7 ms·
Why does Uber not allow its drivers to set fares? Wouldn't that be the true "Ayn Rand approach" to a marketplace? It would be cool if, as a rider, I could set
by chatmasta 10y ago
Why does Uber not allow its drivers to set fares? Wouldn't that be the true "Ayn Rand approach" to a marketplace?
It would be cool if, as a rider, I could set a maximum fare I'm willing to pay, the drivers can bid on the fare, and I'm matched with some combination of nearestDriver * lowestFare.
I imagine Uber has thought of this already, so there must be some reason they're not doing it. Why?
Classic economics suggests this would result in a more efficient market. Perhaps Uber has modeled it and found it would also result in lower fares.
- nickff 10y agoI don't like to put words in other people's minds, or thoughts in their heads, but I would hazard to guess that Uber has set prices for the sake of stability, and to give the users (drivers and passengers) some expectation of what fares might look like on a 'normal' day. It may be that as more users join the platform, it could be transitioned to a bid/ask model. A bid/ask model may lead to more efficient pricing, but could increase transaction costs and lead to a less efficient overall market. I do not know whether this is the case, and it would be difficult to test, though Uber and Lyft are in a very good position to test.
- pdkl95 10y ago> Uber has set prices for the sake of stability Uber forces price instability with "Surge Pricing".
- return0 10y agoCouldn't each driver just propose a fare and let the customer accept it?
- nickff 10y agoYes, that would be an ask-only model. The issue there would be that the customers would have to select from a list, where the list composition was constantly changing (in busy areas). People might also be hesitant to user an app if they have no idea what it will cost. These issues would probably be solvable or solved, as I'm sure prices would stabilize in busy markets, and people would probably be willing to accept any price under $X; transaction costs would still be higher than with the current Uber/Lyft model.
- return0 10y agoI really dont think it would be a big bother. Most of the time the drivers would accept Uber's proposed price, and i really see no big issue with selecting a driver/fare from a list. IT would also create a entire market for "uber fare optimization".
- EdHominem 10y agoAn open market should also exist, but for branded products I'd prefer consistency over slight potential savings. That's the difference between Uber and craigslist.
- gaius 10y agoIt won't tho' - you'll end up with the wedding photographer model - where new entrants operate at a loss to build a portfolio, then when they want to start charging the established rate, they are in turn undercut by new entrants. It's a brutal market, and a race to the bottom.
- zeroer 10y agoClassical economics usually take as assumptions that all actors have complete information and unlimited computational resources and are perfectly rational. In the real world, we have decision fatigue and may engage in regret avoidance and end up not taking Uber at all if it's perceived as more difficult.
- nickff 10y agoThis is a false assertion (and possibly a straw-man); Adam Smith wrote "The Wealth of Nations" as a study of the way things actually worked, not a thought experiment. Classical economists (such as Smith) did not assume perfect information, and everyone knows that there is never perfect information.
- mark_edward 10y agoYes, the above poster is thinking of neoclassical economics. Classical economists like Smith, Ricardo, and Marx barely if at all touched on things like perfect information, rationality, or perfect competition. Those are all neoclassical paradigms.
- SilasX 10y agoThat comes down to the "Nature of the Firm" dynamic[1]; there's a tradeoff between market efficiency and transaction costs, and every organization faces it. You can e.g. ask the same question about "why not auction every shift?", "why not auction every internal work product transfer?" (extreme example: why not auction every fetch-coffee task?) The answer is that having to re-auction every subcomponent introduces transaction costs that may eclipse the efficiency gains of selling at the optimal, market price. In the case of Uber's drivers, that "transaction cost" includes the additional lag in taking bids before you get matched, and higher unpredictability of fares. Of course, it actually gets kinda complicated here: Sidecar did more what you're describing, and (IIUIC) eliminated that lag by letter drivers submit a kind of formula that calculated and submitted their bid based on those factors (e.g distance to pickup), so it's not necessarily some kind of huge dealbreaker to do auctions; drivers don't have to sit down and scratch their heads about how much they'd need to do every request.[2] Sidecar didn't succeed though -- they went out of business on this model (and keep in mind they had a much more solid defense of workers' contractor status for exactly this reason). But this might not have been the cause of their failure. I'm guessing it comes down to there being a big premium on being able to (for lack of a better term) "commoditize" the ride hailing services so that eliminating such bidding was a net positive. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nature_of_the_Firm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nature_of_the_Firm [2] though note that in Sidecar's case, driver's got a list of bids and consciously chose the one they liked based on their implicit criteria rather than being auto-matched
- CobrastanJorji 10y agoI'm certainly no expert, but part of the initial appeal of Uber to me was the price simplicity. There was no tipping, I didn't have to hand anybody any money or worry about what credit card they accepted. I just got a cab. Now that they have the thing where it tells you how much your fare WOULD be given an address, it's even better. The surge stuff makes this worse, but at least I understand the idea. Having me bid for a taxi trip ala priceline would pretty much ruin Uber for me.
- uremog 10y agoI would not want to use that. That sounds beyond annoying, trying to guess the lowest fare that will be accepted.