3 ms·
The thing with the links on wiki is that if they lead to obscure third-party site, the user would trust them at the level of trust for Wikipedia. But if Wikiped
by smsm42 10y ago
The thing with the links on wiki is that if they lead to obscure third-party site, the user would trust them at the level of trust for Wikipedia. But if Wikipedia community has no idea what this site is, they'd feel uncomfortable using these for linking. Especially if there's danger than in 10 years whoever runs this site gives up, loses the domain, some spammer or criminal buys it and gets all the naive people from Wikipedia coming to them and trusting them since Wikipedia referred them.
For archive.org it is a known, established and trusted organization. It's actually has an office within walking distance from Wikimedia offices, AFAIK :) - not that it is very important, just an interesting fact. The point is there's no reputation problem. But for site that is less known, there is.
I understand the frustration of people about not being trusted, but that's how it works - trust needs to be earned. I don't see any way to it but for whoever runs the bot to talk to Wikipedia community and earn their trust. Name-calling won't exactly be helpful here like some do here in comments. Shady practices used by whoever wrote the bot like using tons of IPs and not identifying the bot properly also doesn't help. You can't be sneaky and complain there's no trust at the same time.