3 ms·
Two things: firstly I think most teaching devolves to a cargo cult, unless the culture explicitly tries to keep this from happening. Secondly, this quote: "Adm
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
Two things: firstly I think most teaching devolves to a cargo cult, unless the culture explicitly tries to keep this from happening.
Secondly, this quote: "Admittedly, a tenacious commitment to improvement seems to be part of the Japanese national heritage."
I wonder if a missing phrase might be "collective and individual improvement".
Anglo cultures seem to lack this, because they seem to be more about authoritarian displays of power than about striving for collaborative competence.
It's not that individual teachers are necessarily authoritarian - although many school boards seem to be. It's more the political subtext is 'Shut up, listen to my authority, obey, and repeat."
A culture based on "Think, explore, explain, discuss, debate, experiment, and fact-check" works very differently.
When teaching looks more like the first than the second, *it's not really teaching STEM fundamentals" - it's teaching a robotised cargo cult version of STEM that doesn't truly promote STEM principles.
Kids have three options - they can either obey, which will get them good grades but no deep understanding. They can fail - which is a popular choice, because rote learning is harder than learning by deep understanding. Or they can fail and rebel and decide that math is a waste of everyone's time, because who the hell cares, and would you like fries with that?
So math teaching is a symptom of a deeper problem, which is a culture that's more geared towards top-down competitive hierarchical classroom dynamics - with the teacher as top dog - than to promoting non-competitive collaboration and sharing of individual insights, with the teacher as inspiring facilitator.