3 ms·
I'm always amazed at how techies are so often unable to consider other people's points of view. You'd think I'd be used to it by now, but no. If you don't like
by mikeash 10y ago
I'm always amazed at how techies are so often unable to consider other people's points of view. You'd think I'd be used to it by now, but no.
If you don't like the new design, that's totally fine. I've seen a lot of people saying that. But when you say that the new design is bad for everybody, or bad for millions of people you haven't met, based solely on your own personal reasons, you've lost it.
I'm a developer. The only reason I'm not buying one of these is because what I currently have is just fine, and I don't feel like spending the money. The touch bar looks really cool. It might not end up being very useful, but I think I'd like to have it. If it's not useful, well, no big deal.
Function keys? Never use 'em. Escape key? Having it available as a touch button doesn't seem like a major problem. If it turns out to be, then I'll learn or configure some other shortcut for it and get on with my life.
Now, that's just me. Your opinion may differ, and that's fine. I just ask you to have the same attitude. It's silly to say that this machine "is not a laptop for developers." It's not a laptop for you, apparently, and for people with similar needs and opinions. But not all developers are you.
- 51Cards 10y agoHere is my issue with the new touch bar as a general UI element. Things meant for fingers should have tactile feedback unless you're also looking at the same location (like a touch screen) where you can get visual feedback. This offers no tactile response when used, and its layout changes constantly, thus it needs to be looked at to use it. That means you have to shift your vision focus from screen to keyboard repeatedly as you move through apps (or even while in the same app if they make the content dynamic). To me this is bad UI design at a fundamental level. I can see this being handy as a "slider" style control (though a touch pad edge could be as well). Otherwise though, especially when used as "buttons" my opinion is that it is going to be very tiresome to use extensively and slow general interactions down. If you need this kind of interaction style it should be on a touch screen without forcing the eyes to change focus or monitor changes in peripheral vision. TLDR There is a reason we touch type. Touch. Exactly what this is missing.
- djrogers 10y agoI think the idea here is that it's easier to look down than it is to spend a long period of time holding your arm up to a laptop screen. Either you're moving you're eyes off the screen or lifting your hands up off the keyboard - I'd say there are arguments for and against each, and I look forward to seeing how this solution actually works in use as opposed to the armchair theories we've been seeing.
- mikeash 10y agoI don't think the "shift your vision" part is a big deal, since it's right next to the screen. I do think there is a disadvantage in not having tactile feedback all the same, and it'll be interesting to see how that plays out. As it stands currently, the presence of tactile feedback for those keys doesn't do me any good, because I don't use them. If the touch bar ends up being useful for me, it'll be a net gain even if the experience of locating the controls is worse. For people who actually use the function keys, I sympathize and I can totally understand how this is likely to be a huge step backwards. But "developers" does not equate to "uses function keys regularly."
- 542458 10y agoI type a lot. But 99+% of that is A-Z and common symbols. While I normally touch type, I use the function row so infrequently that I don't have the muscle memory to correctly locate the f-keys. The only ones I can do blind are esc, volume up and volume down, and even those I only type rarely. All the rest require me to stop and look at the labels on the keys. Furthermore, I'm not really using the key shape for those to hit them. I'm mostly just hitting them based on their relative position from the home row. So IMHO at least this wouldn't really affect me - If I end up with one of these laptops I'll still probably be able to hit the few I do infrequently use without looking just fine, and for all the rest I'm looking for labels anyways.
- erikb 10y agoTechies don't say it's useless for everybody, though. They say it's useless for techies. And that should be a statement they are allowed to make.
- mikeash 10y agoI disagree. "Techies" is a huge group and it's ridiculous to think you can speak for all of them, especially when your argument comes down to function keys. As I said, I'm a member of that group and I don't use them. This person is saying that the new MacBook Pro is not for me. What makes it OK for them to speak for me?
- erikb 10y agoSee it this way. On one side you have a group this person cares about. On the other side there is this person, you, he doesn't care about. Maybe he just doesn't count you as part of the group as he says "we techies"? Then he's not speaking for you, right? It's not so political correct, but that is how we techies are. Get used to it if you want to deal with us.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sliverstorm 10y agoBut when you say that the new design is bad for everybody... It's a little funny, considering the inverse of this is basically a core plot point in "Silicon Valley". Life imitates art imitates life.
- AdamJacobMuller 10y agoMy problem is thus: I'm worried I won't like the new laptop and its going to decrease productivity. I have a very small desire for change. I do like my existing mid-2014 15" MBP but I beat on them really hard so at almost 2 years old, it needs a replacement now. I'm worried that I will basically end up in a position where I won't have anything that is a suitable replacement for this laptop when it breaks. The lack of ANY USB ports is frustrating too. I have a hardware USB YubiKey Nano dongle that I leave permanently plugged into my computer for 2FA to various services. I don't want to loose the ability to do that (and I'm not even sure its physically possible to have something like that for USB-C -- its just too small) I use vim for everything and thus obsessively use the esc key (yes, I know you can remap it, but I'll be fighting against 20+ years of muscle memory). Will the new virtual ESC key be enough? I hope so. The lack of magsafe also really irks me. I used to destroy chargers like crazy before magsafe. Replacing magsafe with USB-C doesn't seem like a positive step to me. I really want to love this computer, because I really don't see another option. I'm just worried that I won't and then I won't have any better options.