3 ms·
> Until there is an element of randomness fueled by context, they aren't creating anything new. A neural net has plenty of randomness (which shouldn't be conf
by gwern 10y ago
> Until there is an element of randomness fueled by context, they aren't creating anything new.
A neural net has plenty of randomness (which shouldn't be confused with nondeterminism) inside it, right from the start with its randomly initialized weights & biases; no two trained style networks will be exactly alike and produce exactly the same output unless one takes major trouble to do so.
Any artist (or writer) has had the experience of people finding meaning and depth in their creations which they had no idea about, and may have thought one of their worser works. This can reflect unconscious work, of course, but it also reflects that the artistic process is as much about throwing random things at the wall to see what sticks and triggers an intuitive reaction in other people that 'hey that's good!'. One may have fail hundreds of times before getting a hit. Rarely does one sit down and think 'I am going to write an intricate story about dying in Venice with such and such symbolism, a buildup to the ending, and referencing these specific past authors', write it out in full in 1 pass without revision, decide it's good, and have everyone else agree. Art is as much about about editing, curation, and recognition as it is about planning. A neural net could create great works of art without any planning or intention of doing so, if the right person sees it and selects it out of the vast stream of images the net will generate.