13 ms·
The engineering community is sleeping on Snapchat, but shouldn't be. My life is AR. I'm the CEO for an AR company, I speak write and live and breathe all thing
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
The engineering community is sleeping on Snapchat, but shouldn't be.
My life is AR. I'm the CEO for an AR company, I speak write and live and breathe all things AR.
Snapchat is poised to be the most important AR company around for several reasons. 1. They have a MASSIVE userbase that is comfortable with sharing their lives 2. That userbase has already shown an interest in AR - and yes whether you like it or not their filters are on the AR spectrum - the filters system maps, tracks (SLAM) and modifies in real time.
Their Spectacles release has the potential to build the largest real world image dataset on the planet - something needed (for reasons I won't go into) for AR everywhere. Think on the order of 1.8 Billion images per month with depth data from the stereo cameras (30FPS * 10 sec snap * estimated 20 snaps per day * estimate 100k spectacles users in first month).
Most people have no clue what is going on in the AR world, and I can tell you Snapchat is going to be formidable. If they can invest in a VRD, then they could win the whole AR market, but they need to raise more than 4BN to do that probably.
- neosat 10y ago"Their Spectacles release has the potential to build the largest real world image dataset on the planet" With Google (and now Uber) cars driving around numerous places to capture data specifically for map imagery, satellite imagery and Android/iOS phones taking tons of photos + videos I highly doubt Snap will be the one to build the world's largest image dataset. The rest of your argument makes sense though.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWith only 100k users they would generate approximately 9BN images per month (30FPS min, 10sec Snaps, average 10 snaps per day). With 1M users of spectacles (.6% of their current MAU), that's potentially 90BN images per month and over a trillion per year. In the same dataset. Machine vision wet dream.
- icelancer 10y agoThere is no way the average user is shooting full 10s snaps 10x day. I use Snapchat regularly and that describes the top eschelon of users, which might be Spectacles users, but probably not all of them. I believe that is a vast overestimate.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoAs with most statistics it's likely normally distributed. I know teens send/receive in the hundreds per day - mind boggling really - and the celeb accounts post dozens daily. Even back in 2013 the numbers were staggering. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/how-many-snaps-snapchat-users-get-2013-11 http://www.businessinsider.com/how-many-snaps-snapchat-users...
- loeber 10y agoNitpick: I would strongly expect that the number of snaps sent/received per day is exponentially distributed over the space of users, not normally.
- boomzilla 10y agoAnd how will they make money? Selling ads in the AR world?
- mahyarm 10y agohttps://www.spectacles.com/ https://www.spectacles.com/
- josho 10y agoAm I the only one bothered by the fact that their models are topless? I can't help but feel they are signalling their intent to be an eye into my private life, not unlike the monitoring predicted in 1984.
- brianwawok 10y agoJust you
- nstj 10y agoThey could be wearing tops with no shoulders...
- reneherse 10y agoMy intuition is that these will be a hit. Simple, fun, youthful & on trend, not fussy to charge, huge captive userbase to sell to. Can you turn them around and use the mirrored lenses to take a selfie? Snap probably has a winner here if their users will further embrace the idea of turning cameras away from their faces and onto their friends and experiences. How big an "if" that is, I can't yet say.
- estefan 10y agoI think they're too trendy looking. They'll be fine for a season/uni semester, but after that will drop out of fashion. And they'll be too pricey for their core demographic to keep buying new ones.
- 10y ago
- flanbiscuit 10y agoTheir spectacles is going to be a game changer. I hope it does well (buy also part of me hopes it does not for the sake of everyone's privacy in public). https://www.spectacles.com/ https://www.spectacles.com/
- yolesaber 10y agoNo, they are not. It's gonna be another gimmick lifestyle tech product that gets trumped up in the press and then no one cares about. They are glasses that only take ten seconds video and can only post it to snapchat. And they cost $130. Come on.
- cryptoz 10y agoNo WiFi. Less space than a nomad. Lame.
- yolesaber 10y agoLol people post this everytime someone critiques a hyped up new bullshit tech product. Guess what, the vast majority of them fail. Spectacles is not the iPod. It's going to flop, I stand by it.
- cryptoz 10y agoYour analysis that it is a "gimmick", "bullshit", and "hyped up" is over-simplified and, I think, wrong. There's no need to swear or be mean about this. Some people, myself included (I hate hate hate hate the snapchat app, I'm not able to use it and I can't stand the idea of it) think that Snap does understand product and its market, and has incredible visions for the future with an ability to execute. I think that Snap will be a huge success for a long time to come. Naysaying Snap is fine, but not if your argument is "bullshit hype".
- cgriswald 10y agoHis argument was cost and lack of utility...
- tnecniv 10y agoTheir filters do SLAM?
- rawnlq 10y agoNot in the robotics sense where you map out a hallway of a building or something. But it does map facial landmarks very well (and I suppose that will also give you localization relative to the face).
- hokkos 10y agoNo, it does face recognition and orientation, it's far simpler than slam and have nothing to do with it.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYes, but a narrower interpretation than used in more robust systems like those that we built. They don't need an entire SLAM system with loop closure and relocalization because you can mimic those with the simple facial recognition portions. However they added orientation functionality but without visual odometry. Functionally it works the same, and is the easiest way to describe it.
- sedachv 10y ago> Their Spectacles release has the potential to build the largest real world image dataset on the planet - something needed (for reasons I won't go into) for AR everywhere. This is hn, please explain the reasons. Otherwise your post sounds like Donald Trump - "They have AR. They have the best AR!"
- apsec112 10y ago"Please avoid introducing classic flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say about them." (I'd also like to know more details, but bringing up Trump can only lead to doom)
- erobbins 10y agoThey are not the only player, but they probably have the most accepting user base. They don't have the largest user base amongst the AR players though.
- AndrewKemendo 10y ago*they don't have the larger user base amongst AR players though" Yes they do, by far. The next biggest pure AR player (by mau) is arguably blippar with about 8M. Metaio had a larger install base across all products, but they are gone. I guess if you count Google translate they would eclipse test in their but I don't know how many people are using word view translate implementation. I don't consider Pokemon go a pure AR play and even then their at numbers are hard to come by as a significant population used it without AR
- komali2 10y agoDon't leave us hanging like that - who in the AR world has the largest user base?
- user5994461 10y agoWhat is AR?
- adamt 10y agoaugmented reality. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Augmented_reality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Augmented_reality
- increment_i 10y agoI'm inclined to agree. I was very bearish on Snapchat around the time they rejected the Facebook offer. But more than any other app right now, Snapchat is killing it with users. This is a what a product users love looks like. On top of that, I've been consistently impressed with their technological prowess, even if the AR component seems somewhat inconsequential to me right now. You better believe Snapchat is gunning for that top spot in social - that's what the IPO is about. If they're at or surpassed Facebook's level by 2020, I seriously would not be surprised.
- argonaut 10y agoI'm bullish too, but any comparisons to Facebook are lazy. Snapchat and Facebook are completely orthogonal (the closer competition is Instagram, owned by FB, and Snapchat, but even then I would argue it is lazy to say they are direct competitors, ignoring the Instagram Stories product). For better or worse Facebook is a piece of social infrastructure and utility. Everyone has Facebook. All the groups I know of are organized through Facebook. All of the events. And so on.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoYes but money is made through eyeballs and not infrastructure. The most money will go to the app that gets the most viewing.
- Disruptive_Dave 10y ago> The most money will go to the app that gets the most viewing. ...and figures out how to draw consistent revenue from that. Snapchat is making $365m this year in revenue, projecting $1b next year, and has a newly launched ads API.
- kevinmannix 10y agoCompletely anecdotal, but my siblings and cousins that are teens don't have Facebook, and most of their classmates don't either. It's weird to imagine a world where not everyone has Facebook, but I don't think it's as ubiquitous for those who grew up where alternatives existed, such as Snapchat and Instagram (even Twitter as well).
- bogomipz 10y agoCan you elaborate a bit on how they use SLAM? I was my (mis?)understanding that SLAM required a pre-existing map. If this is true what are the source of the maps? Are the maps built from previous users's snaps?
- mcintyre1994 10y agoIs the reason AR benefits from billions of photos of the real world a secret, or is there something you can point to to read about that? I'm intrigued :) Also, you probably know better than me, but to me it looks like the beauty filters are the ones that have really stuck for Snapchat. If I'm right and their users only really care about filters that make them look better, does that affect your outlook at all regarding their users showing an interest in AR?
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThe simple answer is that you can make very large 3D maps with those images. I disagree with your second assumption, though I can see where it comes from. It's not so much the specific implementation, beauty or whimsy, but rather that people will take the action of modifying their real time view consistently.
- simooooo 10y agoYou're trying to convince yourself very hard, as you're all about AR. But nobody will wear those dumb glasses.
- jdavis703 10y agoAnd nobody would carry Palm Pilot PDAs. Well they didn't wind up carrying them from Palm, but Apple and Samsung sure have something awfully close. Snap may or may not be the AR disruptor, but AR will be the new smartphone. Whoever owns it will be the new Apple.
- 205guy 10y agoBut before Palm Pilots, there was the Newton so loved by techies, just like Glass. So snap may end up the palm pilot or one of the dozen PDA knockoffs that were around (I seem to remember some Microsoft ones too). It seems like concepts float around in several iterations, or as many as it takes, until someone hits the sweet spot. I'm not really knowledgeable about the "wearable" market, but to me it doesn't seem as ubiquitous as the smart phone.
- beambot 10y agoFamous last words. Reminds me of the old adage: "640k of memory is all that anybody with a computer would ever need." I already know a lot of younger folks that are pumped about the Snapchat glasses... (I'm not saying you're wrong... I just wouldn't make such steadfast predictions about the future either. But then again, I don't understand SnapChat and am not their target audience.)
- untog 10y agoYou can trot out that 640k comment to sell any piece of technology, it doesn't make it true. I could have said the same about Google Glass.
- beambot 10y agoIndeed you could. And sometimes you'd be right; other times you'd be dead wrong. If you could be right even half the time, you'd be rich as all get out. Which is why I would suggest: Don't make overreaching bold predictions (or become an investor).
- adamweld 10y agoThere is only one camera on the Spectacles. No stereo.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYou appear to be right. For some reason I thought I saw a stereo version. Missed opportunity there in that case. I still stand by my assertion though - as you don't need stereo for depth but it does make it faster and more robustly recovered.
- duaneb 10y agoSounds like twitter: interesting, perhaps the future, but not a business worth investment. How can they succeed where twitter failed? The ads have ruined the app. Everyone I know who uses it agrees it performs terribly and is extremely difficult to avoid unwanted, irrelevant ads. Again: it's twitter.
- maruhan2 10y agoIt's a better case than twitter though. There is no obvious way of monetizing twitter, while there are many ways that I can think of that snapchat can monetized. For example, Line and Kakao have massively succeeded with their sticker/character business, and snapchat could bring something similar. There are many other ways I can list. So, the issue is not "What are possible methods of monetization?" but "How do I optimize profit?" This is definitely a more favorable setting than twitter.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sysexit 10y agoSo 4B for a selling stickers business model?
- rufb 10y agoKakao's business model history is actually rather fascinating, and they keep grabbing sizeable market shares in unlikely or previously inexpressive markets to great success. > In 2012, KakaoTalk's $42 million revenue is broken down to 67.5% ($31.1M) gaming, 26.2% ($12.1M) advertising, and 6.3% ($2.8M) emoticon sales. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KakaoTalk#Company_Business_Model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KakaoTalk#Company_Business_Mod...
- sanowski 10y ago$200MM rev is crumbs when you're taking billions. I don't think this provides a good example of how it can work.
- taf2 10y agoSorry... I tried googling this but what is AR?
- WhitneyLand 10y agoAndrew I think you're too optimistic about spectacles given no one has even proven it's a viable market, let alone that Snapchat will have a successful implementation. What's your best guess of how many pair will sell through to actual customers?
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoAt a minimum 100k, which is enough to start proving the market out and getting some virtuous cycles building.
- wslh 10y agoBut don't you think that because AR is just starting to have a place in our mobile phones it is open to a lot of newcomers? This is not a mature market sector like social networks, ads, or search.
- Taek 10y agoYet another example of a massive amount of user collected and provided data that is only available to one company. I wish that there were more open data laws. A lot of startups would benefit from having the data volumes that more massive companies have.
- henrygrew 10y agowhat does AR, SLAM, and VRD stand for?
- thesehands 10y agoAR: Augmented Reality SLAM: Simultaneous Localisation and Mapping VRD: Virtual Retinal Display
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- haywirez 10y agoI used to love Snapchat, it felt like the future of communication in many ways. Unfortunately it seems that their Android app became completely unusable on mid-tier devices in the past year. Painfully slow UX and unreliable in most situations. Wish they'd do something about this as it forced me to abandon the platform entirely.