you made. and with the iMac they made a mistake then and are making that mistake again. For what? To save a couple dollars of licensing fees? > What do people expect to happen to laptops at this point anyway?? I don't see any good alternative ideas being offered. You're just one person and you don't have any decent ideas. That's why you don't work to develop new things. Plenty of people I'm sure have cool and interesting ideas that are more useful. > Given the prices, I really think Apple should have softened this by at least bundling Lightning-to-USB-C with the new MacBooks. WHY fight within your own ecosystem? That's Apple. Milk the customer for every penny they got by selling nice looking outdated hardware and cutting out features and ports and making them pay more for it. I can't recommend an apple product to anyone, except for the iPhone which I will probably stop recommending when a decent competitor comes around. Many Apple users are pissed as well, I really hope they throw out the CEO. He's horrible and a lot of people don't like him. > They should've just called it a 13" MacBook, and given it a choice of more colors. But they can milk you for even more money by calling it a PRO! > but I hope it pushes Apple to address the actual issues. I'm pretty damn sure Apple doesn't give a shit about its customers. They do what they want like a shady dictator and not for the people. It's only about how much they can get out of every customer and they are playing customers like a fool. I'm glad I switched away years ago and I will never go back.