3 ms·
We need a single payer system or at the very least a single body that negotiates the price of all drugs and health care services on behalf of all Americans. Fra
by maxerickson 10y ago
We need a single payer system or at the very least a single body that negotiates the price of all drugs and health care services on behalf of all Americans. Frankly I'm surprised that the insurance companies aren't lobbying for such a thing as it could be their only hope for continued existence very soon.
What role do insurance companies have if there is a national body fixing prices?
- jefurii 10y agoLooks like not much of a role at all. After all of my experiences with insurance companies I'm quite okay with that. A NHS-style system would still need staff in order to function and I expect many rank-and-file insurance people would end up there. The executives can go to hell as far as I'm concerned.
- maxerickson 10y agoProviders also have a lot of staff dedicated to working with the insurance companies. I'm pretty sure billing complexity is one of the things driving consolidation of physicians into large practices and health systems.
- DiabloD3 10y agoNone. Which is America's end game: to end that apparent scam. This is why I actually had hope for the original draft of Obamacare: he straight up cloned the Netherlands system where insurance companies must insure x% of various classifications of sick people (cancer, AIDS, asthma, heart disease, overweight, etc), where x% approximates the national average... ... and they must spend ridiculous high levels of what they make on actual health care, AND the prices of health care are nationalized. In the end, they fight over sick people (have a rare sickness? insurance companies will give you a discount to get you, instead of trying to figure out how to lifetime ban you from insurance instead). And what happens if an insurance company can't get enough people to meet the strict guidelines? They're banned from selling insurance in the Netherlands until they do. This is essentially the original Obamacare, filtered through the American way of doing shit. What we got instead? Half of that, and maybe not even the good half. We got fucked.
- nlodnl 10y agoThey'd still be providing insurance. A national body negotiating pricing doesn't necessarily mean any or all forms of healthcare would be affordable.