5 ms·
This was possibly interesting ... before the leak of the emails that made it crystal clear that the "consensus" group systematically kept the other side out of
by hga 17y ago
This was possibly interesting ... before the leak of the emails that made it crystal clear that the "consensus" group systematically kept the other side out of the peer-reviewed literature.
I'd also note that "consensus" is not a word you find in real science; one inconvenient fact can destroy the position of a consensus, although as Kuhn says (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Structure_of_Scientific_Revolutions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Structure_of_Scientific_Rev...), grossly oversimplifying, you might have to wait until enough of the members of the consensus retire or die.
- tomjen3 17y agoFor those of you downmodding hga, the leaked emails contained conversations between some of the researcher that specifically talk about how to keep a scientist who disagree with them out of the peer reviewed press.
- ugh 17y agoI think we have to stop considering Climate Research as a legitimate peer-reviewed journal. Perhaps we should encourage our colleagues in the climate research community to no longer submit to, or cite papers in, this journal. The other paper by MM is just garbage. [...] I can't see either of these papers being in the next IPCC report. Kevin and I will keep them out somehow — even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is! I don’t really understand what’s incriminating about this. Please explain.
- lutorm 17y agoI just want to make the point that "Me talking about how to keep you out of HN" != "you being kept out of HN".
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- dsplittgerber 17y agoAre you aware regarding to which specific points the other side, as you say, disagrees with the majority view? I have found virtually every single mainstream article about climate change to be spin, I'd like to see for myself. The wording of the consensus view may also play a role. How much in "Human activities ... are modifying the concentration of atmospheric constituents ... that absorb or scatter radiant energy. Most of the observed warming over the last 50 years is likely to have been due to the increase in greenhouse gas concentrations." is there to disagree on? It's enormously vague, is it not?
- lutorm 17y ago"The other side" seems to push a number of arguments from the hypothesis that the greenhouse effect violates fundamental physics (it doesn't, no serious scientist would argue that no matter how much they disagree with the IPCC conclusions) to disagreeing on whether the increase in CO2 is driven by warming climate instead of the other way to arguing about the specific numbers of projected radiative forcing and climate sensitivity. But you are correct. If the official IPCC estimate is that the increased radiative forcing due to greenhouse gases is [+2.07 - +2.53] W/m^2, are you "disagreeing with the consensus" if you think it's +2.06? What if it's +1.5? The real world is not binary, it's a matter of degree. Edit: For a list of things that people disagree on, you can look at the "How to talk to a climate sceptic" post, which regardless of whether you believe the responses or not is a pretty comprehensive list: http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2008/07/how_to_talk_to_a_sceptic.php http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2008/07/how_to_talk_to...
- dsplittgerber 17y agoThanks! Was looking for a link like that.
- lutorm 17y agoYour point is grossly biased. You are equating the handful of people whose communications were included in the leak with the authors of (according to the article) at least 900 (papers that support the "consensus". Given that the IPCC AR4 WG1 report that talks about the scientific basis for climate change is based on of order 1000 citations for each of the 10 chapters, I think you are significantly underestimating the body of science underlying the conclusions of the IPCC report. To think that one research group could significantly bias this, you must think they are powerful indeed. You are also equating them talking about doing something with it actually happening. People talk about doing stuff all the time, so unless you can show evidence that a) they actually tried to act on their statements and b) were in a position to exclude papers from the body of scientific literature, I find no reason to think that the body of published studies is systematically biased. Furthermore, the statements can also be interpreted as attempting (perhaps overzealously) to exclude shoddy science, not furthering a personal vendetta.
- nollidge 17y ago> The leak of emails that made it crystal clear that a handful of members of the consensus group, on a handful of occasions, talked about keeping the other side out of the process of peer-review. There, fixed that for you. The consensus of biologists is that evolution is true. The consensus of astronomers is that the Big Bang happened. The consensus of archaeologists is that the KT extinction event happened and that it was due in significant part to the Chicxulub impact. The consensus of physicists is that quantum physics and relativity are accurate models of the universe at the appropriate scales. The consensus of climate scientists is that the planet is warming and it is anthropogenic. Why is this fact irrelevant here, but not in other fields?
- KirinDave 17y agoBecause more money is involved. Because this is actually actionable and requires immediate consideration in long term business planning. And maybe, with some people, because they don't really like the idea of shouldering that much responsibility.
- abstractbill 17y agoFrom wikipedia: With a budget of 9 billion US dollars (approx. €6300M or £5600M as of Jan 2010), the LHC is one of the most expensive scientific instruments ever built in human history. The Large Hadron Collider is pretty expensive! Why does nobody ever accuse particle physicists of "making up" the Higgs?
- hga 17y agoThe LHC crew are on safer ground. If they don't find the Higgs, they're still likely to find something interesting. (After all, various people have been worried they'd find something a bit too interesting. :-)
- aphyr 17y ago$9 billion is nothing compared to the scope of government or environmental spending. In the lifetime of the LHC, US oil alone will process literally tens of trillions of dollars. Making policy decisions about a system that big has nontrivial financial impact. :) Personally, I like to believe the LHC is too awesome to fail. After the SSC debacle, nobody wants to back out of a second collider. :)
- aphyr 17y agoI'd also note that "consensus" is not a word you find in real science; As someone who has done real science (albeit in quantum mechanics, not climatology), I call bullshit. We use "consensus" all the time. There's also an understanding that consensus has historically opposed better models, which suggests we all need to keep an open mind. That doesn't change the fact that often, scientists mostly agree on stuff.
- abstractbill 17y agoEven when I was a pure mathematician, where a layperson might not expect it, we used the word "consensus" all the time. "The consensus is that Foo's proof, once checked, will be found to be correct". "The consensus is that the Wibble Conjecture must be true, even though nobody has any idea how to prove it yet". etc.
- hga 17y agoIn reference to both the comments up thread, real scientists don't use a "consensus" to bludgeon someone bringing up an inconvenient fact. WRT to the above, if Foo's proof upon checking turns out not to be correct, real scientists/mathematicians will prefect or throw away the proof, not the check that falsified it. When someone says "The consensus of climate scientists is that the planet is warming and it is anthropogenic" and it's pointed out that contrary to their very specific predictions the planet has been cooling for the last decade, what do you say real scientists should do?
- aphyr 17y agoTo respond to your example: Point out that we don't have a high confidence time series that says the planet is cooling over the last decade? For that matter, nobody has a 10-year time series for global average temp which passes any real significance test. It's just not a long enough period to deal with high frequency fluctuations: you need 30 or so years for that. (Actually, to the best of my knowledge, the last decade's average surface temp has been rising, even if the significance is below two-sigma.) To respond to the general argument, you're absolutely correct. Proofs, statistically rigorous arguments absolutely call into question the consensus. However, vague counterarguments are not sufficient to overturn carefully gathered evidence. One must weigh the arguments on the strength of their evidence and analysis. There is just not very much substantial peer reviewed research supporting a climate model with zero radiative forcing for CO2.