3 ms·
It is likely that you will never be in a car crash with your current car. It is likely that the money you spent on crumple zones, airbags, and seat belts was en
by jerf 10y ago
It is likely that you will never be in a car crash with your current car. It is likely that the money you spent on crumple zones, airbags, and seat belts was entirely wasted.
But if we conclude from that that we should remove these things from cars, we would be wrong, because we have to reason at scale about these things. At scale, the extreme events happen with some frequency.
It should also be pointed out that we are now living in a world where we are not hypothesizing that someday IoT devices may have serious insecurities that lead to real problems for people, but one where we know it is true because it happens. When the Internet basically went down on the east coast and some other places last week, plenty of people who were affected by that were also the ones who owned the devices that caused it. At scale, they made a decision to buy something that ended up taking the Internet out for themselves and others. It does no good to reason that each of them only took a small risk individually when what affects us all is the collective risk of those actions.
Just like in the automotive case, where we must consider the effects of various safety interventions on society as a whole and at scale, we must consider the effects of this security on society as a whole and at scale. Unlike the automotive case, computers have extra concerns about their ability to interact in ways that physical devices can not. And at that scale and with those concerns, no, there's nothing unreasonable about this analysis, especially in the face of the existing Mirai botnet. It's not just the visual-imagination compelling stories like burglars breaking into your house because they saw you weren't home from your camera (and then, presumably, remotely shut it off); it's all the possibilities.
You shouldn't buy a device that is open to the internet with a default root password that can't be changed and has no firmware update mechanism even available. It's not hard to take the Kantian imperative and actually show that to be unethical of you. (While the Kantian imperative is philosophically controversial, I think this is one of those cases where it applies pretty well.)