4 ms·
If Congress legally empowered an un-elected five person 'Super Congress' that wielded the power of Congress itself to make laws independently would you feel lik
by Spivak 10y ago
If Congress legally empowered an un-elected five person 'Super Congress' that wielded the power of Congress itself to make laws independently would you feel like your voice at the ballot box was being undermined?
I'm not saying the US regulatory agencies are at that point, but I would feel better about them if their power was more directly checked by the Executive branch.
Instead of "FCC voted today on a new ISP resulations..." it would be "Today President Obama approves new FCC recommendation...".
- meddlepal 10y agoThat's great and all if you like the president. Enjoy when its president Palin, Trump, Cruz, or Bachmann for example.
- Frogolocalypse 10y ago> I would feel better about them if their power was more directly checked by the Executive branch. They can. The executive can always modify or repeal the act that defines their constitution and authority.
- pdonis 10y ago> The executive can always modify or repeal the act that defines their constitution and authority. Um, what? Once it's signed into law (which the acts that empower agencies like the FCC are), the executive branch can't modify the law at all. Only Congress can. The only thing the executive can do is veto a bill when it comes, to prevent it from becoming law in the first place.
- Frogolocalypse 10y ago> Only Congress can. Sorry, I should have said 'government'. There are three branches of the US government : the legislature, the judiciary, and the executive. You have a say in all of them though. Don't you vote in your congress-people and senators? So... They can. The government can always modify or repeal the act that defines their constitution and authority. They're your representative. If you don't like an act, get them to change it.
- pdonis 10y ago> I should have said 'government'. Ah, ok. Yes, the government--specifically the legislative branch--can always modify or repeal a law. > The government can always modify or repeal the act that defines their constitution and authority. If by "their" you mean "the FCC's" (or some other agency), then yes. But if by "their" you mean "the government's" in general, it's not so easy. A Constitutional amendment has a much higher threshold of passage than a simple law. It takes a 2/3 majority of both houses of Congress to propose an amendment, and then it takes 3/4 of the states ratifying it before it actually can take effect. > If you don't like an act, get them to change it. Sure, as long as enough other voters agree with you to get their attention. Which practically never happens.
- Frogolocalypse 10y ago> A Constitutional amendment has a much higher threshold of passage than a simple law. You are misunderstanding the word 'constitution'. Every company and regulatory body has one. It defines who does what, and the 'what you can do, and more importantly, what you should do' of a regulatory body is defined within the act. It is not the 'american constitution'. It is created and modified during the regular practice of government with the creation and modification of an act. Every democratic government, and indeed, even non-democratic ones, does it roughly the same way. If it didn't happen this way, cars would still be driving with lead petrol. > Sure, as long as enough other voters agree with you to get their attention. It happens all of the time. You know dude, I'm not really sure you know how the government functions. This is what they do, and there are so many levels of it. It's true that large multi-state regulatory bodies have larger impacts, and therefore require more support, in order to be enacted. But they get created in the first place for a reason, and end up getting modified for a reason. Your representatives create and modify acts that allocate funds to fund regulatory bodies to enforce laws. That's democracy. That's how it works.
- pdonis 10y ago> You are misunderstanding the word 'constitution'. If you want to use that word in an unusual way, that's fine; but I didn't understand that that's how you were using it in reference to regulatory bodies created by US statutes. ("Statute", btw, is the usual way of referring to laws that tell what regulatory bodies can and should do.) > You know dude, I'm not really sure you know how the government functions. You know, I'm not really sure you know how to describe how the government functions using proper terminology. If you had said "statute" in the first place, which, as above, is the correct term for what you are referring to, I would have understood what you said right away. But you didn't. > Your representatives create and modify acts that allocate funds to fund regulatory bodies to enforce laws. Yes, and these are called "statutes", not a "constitution".
- hackuser 10y ago> Instead of "FCC voted today on a new ISP resulations..." it would be "Today President Obama approves new FCC recommendation...". Again, how could that be done realistically? The President would do nothing else and still have no chance to keep up. They could print the statement the way you describe, but it would be deceitful. Also, we want to depoliticize regulations; I'm not sure I want the President involved in every one.
- matthewmcg 10y agoThere's a longstanding principle in U.S. Constitutional Law called the nondelegation doctrine[1]. Congress has broad authority to grant administrative and rulemaking authority to executive branch agencies, but it can't just give them blank-check power as a mini-legislature. Instead, it has to provide an "inteligible principle" to guide agency rulemaking. [1] See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._W._Hampton,_Jr.,_%26_Co._v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._W._Hampton,_Jr.,_%26_Co._v....