3 ms·
The big question is this: People end up more and more segmented into their filter bubbles. This has led to extreme behaviour during the US elections already.
by kuschku 10y ago
The big question is this:
People end up more and more segmented into their filter bubbles. This has led to extreme behaviour during the US elections already.
We really really don’t want to repeat that horrible situation with the federal election in Germany 2017. The question is how we can prevent that.
________________________
My personal suggestion would be to require Google to only use non-personalized ranking for all news and political articles, and to require Facebook to add fact-checking previews to every single article posted discussing a topic on which a fact-check exists.
So that if someone posts a Trump tweet on Facebook, in the preview it’d also display a short fact-check from both sides of the political spectrum, and any longer article would also always be presented together with an opposite point of view.
The traditional media have been required to present multiple points of view on topics, and to fact-check political statements for ages, such a solution might be useful for the modern media, too.
________________________
But to go back to the start: If there’s one thing we don’t want to repeat, it’s Trump, or the AfD, or any other populists propelled to power through misinformation and propaganda.
- sidlls 10y agoPerhaps unintentional, but your examples are extremely biased. More than one politician has distorted reality and played fast and loose (to be charitable) with facts. Moreover, who checks the fact checkers? Politifact and other sites aren't unbiased themselves, after all, and we certainly have seen that the news media in America are easily manipulated (c.f. the tons of free media Trump gets and the collusion explicit in email dumps from the DNC hack). We don't have high quality, (mostly) neutral fact checkers in this country. That's a big contributing factor to the state of our current election, where the highest office is contested by a bigoted, stupid clown and a corrupt, deceitful and likely criminal woman, both of whom are likely to engage in terrible and aggressive foreign wars, while just about anything down-ticket of these two is ignored unless it intersects with the Presidential race or involves some completely irrelevant and salacious sex scandal.
- hackuser 10y ago> We don't have high quality, (mostly) neutral fact checkers in this country. I disagree. The leading news sources, including the NY Times, Washington Post, and others, do a very good job. In case you think the Times is biased, remember that they broke the Clinton email server story.
- thwarted 10y agoSo that if someone posts a Trump tweet on Facebook, in the preview it’d also display a short fact-check from both sides I don't even know what a partisan fact check is. If the intent is to fact check, there can't be multiple interpretations of it. A ranking of how truthful it is, which parts of a statement are accurately representing reality, like politifact's truth-o-meter, would be useful. Partisan fact checking is how you get things like "clean coal". Fact checking, however, is a fight against entropy. It is easier to lie or misrepresent, even inadvertently, than it is to be fully informed enough to be always say fully, 100% true statements. The liers are not lying for lying's sake, they have an agenda, and they'd just as soon tell the truth if it would serve their purposes.
- mzw_mzw 10y ago"Fact-checking" doesn't work, because now you've got a single exploitable point of failure. All your ideological cronies have to do is get control of the fact-checking department.