3 ms·
No-one expects this policy to be enforced completely successfully, but no law or rule against discrimination ever is. I see no reason why it could not make a po
by foldr 10y ago
No-one expects this policy to be enforced completely successfully, but no law or rule against discrimination ever is. I see no reason why it could not make a positive difference.
As to your final question, why so cynical? I imagine Airbnb came up with this when they recognized that discriminatory behavior by hosts was a serious problem. I doubt that Airbnb are secretly in favor of racism and doing this for some other reason.
- jacquesm 10y ago> As to your final question, why so cynical? Past and present Airbnb behavior is - to use light terms - less than ethical. > I imagine Airbnb came up with this when they recognized that discriminatory behavior by hosts was a serious problem. But they only chose to act when it became a matter of negative press. > I doubt that Airbnb are secretly in favor of racism and doing this for some other reason. They don't have to be 'secretly in favor of it' for them to condone it because it affects their bottom line one way or the other, presumably they've done the math and they now figure that further run-ins with the press and the law would work against them. Really, when it comes to the likes of Airbnb, Uber, Facebook and so on I've over time come to realize that they are deeply un-ethical companies that couldn't care less about what the 'right' thing to do is, they just want to maintain their leadership position and to make as much money as possible. Ethics mean nothing to them.
- foldr 10y ago> Really, when it comes to the likes of Airbnb, Uber, Facebook and so on I've over time come to realize that they are deeply un-ethical companies that couldn't care less about what the 'right' thing to do is, they just want to maintain their leadership position and to make as much money as possible. Ethics mean nothing to them. Right, so you have no specific knowledge of what is going on here. You just have a general policy of assuming the worst. Aka cynicism.
- jacquesm 10y ago> Right, so you have no specific knowledge of what is going on here. You just have a general policy of assuming the worst. Aka cynicism. It's cynicism when applied to companies about which you have no datapoints, we have plenty of datapoints about those three mentioned above. Airbnb would have to significantly change their ways before I would be ready to see them as an ethical operator, I've outlined two things they could do to really combat racism, but I'll bet you they will never do this because it would cut into their bottom line. See, being an ethical company always cuts into the bottom line, there is almost always more money to be made by being unethical.
- foldr 10y agoWe don’t have any data points about why they made this decision. I’m sorry, but your argument basically amounts to saying “Airbnb is a big evil corporation, therefore everything it does is evil”. We simply don’t know what motivations the individuals who made this decision had. I looked through your recent comments but couldn’t see any practical suggestions. Forcing hosts to accept all bookings would prevent legitimate instances of discrimination. (There are plenty of legitimate reasons why you may not want to rent your room to a particular person. Reasons based on their gender, nationality, race, etc. are of course not among these.)
- jacquesm 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12824223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12824223 It's pretty common for women not to want to rent out their room to men, the new policy would make that impossible. People make their decisions about who to leave their private property, their home and the bed they sleep in based on their own personal criteria, being allowed to do so is a plus, not a minus. If that also enables racism then you could argue the model is broken but not that 'racism is such a large problem that we will now also stop people from having control over who gets to stay in their property'.
- foldr 10y agoSo when it comes down to it, you’d actually like Airbnb to be doing less than they are currently doing to combat racial discrimination! If you are upset with Airbnb because you’re in favor of hosts being allowed to racially discriminate, you could have saved a lot of confusion by just saying so. For my part, I think that you very obviously can argue that racism is such a large problem that it’s appropriate for Airbnb to exercise some element of control over the host’s decision making process. That is the argument that many people have been making, and Airbnb appears to have accepted the argument. By the way, it is very unclear from your range of posts what you actually want Airbnb to do. In some places you appear to be suggesting that Airbnb should exercise more control over hosts that they are at present (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12824223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12824223). But here you seem to be complaining that they are attempting to exert any degree of control whatsoever.