8 ms·
The Strange Inevitability of Evolution
- npgatech 10y ago"You don’t have to be a benighted creationist, nor even a believer in divine providence, to argue that Darwin’s astonishing theory doesn’t fully explain why nature is so marvelously, endlessly inventive." Interesting article but why are we still bringing up creationism. This whole apologist / sympathizing attitude needs to be changed. It adds no value to the article except ridicules itself.
- kwhitefoot 10y ago"You don’t have to be a benighted creationist, nor even a believer in divine providence, to argue that Darwin’s astonishing theory doesn’t fully explain why nature is so marvelously, endlessly inventive." But you probably would have to be to think that the argument was relevant to Darwin's theory. Darwin book is titled: "The Origin of Species by means of natural selection or the preservation of favoured races in the struggle for life". That is to say, it is explicitly not about how the variation comes about but about how the variation becomes fixed.
- spacehacker 10y agoIndeed. Until we can quantify nature's computational power and the computational complexity of evolving solutions to problems in nature, the only sensible response to the fact that evolution works extremely well is no response because we lack comparisons. Evolution only surprises us when we falsely (or at least without good reason) regard nature and our own creative abilities to belong to the same reference class. There are also already plenty of clues for why evolution works, e.g. distributed representations, parallelization, composition counteracting combinatorial explosions, selection for structures that evolve faster/better (kind of like learning to learn) etc.
- SiVal 10y agoThis whole apologist / sympathizing attitude needs to be changed I don't know, as an atheist myself I think the attitude of smug arrogance embodied in terms like "benighted creationist" is the real problem, not that even acknowledging a theory that has been believed in some form by most humans who ever lived is too kind. A person can be a creationist without being a fool and can be a believer in evolution by nothing more enlightened than a lack of independent thinking in an environment where atheism is in fashion among the cool kids. I'll have to say that I'm astonished again and again when I write code that uses some "mindless" search process (including numerous experiments with evolutionary algorithms) and it finds the answer to some problem that I couldn't reason through. I can't seem to get over the feeling that if I have to reason to solve a certain problem, and I can't reason well enough to solve it, and another "thing" does solve it, it must reason better than I do--be smarter than I am--even when I wrote the code that did it. It gives me a sense of "awe" for the power of evolution and a lasting "sympathetic attitude" toward those who just can't believe that it could work this well. Like the power of a simple, naive bayes spam sorter to "interpret the text of email", evolution is one of those things that, even when I can explain it well enough to actually implement it with my own hands, it's still hard for me to believe.
- flukus 10y ago> I don't know, as an atheist myself I think the attitude of smug arrogance embodied in terms like "benighted creationist" is the real problem, not that even acknowledging a theory that has been believed in some form by most humans who ever lived is too kind. Creationism was never a scientific theory. And I think we can give a free pass to people being creationist before the theory was created and before it was taught in schools. Modern day creationist though, they are fools.
- alphapapa 10y agoThe idea that the universe was created by an intelligent being is not a scientific theory and cannot be disproven by science. It is not in competition with scientific theories of evolution or even, for example, big bang theories, because neither of them can explain why the universe exists, where it came from, etc. If you believe in the big bang, then what caused it, where did the matter come from, etc? You cannot disprove philosophy with science, and the fools are those who think they can.
- flukus 10y agoSure, there are limits to out knowledge, atheists are a lot happier to say they don't know than most religious folk I've come across. But what your describing is very different to most creationist, you've pushed the god of gaps back to a level where it's largely irrelevant. Most creationist are the 6000 year old earth kind, which has been disproven by several major branches of science.
- alphapapa 10y ago> Sure, there are limits to out knowledge, atheists are a lot happier to say they don't know than most religious folk I've come across. So, if a person says, "I don't know, but I still believe," is that not an example of faith? How, then, can you claim that atheism and/or, shall we say, "sciencism", are more rational belief systems than Creationism, Christianity, etc, given that they both ultimately rely on faith? The atheist says, "Creationists are fools because they have no proof of their creator," while the creationist says, "Atheists are fools because they have no proof of what created." What's the difference? Who has more faith: the one who sees something that exists and believes that something created it, or the one who sees something that exists and believes it was not created? Is either one not faith-based? Does either one not have missing links in its assumed chain? > But what your describing is very different to most creationist, you've pushed the god of gaps back to a level where it's largely irrelevant. How is it not relevant whether an intelligent being created the universe? If the universe was created by an intelligent being, what does it matter how it was done, through natural processes set in motion or by blinking into existence in an advanced state? If the universe was created by an intelligent being, wouldn't that be much more important than how? > Most creationist are the 6000 year old earth kind, which has been disproven by several major branches of science. To be strictly fair, this is not true, because it does not engage with that kind of creationism's assumptions. If one believes that an intelligent being created the universe from nothing, including all the physical laws from subatomic to intergalactic, why would it be beyond that being's ability to create the Earth in a state advanced far beyond its actual age? Besides, in matters like this, what is time, anyway? Einstein showed that it's relative--and if an intelligent being created the rules that Einstein discovered, could not that being bend its own rules? In other words, you unfairly ascribe to the "6000 year old earth kind" an inconsistency which it does not actually bear; you do not engage with it on its own terms. If you do not accept its assumptions, that's fine--your disagreement then lies with them, not with a false inconsistency. Ultimately, the most important question is of who or what created the universe, not how or when it was created. The former makes a difference in how we should lead our lives, while the latter is merely interesting.
- simondedalus 10y agoAs usual, this article makes me think of Wittgenstein, who would probably say, "I agree with everything you're saying, except the word 'strange'." The content is interesting, definitely, but you could save some time and potentially misleading "appreciation of strangeness" by stating that neutral drift allows for dramatically more random possibilities than those offered by one-time random mutations. Not that Wittgenstein (or I) want to poopoo the "wonder" element of science or life in general... but I think it's telling that the author, as other comments point out, mentions creationism, as if that's a natural motivator for "wonder" (or a natural view to take in light of "wonder"). But creationism is simplistic, incoherent, and wrong. If "strange" is adding nothing to the truth or falsity of any of the statements involved, and "strange" is somehow an excuse for creationism, perhaps we should take issue with this being "strange" at all.
- hsitz 10y agoA maybe relevant Wittgenstein quote: "It is not how the world is, that is the mystical, but that it is." Tractatus 6.44
- simondedalus 10y agoindeed, the early wittgenstein thinks that the world is must be one of those things we must pass over in silence, while how the world is is exactly the kind of thing about which we can talk and reason. the later wittgenstein (still?) thinks that explanation comes to an end somewhere, and just wants to make sure one doesn't append "and isn't that mysterious?" to the end of a good explanation (ie one that sets out to answer a precise question, then does so). but who knows. wittgenstein and mysticism is an interesting topic... for the early wittgenstein, it's crystal clear that he's saying there are 2 domains: stuff that admits of being talked about in a propositional way, and stuff that doesn't. all the latter stuff is mystical; it's not necessarily supernatural, it's just that we can't get anywhere talking about it with true/false (or satisfaction-condition or whatever) talk. but what about the later wittgenstein? he thinks that the domain of things we can talk about has opened up considerably, because he no longer things that language functions as a mirror of "the world", nor should it even try to. now he thinks that utterances are tools to get this or that done. this does not neatly carve out anything to be called mystical. --- relating this back to the article, the idea is that we sort of put an air of magic about the mystical, and when we treat something for which we can create an adequate explanation as mystical or magic (or "strange"), we lead ourselves and others into getting perplexed. and if there is something to be said for religion or purpose, it's not to be found in something we can explicate adequately by adverting to neutral drift, etc. that being the case, we want to be careful about what we call strange. what are we endorsing when we see strangeness in something we can understand?
- walter_bishop 10y ago"You don’t have to be a benighted creationist, nor even a believer in divine providence, to argue that Darwin’s astonishing theory doesn’t fully explain why nature is so marvelously, endlessly inventive." I used watch those Dawkins v the true believers videos and I suspect such opinions are promoted to discredit Darwinian Evolution acting on the genome. Regardless of the unknown nuances of DNA, Evolution is the environment acting on the species to further adapt it to the environment. Here's another quote from Philip Ball: "What often goes unremarked among the revisionism that current research is prompting is that DNA was supposed to be the missing part of the puzzle in evolutionary theory: the repository of Mendelian hereditary factors." So if DNA doesn't act on the units of inheritance, there must be some kind of spooky spirit entities acting on matter, http://www.sciencecartoonsplus.com/images/miracle_sharris.gif http://www.sciencecartoonsplus.com/images/miracle_sharris.gi... http://www.philipball.co.uk/images/stories/docs/pdf/genes%20and%20evolution%20full.pdf http://www.philipball.co.uk/images/stories/docs/pdf/genes%20...
- lucio 10y agoI don't like the anthropomorphization of evolution. It's a bad angle to view the subject >If evolution is “searching” for that function by natural selection... Evolution is "doing" nothing. It has no particular purpose and it is not "searching" for the particular life forms of this planet. The true shaper of the life-forms we know is death. Death (by resource starvation) is the knife cutting the uncontrolled growth of life, uncontrolled growth in number and variations.
- judahmeek 10y agoI agree. The difficulty people, including myself, have of realizing that evolution is actually a impersonal, negative process (resource starvation and the culling of the unfit) rather than a sentient, positive process is astounding.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI'd say it's simple when you actually "step through" a few steps of a simplified simulation. On paper or in your head, picture a few critters reproducing and dying, with random feature changes occuring every reproduction step and with chance of death being directly tied to those features. Step a few generations and you can clearly see that what really drives the evolutionary process is the criterion you chose to determine which critters die and which survive. But yeah, I know most people have problem grokking processes like these. School definitely doesn't teach it - not in a proper, abstract, "algorithmic" way. Only with stories about butterflies and dinosaurs. I know I finally grokked evolution somewhere in my mid 20-s, after a) reading enough Less Wrong articles, and b) simulating it in my head, pretty much in the way I described above.
- _greim_ 10y agoIf you put an boulder in front of a blind wanderer traveling in a straight line, they'll bump into it and stop. If they're wandering in a plane, however, they might wander past it. You can install a line of boulders instead. But if it's a blind drifter drifting through a 3D volume, they might drift past the string of boulders. For every increase in the number of dimensions N the wanderer can move through, an obstacle must block that many more pathways, in order to remain an obstacle. Complex genomes, having high-dimensionality phase spaces, present fewer systematic barriers to genetic drift, allowing populations to spread out through more of the phase space, which in turn ratchets up the probability some mutation would emerge that increases fitness.
- reubenswartz 10y agoIf you enjoyed this, you might like The Vital Question by Nick Lane (https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00OD8Z4JW https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00OD8Z4JW), which discusses the origin of life, and the jump from prokaryotic to eukaryotic cells, focusing on energy.
- Jupe 10y agoEvolution does give us a tool to make predictions, and yes, some of those predictions come true. Unfortunately, humans don't always heed those predictions: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2702430/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2702430/
- dilemma 10y agoWhat if evolution is... Intelligently Designed?