6 ms·
If you read the letter, it's a lot more than "answering a few questions". He gets two weeks to provide an enormous amount of detailed information about the pro
by BurningFrog 10y ago
If you read the letter, it's a lot more than "answering a few questions".
He gets two weeks to provide an enormous amount of detailed information about the product, I assume under threat of legal consequences if any of it contains an error, interspersed with lots of reminders that they can and will close down his business if they feel like it.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoYeah it seems a lot of the community here thinks that if he just threw together a few bullet points in an email response the NHTSA would sit back, say "Okay, great have fun!" and not, you know, make a big deal out of it. I, uh, disagree.
- DanBC 10y agoI more thinking "why the hell doesn't he have the answers already?"
- vvanders 10y agoThis, it's not a secret that NHSTA is interested in self-driving cars and would be asking the serious questions that he should already have responses for.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoHaving mentioned this elsewhere, I have first-hand experience going between SMEs and X/Y/Z bureaucratic entities for half a decade and there's a big difference between "having the answers you think are satisfactory" and "providing answers that they think are satisfactory." GI Joe pointed this out long ago in that "Knowing is half the battle" and putting it into a work product that accomplishes its task is the other half of the battle in this case (with no guarantees the responses provided will end the inquiry / threat of fines).
- taco_emoji 10y agoThat doesn't really answer the question. You don't need first-hand experience to know that government red tape is onerous. It was flatly predictable that the NHTSA -- the government agency concerned with roadway safety -- would make such inquiries. So why didn't Comma work with the NHTSA and get their blessing before announcing a release date? I mean yeah, it sucks that the government is so darn picky about things, but that's not an excuse to just skip the process. They should have hired someone like you from the start to ensure that their ducks were in a row when they were ready to release.
- mikeash 10y agoWe'll never know, because he's not even trying. Here's a nicely readable transcript of what they wanted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12817061 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12817061 None of them sound particularly difficult to answer. Maybe they are difficult to answer in sufficient detail to satisfy the NHTSA, but you can always start out by answering them as best you can, and then seeing if they want more. There are people on the other end of this letter, not some unthinking machine. Toss off a quick response and say, "If you have any other questions or need further detail on the answers given here, please feel free to contact me at any time."
- DannyBee 10y agoIf he gave them the docs he certainly has on this stuff, and said "i am glad to sit down and walk you through any other answers or questions you may have", they'd be fine with it as an initial response. I think you have pretty much already assigned a negative agenda to NHTSA, when they've just requested some info. While they may have followups if they don't like the answers they get, of all the agencies you find, NHTSA is not one that tends to have a serious pre-bias towards anyone.
- jdonaldson 10y agoYeah, the extremely short timeline here combined with excessive fines puts this squarely in "F-You" territory.
- akamaka 10y agoI agree that the fines are set at a level more appropriate for a large corporation, but I looked at the questions, and they're all things I would want to know as a customer, and I would expect for them to mostly already know (e.g. "What weather conditions have you tested this in?"). There's only one question which could be considered too broad, which is compliance with safety standards, but it's generously worded as a yes or no question. He could simply answer "no, I haven't analyzed my product against against the safety standards".
- bdrool 10y agoAs others have pointed out, the short timeline is mainly due to Hotz himself and his plan for putting the product on the market so quickly.
- bradjohnson 10y agoThey specifically state in the instructions "If you are unable to respond because you do not have all or any of the precise information needed to respond, provide an estimate." This would imply that they are willing to postpone the fine given that he is actually putting together the required documentation. The required documentation is not even excessive, he should know most of that stuff off hand and should definitely have documentation for it if he's planning a release this year.
- scott_s 10y agoI don't see a problem with that. In fact, I want government regulators to do that. He should have anticipated this process, and been working with them since the beginning.
- kefka 10y agoWith that kind of talk, only those "well connected" can readily do that. Hmm. Regulatory capture? Yeah. That.
- smallnamespace 10y agoIf by 'well-connected', you mean people who have the means and resources to properly test their products, then I agree.
- kefka 10y ago"Product" ? I'm seeing a demo he wasn't selling. And when a big govt stick comes a'knocking, unless you're also big and well connected, you will get shut down. This was clear as a way to "do insane amount of documentation in a laughably short timeframe, or fuck your business with a fine-stick." Yeah, GeoHotz is an ass, but this is inane. Great way to kill small businesses.
- smallnamespace 10y agoSo what would you have the regulator do here--wait until the product is on the market first? He's publicly stated they were aiming for year-end release.
- kefka 10y agoThat may be what he stated. I can say that I plan to launch pigs from a catapult tomorrow. Doesn't make it true. I would understand filing that documentation prior to selling. But I'm also familiar with using "Filing with govt" as a tool of oppression that large companies try to pass as a barrier of market entry. Lawyers are rather expensive, and requiring more volumnous paperwork requires more lawyers. And speaking of that, what is the repercussions of what you send to NHTSA? Say he sends something inaccurate or glosses over details. What is the liability of sending something wrong to govt? Hmm... Yes. Wait till he's selling them. And when there's a claim, act on it. Not before.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> He gets two weeks to provide an enormous amount of detailed information about the product Which either he should have readily available, since he's the creator, or he should have known, since he should be able to demonstrate the safety of the device. > I assume under threat of legal consequences if any of it contains an error Usually you hand over what you have, then you negotiate with the regulator for a time frame to answer the more difficult questions. If you're unsure about something, tell the regulator up front. The correct response is not to throw a tantrum and shut everything down. > interspersed with lots of reminders that they can and will close down his business if they feel like it That's the textbook definition of 'regulation'.
- BurningFrog 10y ago> > they can and will close down his business if they feel like it > That's the textbook definition of 'regulation'. Right, and it's one of the big problems I have with this form of regulation. I think it violates the idea of "Rule of Law", as opposed to "Rule of Man", which was one of the major factors behind the rise of modern free society.
- taco_emoji 10y agoCan you explain? You seem to be implying that you believe that the NHTSA is capriciously making demands of Comma but not to other similar companies in a similar stage of market-readiness.
- BurningFrog 10y agoThey certainly could, which is part of my point. Whether they do or not depends on the honesty, bias, and personal ambitions of the people running the agency. The empirical experience is that regulatory agencies over time gravitate towards favoring the big established players in the industry they're regulating. The economist term is "Regulatory Capture".
- smallnamespace 10y ago
- akehrer 10y agoHe's got two weeks to provide the detailed information he should already have or a reason why he doesn't have it. He could even provide an estimate (see instruction #4 in the Special Order). The threat of legal consequences is if any information/reason is missing or if the order is completely ignored. Getting your company shut down by the government only comes after a lot of back and forth communication and is usually due to willful negligence on the company's part.
- idlewords 10y agoThis is why lawyers exist, and the job they are trained to do. A competent one would have told Hotz on Day 1 that this letter was coming, and would already have the documents ready in a folder with a little pink ribbon bow.
- shashwatak 10y agoConsidering the gravity of what they're building, they should already have detailed answers to all these questions. They shouldn't have launched a startup without spending massive time and effort ironing out these details. Two weeks is plenty of time to organize your thoughts.
- danaliv 10y agoIf he doesn't already know the answers to these questions, he's got no business selling this product. Everything that they're asking for—essentially the owner's manual, product requirements, and test methodology—would be readily at hand for any serious operation. You can't just wire up an Arduino to the CAN bus of a 4,000-pound missile and sell it on the open market willy-nilly.
- donpdonp 10y ago"You can't just wire up an Arduino to the CAN bus of a 4,000-pound missile and sell it on the open market" best self-driving comment ever.
- mikeryan 10y agoHe gets two weeks to provide an enormous amount of detailed information about the product, I assume under threat of legal consequences if any of it contains an error, interspersed with lots of reminders that they can and will close down his business if they feel like it. He has announced the release of the product, was taking orders for it and said it was going to be shipping by the end of the year [1] The timeframe here is driven by Hotz who apparently has not had any communication with the relevant regulatory agencies. Any attorney he hires would tell him "Okay lets push back the release to mid next year while we work with the NHTSA on resolving their concerns" and the NHTSA would probably be perfectly fine with working with him. "Move fast and break shit" doesn't count when you're putting lives at risk. lots of reminders that they can and will close down his business if they feel like it - yes and they should. [1] https://electrek.co/2016/09/14/comma-ai-claims-to-have-packaged-the-tesla-autopilot-in-a-999-aftermarket-device/ https://electrek.co/2016/09/14/comma-ai-claims-to-have-packa...
- jahewson 10y agoFirst of all, he's not being asked for an "enormous amount of detailed information". He's being asked some really simple questions about how his product complies with existing regulatory requirements. Which apparently, it doesn't. Worse still, by abandoning the product he's made it clear that he had no intention of complying with existing regulations and has an astounding disregard for his customer's safety.