5 ms·
The question is who doesn't do crap like this with popular consumer downloads. Apple does it with itunes+quicktime, last time I had to download Java there were
by guelo 17y ago
The question is who doesn't do crap like this with popular consumer downloads. Apple does it with itunes+quicktime, last time I had to download Java there were toolbars, WinAmp ditto. Maybe Google and Microsoft are the only ones that don't, though they don't really have super popular consumer downloads besides maybe Gtalk and some of Microsoft's document viewers.
- ugh 17y agoNo, Apple doesn’t. You click a link and the file downloads. You can enter your email address but you don’t have to. You can download a standalone version of QuickTime if you really want to [1] and it’s pretty obvious that iTunes won’t work without QuickTime. [1] http://www.apple.com/quicktime/download/ http://www.apple.com/quicktime/download/
- guelo 17y agoOh I guess they changed that at some point, it used to be tricky to download just Quicktime. Still, when installing iTunes on Windows they don't even give you the option of not installing Quicktime, Bonjour, Apple Mobile Device Support, Apple Application Support and Apple Software Update (which will go ahead and install other garbage if you're not careful).
- ugh 17y agoI honestly wouldn’t install any Apple software on a PC – Apple doesn’t like you :)
- armandososa 17y agoBut they install Safari for windows whenever you update iTunes. You can opt-out (just with the adobe download manager) but it's not obvious for the common user. I've heard both from my dad and my sister say 'Hey! what's this Safari thing?' because they don't remember installing it.
- ugh 17y agoAdmittedly, their Windows software sucks :)
- mishmash 17y agoAnd I've never understood that.
- pak 17y agoIf you're a web developer, you'd wish Apple were more aggressive and just replaced IE with Safari entirely. ...I wouldn't mind that. Especially if it was IE6.
- Silhouette 17y agoNo, I wouldn't, because I have to test with IE to make sure my stuff is going to work for the required customer base. Other parties messing around with my carefully configured development system are not welcome, ever. You don't get to install software updates without checking with me first. You don't get to install add-ons or toolbars or system tray utilities or lurking processes. These things are a threat to my system and my ability to do a proper, professional job using it, and they will be dealt with accordingly.
- pak 17y agoOk, but I'm referring to the general home user (that uses iTunes), not a carefully configured corporate environment. If all these moms and pops out there switched to Safari and cut IE6 usage in half, I really would not mind. Yes, I know it's evil, but so is supporting IE6; this is my disgruntled self speaking.
- Silhouette 17y agoIME, most home users left IE6 behind a long time ago. Sure, there's still the odd one, but it's the big corporations with their standard desktop configurations and in-house software tied to IE6 that are really holding things back. At least we seem to have turned a corner in recent months, with even major players like Google basically saying that if you're still on IE6 it's now you're problem not theirs, so I imagine even the hold-outs will find it increasingly difficult to ignore progress in future.
- Tichy 17y ago"The question is who doesn't do crap like this with popular consumer downloads." That's why I prefer to use Linux. Even Google pushes their spybar along with lots of downloads.
- gaius 17y agoYeah, it's insane. J2EE for example is "serious" software, why would anyone downloading it also want a Yahoo toolbar!?
- Silhouette 17y agoMy question is why Firefox even has a mechanism through which these companies can install add-ons without the user's consent, and which in some cases can't even be uninstalled using the normal add-ons controls. Wasn't Firefox supposed to offer a safer choice than certain other browsers, with an add-on system that kept it lightweight and provided the user with control over exactly what extra functionality they wanted to have available? Someone lost the plot somewhere.
- TorKlingberg 17y agoBecause there is nothing Firefox can do to prevent it. I suppose Mozilla prefers they do it with a documented interface rather than modifying the Firefox install directly. If you want to prevent applications from installing plugins into each other, then you need an operating system that sandboxes each application (difficult), or use a package manager that is run by a trusted party (Linux).
- kierank 17y agoGoogle's updater is worse. There were seven memory hogging instances running when I looked once.
- protomyth 17y agoGoogle's updater should be manageable. It is a real pain when a whole lab of machines decides to update Google Earth at the same time. Not all of us have super high speed internet. I really wish Google would realize this.