3 ms·
Wow, this is pretty lame. The various stuff I've become a "fan" of (apparently now renamed "like") was under the understanding, explicitly stated by Facebook, t
by _delirium 17y ago
Wow, this is pretty lame. The various stuff I've become a "fan" of (apparently now renamed "like") was under the understanding, explicitly stated by Facebook, that it wasn't part of the public information. Seems they changed that without warning or opt-out? Is there at least an easy way to quickly remove all the hundreds of things I've become a fan of before Google starts indexing them, if I'd prefer them not to be indexed?
What I'm getting from this is that you should assume that all your Facebook information is publicly available, and act accordingly, because they could make it so at any time. At this rate of trustworthiness, I wouldn't be that surprised if in 2 years status updates were made retroactively public with no opt-out (and maybe without even telling you).
Edit: Is this even legal? Consider the following scenario: Someone signed up for a Facebook account 3 years ago, and entered some of this information, at a time when their privacy policy explicitly promised that the information would not be shared. They have not logged in since, so cannot be said to have even implicitly agreed to a change in the privacy policy (and Facebook has not mailed out any notice of the change). Now their information is made public, in violation of the privacy policy. Not sure how easy it'd be to enforce, but at the very least it seems sleazy.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 17y agoHmm, if it's opt-in that's much less problematic. EFF's description of "removed its users' ability to control who can see their own interests and personal information" certainly doesn't sound opt-in! Are they talking about different things, or just mistaken? I don't seem to see any dialogs on my own page...
- indigoviolet 17y agoI don't think it's fully rolled out yet.
- sinc 17y agoyup, doesn't work for me yet either. But thanks for the fast response and showing that you care.
- wdewind 17y agoWell wait, this doesn't say anything different than the EFF article does it? Yes you can still remove connections, but you also remove the interest as well right? (I have no idea, I like many of the above have zero trust for FB and deleted acct months ago).
- argv_empty 17y agoYes you can still remove connections, but you also remove the interest as well right? Ok, then. If I later decide I really want to repost that info (and keep it friends-only), I'll probably stick it in "Favorite Quotations" or "About Me." If they scrape that too, maybe I'll repost it in captcha-like text in my photos section.
- wdewind 17y agoBut why should you have to keep playing catch up? Yes it's not HARD to put stuff there, but you can't argue it's not bad UX to constantly pull the rug out from under users like this. Captcha like text? Seriously?
- argv_empty 17y agoSure. At that point, participation in Facebook would be nothing more than a game I play on occasion. If I get annoyed with it, I can put it away for a bit. This just makes the "post information" part more difficult. Except I don't much care about that part anyway. If I won't have my information protected, I won't post it, and I won't feel like I've lost much by not posting it anyway. Really, this just solidifies Facebook's role in my life as nothing more than an occasional diversion. My reaction is mostly amusement at Facebook's self-destruction.
- indigoviolet 17y agoI deleted my response to this by mistake. Here's what I'd posted, in essence: http://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=382978412130 http://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=382978412130 Users can edit which connections they want to add to their profile. They can also hide some connections on their profile, and remove others if they so choose. Disclosure: I work for Facebook. My opinions are my own.
- ElbertF 17y ago> you should assume that all your Facebook information is publicly available Indeed you should, I'd say this applies to any website.
- _delirium 17y agoThat would certainly make mint.com pretty interesting...
- mjgoins 17y agomint.com is a much more absurd idea than facebook. And the fact that it has users is even more mind-boggling.
- bruceboughton 17y agoAnd online banking for that matter...
- btilly 17y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1281750 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1281750 pointed to a Time article about http://suicidemachine.org/ http://suicidemachine.org/ which can be used to delete your whole Facebook account if you want.
- Estragon 17y agoThat's exactly what I did. Merely complaining about this is a bit dependent, because they've repeately demonstrated that they have no interest in users' privacy.
- graywh 17y agoAnd now Facebook puts TOS and privacy policy changes on a Page (Facebook Site Governance) that you have to be a fan of/follow/like in order to be aware of anything.