4 ms·
> Options are a cop out. It’s the designer’s job to figure out the best way to use the product, and delegating that choice to the user is pure laziness. Hive on
by SCdF 10y ago
> Options are a cop out. It’s the designer’s job to figure out the best way to use the product, and delegating that choice to the user is pure laziness. Hive only resorts to options as a last resort.
I think if you are building a simple tool to solve a simple problem, this makes sense.
On the other hand, I think this gets abused in the other direction: by designers using this as an excuse to not think about flexibility, or engage in humility. It's like the misuse of premature optimsation, but for designers.
For example, I think it's instructive that almost[1] none of the popular pro tools in any industry follow this guideline. Those tools are not for easing users in, they are for getting shit done: they understand that the idea that some UX designer can come along and tell the entire photography world how to process raw files, or tell developers how to build software in N different languages, or what a film editor's process should be for making movies etc, is utter druff.
This is why, as I understand it, the film industry reacted to strongly and negatively to Final Cut X: Apple were saying "we don't care what your current process is, you must now edit films this way, in this order, using this process, because we know better".
[1] I wanted to just say "none" here, but I obviously haven't used all pro tools
- svantana 10y agoAgree 100%. And even if it's not a pro tool, what's wrong with having options? I think it comes down to two reasons: 1) It clutters the user experience 2) App designers are benevolent gods that keep users from self-harm Now 1) I can understand, though in that case I prefer something like Overcast, where the settings menu has a submenu called "Nitpicky Details", for those of us who really care. 2) seems to be a prevalent opinion in the business these days -- while it makes sense for security on mobile devices (no root access etc), a lot of times it's just pure conceit IMHO.