3 ms·
> Blockchains are not yet ubiquitous, but when they are (in every device and underlying many services we use), every person will have the infrastructure to crea
by wslh 10y ago
> Blockchains are not yet ubiquitous, but when they are (in every device and underlying many services we use), every person will have the infrastructure to create and maintain complex agreements for near-zero costs. (Financial agreements and otherwise.) This will be pretty transformative.
Sorry, but this is wishful thinking. The simple question about how you can enforce agreements running in blockchains can't be answered. In the real world you have the military or police force while in the blockchain itself you are pretty limited. On the other hand external oracles are the weakest part of the blockchain system. If they are hacked you hacked the agreements.
I think the blockchain/cryptocurrency/smart-contracts/app-coin scene is really exciting but the connection with the real world is problematic, more when the financial institutions are enforcing AML/KYC/etc
- aianus 10y ago> The simple question about how you can enforce agreements running in blockchains can't be answered. Check out https://www.augur.net/ https://www.augur.net/ for an attempt at answering that question. They crowdsource the outcomes of the various bets from people holding REP tokens. REP holders have a financial incentive to act honestly to increase or maintain the value of their REP.
- wslh 10y agoI know Augur, but what part of Augur is an attempt to answering my question?
- aianus 10y agoThey developed a way of enforcing agreements (bets) made on a blockchain without courts, police, military, or easy-to-hack external oracles.
- wslh 10y agoAugur doesn't answer my original concern. If you have a smart contract between, for example, two companies, that information is private and it doesn't work like a popular baseball game. If one company doesn't follow the contract you need to solve the problem in the real world. Also, we don't know yet how public blockchains (where Augur runs) work with State or powerful actor attacks, when the incentives are not purely financial.
- etherael 10y agoOne way you could solve the problem in the real world is track down the delinquent counterparty to the contract, drag them into an expensive legal system, subject them to the costs thereof, levy a penalty on them, hope that they pay it, in the even that they do not or cannot, seize their assets, in the event that they have none or you cannot, punish them with prison, in the event that they resist, kill them. Sure, that's the traditionally accepted way to go about solving the problem in the real world. But there are many other ways to solve the same problems that we're all intimately familiar with by now based around reputation systems. When it becomes public that a counterparty to a contract has engaged in delinquency, they suffer a reputational hit. If their reputation has value (and there is nothing about pseudonymous entities that mean that they cannot accrue reputational value, rating systems work on darknet markets quite well and have since their inception), and the amount of damage to their reputation is higher cost than making good on the contract, then they will make good on the contract (and even if they can't, you've punished their delinquency by damaging their reputation, instead of dragging them through an expensive inefficient corrupt legal system involving violence as the final sanction). All sharing economy and peer to peer systems that currently exist work on systems of this kind, and cryptocurrencies to the extent that reputations are valued and contracts made similarly so, and this will only become more prevalent as time goes by. Not everything requires recourse to violence.
- wslh 10y agoReputation doesn't work in problems with a lot of money/power at stake. You can easily hack the system behaving like a good citizen for a long time until you consume all your reputation in a big transaction. Not only that, reputation is a hard problem if you are a newcomer.
- EdHominem 10y agoThat's why many people say "Everything is an exit scam in waiting". Even your legitimate meatspace bank will cheat if it thinks the economics make sense. You could use transparency to tell how much a given escrow agent is holding and don't use them if it approaches the value of their reputation. And/or use a system where they don't hold the funds, they merely choose to unlock a transaction to pay to A or B.